Reviews

Lucia and the Light by Phyllis Root, Mary GrandPré

rampaginglibrarian's review

Go to review page

5.0

curses on those children's librarians and their picture book displays
because i stumble across so many lovely books like Lucia and the Light by Phyllis Root (illustrated by the most talented Mary Grandpré) that i then simply must possess!
Lucia and the Light is inspired by Nordic lore and is set in the mountains of the Far North (and of course the cold, cold, dark, dark winter) which is made even darker and colder by the fact that the sun has gone away. Lucia can stand it no more and decides she will go in search of the sun though her grandmother warns of trolls.
When she opens the door to leave, her loyal (i stress this word, because yes, it is possible for creatures of the feline persuasion to possess this trait) and beautiful milk-white cat "jumped from the windowsill into her hood and went out into the swirling snow with her. Lucia was glad for the company and the warmth of the milk-white cat around her neck."
Lucia laboriously skied her way up the mountain and met the inevitable trolls who threatened to eat her up. But the beautiful and brave milk-white cat saves the day in the end. to learn how you must (absolutely must) pick up this enticing and oh-so-alluring book for yourself!

barbarianlibarian's review

Go to review page

4.0

this was long but really well done, a-typical fairy tale

coldinaugust's review

Go to review page

4.0

The oil pastel illustrations were gorgeous. Similar to the other Phyllis Root story I read, the illustrations were definitely the better part of the book.

As for the story itself, it was almost a 5-star book. The heroine of this folk talk is Lucia, who lives with her mother and baby brother & their cow and cat in the Far North. One day, the sun stops rising and life goes from difficult to unbearable. Lucia decides that she is going to climb the mountains near her house to find the sun and bring back the Light.

Although Lucia is very brave and clever, it is ultimately her cat who finds the sun. And while I probably love cats more than the average reader, I was disappointed that it wasn't the young female protagonist, a minority in children's folk tales anyway, who actually saves the day--instead it is a nameless animal who decides to go with her on its own. Maybe it adds a little realism to the story, showing how sometimes despite one's best-laid plans and cleverness, the win actually comes by accident, through Grace. Still, it was disappointing enough to keep me from completely enjoying the story.
More...