Scan barcode
aceinit's review
3.0
This is one of those novels where the world building and the characters are much more interesting than the story. The plot was, to me anyway, barely there at best and was more a game of “let’s see how many times we can abduct the characters” (answer: a LOT), than an actual story progression.
As for the world-building, it’s pretty intense. Start with the basis of the holy wars between Islam and Judasim and escalate it to an all-encompassing borderline-apocalypse between the two central nations, thrust it onto a desert planet where magic and technology is fueled by bugs, where vehicles are partially organic, and where shifters intermingle with the population. Add mandatory drafts, forced breeding grounds, an all-female bounty hunter squad and meddling offworlders. Then make each of the two central characters from opposite sides of that war, working together as part of a mercenary team.
The complicated relationship between disgraced bel dame (bountry hunter) Nyx and the fugitive magician Rhys is what kept me reading this book even amid the weak, often haphazard plot. Where as most “complicated’ literary relationships really aren’t once you start looking at them, there is enough love and resentment bound up between the two of them to keep the story going even when it flounders. And it was fascinating to read the interactions between Nyx and her crew, given the vast differences in nationalities, world views and backgrounds that are spread between them. These interactions are what gives the novel its strengths, and what helps breathe life to the world Hurley has created.
Book two should be an interesting ride.
As for the world-building, it’s pretty intense. Start with the basis of the holy wars between Islam and Judasim and escalate it to an all-encompassing borderline-apocalypse between the two central nations, thrust it onto a desert planet where magic and technology is fueled by bugs, where vehicles are partially organic, and where shifters intermingle with the population. Add mandatory drafts, forced breeding grounds, an all-female bounty hunter squad and meddling offworlders. Then make each of the two central characters from opposite sides of that war, working together as part of a mercenary team.
The complicated relationship between disgraced bel dame (bountry hunter) Nyx and the fugitive magician Rhys is what kept me reading this book even amid the weak, often haphazard plot. Where as most “complicated’ literary relationships really aren’t once you start looking at them, there is enough love and resentment bound up between the two of them to keep the story going even when it flounders. And it was fascinating to read the interactions between Nyx and her crew, given the vast differences in nationalities, world views and backgrounds that are spread between them. These interactions are what gives the novel its strengths, and what helps breathe life to the world Hurley has created.
Book two should be an interesting ride.
songwind's review against another edition
3.0
My feelings on this book are complicated.
The text is better crafted than the story, and the world building is better than either. Usually this is a formula for a bad book, but for God's War that's not the case.
The characters are nicely done, each with conflicting desires, loyalties and dreams. The complicated web of interpersonal relationships adds another dimension of complexity.
The world of Umayma is similarly richly imagined. Most of the world that we see is a blasted desert. The planet is home to a large variety of insect life, and these insects are the base of much of the planet's technology. It's not clear if they are indigenous, transplanted, artificial, or a combination. "Magicians" are humans that are born with the ability to control the insects, making them valuable as doctors, technicians, and the like.
Umayma is populated by "people of the Book," the Islamic catch-all for the various Yahweh religions - Jews, Christians and Muslims. They are never named as such, but are identifiable from context. The religions and associated cultures are familiar to the modern reader, but also slightly alien and the pressures of time have altered them to one degree or another. The two countries where the story takes place are "Muslim."
Against this bleak but compelling backdrop, we have the story of Nyx. She is a bel dame who hunts deserters from the front of the ancient war between Nasheen and Chenja. She also takes "black work" on the side, picking up extra money through bounty hunting and black market courier work.
Nyx's motivations and those of her associates tend toward the small, short sighted and banal. Most of the characters are unlikable. Though the plot touches on important events, the protagonists get involved for entirely selfish reasons, and persist in the face of clear ignorance of the importance and effects of their actions.
God's War is a decent story, bolstered by great world building but hampered by an unlikable cast of characters.
The text is better crafted than the story, and the world building is better than either. Usually this is a formula for a bad book, but for God's War that's not the case.
The characters are nicely done, each with conflicting desires, loyalties and dreams. The complicated web of interpersonal relationships adds another dimension of complexity.
The world of Umayma is similarly richly imagined. Most of the world that we see is a blasted desert. The planet is home to a large variety of insect life, and these insects are the base of much of the planet's technology. It's not clear if they are indigenous, transplanted, artificial, or a combination. "Magicians" are humans that are born with the ability to control the insects, making them valuable as doctors, technicians, and the like.
Umayma is populated by "people of the Book," the Islamic catch-all for the various Yahweh religions - Jews, Christians and Muslims. They are never named as such, but are identifiable from context. The religions and associated cultures are familiar to the modern reader, but also slightly alien and the pressures of time have altered them to one degree or another. The two countries where the story takes place are "Muslim."
