Scan barcode
readingspells's review against another edition
challenging
dark
informative
medium-paced
4.0
I can totally see why this was nominated for the Women's Prize for Non-fiction. It is a powerful and immersive memoir about Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Race, Identity and flat landscapes.
I really wasn't sure what to expect with this book and even now I have read it (listened to it) I find it hard to explain it. It is deeply personal and intense work, that picks apart these subjects and how healing or at least some sort of connection and love can be found in places and also in objects. Oh and animals too, the parts about her cat really resonated with me too. That odd bond and connection with a pet that can be hard to explain to someone who has not experienced it.
The authors raw and brutal words about racism in the UK were really powerful. Her stripping away of the fantasy of colonialism for the reality of it's damage and violence and how that lingers in modern Briton today made me yet again realise that our failure to teach the realities of this in schools is a woeful thing.
I don't think this book deserves to win the Women's prize, I still believe that should be Doppelganger but it definitely deserves its place on the short list and I highly recommend it.
"Britain lives in terrible denial, I know now, of a history it can’t admit to. And it survives that denial by indicating to people of colour, very subtly, very passively, that they shouldn’t think of themselves as real. Because if no one real was hurt, then no real harm has been done.”
― Noreen Masud
I really wasn't sure what to expect with this book and even now I have read it (listened to it) I find it hard to explain it. It is deeply personal and intense work, that picks apart these subjects and how healing or at least some sort of connection and love can be found in places and also in objects. Oh and animals too, the parts about her cat really resonated with me too. That odd bond and connection with a pet that can be hard to explain to someone who has not experienced it.
The authors raw and brutal words about racism in the UK were really powerful. Her stripping away of the fantasy of colonialism for the reality of it's damage and violence and how that lingers in modern Briton today made me yet again realise that our failure to teach the realities of this in schools is a woeful thing.
I don't think this book deserves to win the Women's prize, I still believe that should be Doppelganger but it definitely deserves its place on the short list and I highly recommend it.
"Britain lives in terrible denial, I know now, of a history it can’t admit to. And it survives that denial by indicating to people of colour, very subtly, very passively, that they shouldn’t think of themselves as real. Because if no one real was hurt, then no real harm has been done.”
― Noreen Masud
sarahwiltshire's review against another edition
challenging
emotional
hopeful
informative
inspiring
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
4.75
I will need to re-read to fully absorb all that I have read. Through the journeys Noreen Masud describes, inhabits and what she reveals to us about her cPTSD, we learn so much more about racism, colonialism and how we as humans connect and impact the natural world.
howtobebooks's review against another edition
emotional
reflective
medium-paced
5.0
📚 A Flat Place by Noreen Masud on trauma and its link to land - review
The flat landscapes metaphorically represent the erasure of history and personal trauma, much like the draining of the fens removed the natural history and biodiversity.
“A Flat Place” by Noreen Masud illustrates her multifaceted connection to flat landscapes —serving not only as a reflection of her emotional numbness and derealisation but also as a symbol of the enduring, unchangeable impact of her traumatic past.
Read the full review / Link in bio.
https://howtobe247.com/a-flat-place-by-noreen-masud-on-trauma-and-its-link-to-land-review/
bookswithboo's review against another edition
challenging
emotional
informative
reflective
medium-paced
4.25