3.63 AVERAGE

bfrodermann's profile picture

bfrodermann's review

5.0

This book was great to talk to my daughter about women, herbs, and midwifery during medieval England.

This Newbery winner from ages ago is still worth a read. Strong voice and amazing character arc make it a timeless story of a girl learning to never give up.

I read this a lot when I was younger, I really like the descriptive 'how to'-ish parts. This is actually a lot shorter than I remember. I was there was more story and it felt less clumsy but over all I enjoyed it.

This short fairy tale like story is just the right mix of bitter and sweet. I read it slowly because it is a short book and I didn't want it to end.

Umm. Maybe this is a Young Adult book. But it is not a children's book regardless of the Newbery Award. As usually you probably should read most things before you hand them over to the under 10 crowd.

It is a well researched look at the life of a a medieval midwife.

I can see why this book won awards. I wish I'd found it years ago, I would have read it to the boys.

kmc3050's review

3.0

3. I am not sure who the intended audience is, but I liked it.

kathrun006's review

4.0
hopeful inspiring lighthearted sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

This book is suitable for children ages 11 and up, but I'm 23 and I enjoyed it a lot. It's set in midevil England and is about a homeless girl who doesn't even have a name and has to sleep in a compost pile because it's the only warm place where she won't rejected. The story is about how she gets taken in by a midwife to be her apprentice. Its heartwarming to watch her situation and outlook on life improve as she learns this skill.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
alisoun's profile picture

alisoun's review

5.0
reflective

stenaros's review

3.0

I appreciate Cushman's commitment to all the characters being horrible to Alyce. She's also great at weaving in period details without devolving into lecture.