Against this bleak but compelling backdrop, we have the story of Nyx. She is a bel dame who hunts deserters from the front of the ancient war between Nasheen and Chenja. She also takes "black work" on the side, picking up extra money through bounty hunting and black market courier work.
Nyx's motivations and those of her associates tend toward the small, short sighted and banal. Most of the characters are unlikable. Though the plot touches on important events, the protagonists get involved for entirely selfish reasons, and persist in the face of clear ignorance of the importance and effects of their actions.
God's War is a decent story, bolstered by great world building but hampered by an unlikable cast of characters.
lsparrow's review
4.0
I enjoyed the sf world that came out of Islamic tradition in this book.
wanted the story to keep going.
wanted the story to keep going.
tricapra's review
4.0
I always struggle with the first 10% of Kameron Hurley books, then as soon as I get my bearings I absolutely love them. I love her obsession with gross bug-based technology. The world building in this one was fantastic, and if her goal was to create a female version of a rough around the edges 80s antihero, she succeeded. (it was, she states that in Geek Feminist Revolution)
I didn't realize how much I'd come to care for Nyx and her team until I was sitting in my car, long after I'd reached my destination, just to hear (and process) what happened when one of them was taken. If that's not praise for a book, I don't know what is.
I didn't realize how much I'd come to care for Nyx and her team until I was sitting in my car, long after I'd reached my destination, just to hear (and process) what happened when one of them was taken. If that's not praise for a book, I don't know what is.
spikeanderson1's review
1.0
There are jewels in here, but then just when I think I'm with it, it loses me. Really hard to follow. Choppy. Cyber punk with inexplicable blackouts. I could not finish it
sporter's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
dsleyba's review
adventurous
dark
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
maxines_obsessions's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
hollybg's review
4.0
Bugged Out
Woman who's so tough she took one look at The Expendables and pissed herself laughing? Check. Mysteriously robed dude with his little creepy crawly friends? Check. Plus the dismembered head and gorgeously tiled background make this a double cover win for being both beautiful and specifically relevant to the story. Extra special bonus points for featuring dark skinned protagonists (because, you know, the characters are dark it would be nonsensical to have white people on the cover, they may as well have a picture of a roller coster) especially considering the picture they nearly ended up with.
The Angry Angry Caterpillar
On a desert planet with multiple suns, two powerful countries, the heavily religious Chenja and the 'ungodly' Nasheen, have all but wiped out each other's menfolk fighting their centuries old holy war. Nyx is trying to scrape out a living in Nasheen, a country now run by women while all the men are sent to the front to fight. After losing her coveted position as a Bel Dame assassin and finishing a prison sentence, she runs a small bounty hunting service with the help of her rag tag crew featuring a shapeshifter, a teenage weapons expert and her subpar magician Rhys, a man capable of controlling the ubiquitous energy all their technology runs on. Bugs.
Accepting a suspiciously well paid mission for the Nasheen Queen, Nyx is trailing a missing off worlder who claims to possess the power to finally end the war. But in which side's favour?
Entomology 101
What an incredible world Ms Hurley has created here! We've all seen desert based worlds before in sci fi and fantasy, they can be (ironically) rather fertile settings for writers to explore, although too often you are left with a Dune or Firefly taste in your brain. What I enjoyed about God's War was the way she completely embraced this arid environment as her world, and then fully mapped out of all the problems it would cause with things like travel, health and food and how civilizations would adapt to these difficulties. No hermetically sealed underground cities or widely available flying machines here. Here people deal with the deadly environment with nothing but the basics. They develop cancers as easily as we grow our nails, with a war-zone choking on deadly gases clean organs are freely traded for cash and male children are smuggled across neutral borders to save them from a lifetime fighting at the front. Weirdly it seems so alien and at the same time familiarly human.
Personally, my favorite part of this world was the technology. Everything on this planet, from weapons to cars to radios, is run using bugs. Creepy crawlies spill out of exhaust pipes on organically run cars and seal up wounds. They can be controlled to varying degrees by the magicians, men and women born with this ability that sets them apart and, they seem to think, above everyone else. Nyx's magician, Rhys, is not exceptionally gifted but as a devoutly religious Chejan man in very prejudiced Nasheen, he's got little option but to stay with Nyx and aid her on any mercenary work she picks up. Regardless of how much he may disapprove of the work and, especially, the woman herself.
Nyx is a deeply complex character and I loved her complete honesty in everything she did, even when telling an outright lie. It's fair to say she's not your average 'kick ass heroine' (which is a good thing, no tight trousers and an alpha male for her) she's barely even heroic, except maybe in her ability to withstand punishment. Nyx deals with all types of pain in this book and it gets pretty graphic at points, but then I love those stories where the protagonist spends most of the book just barely surviving and trying to pull bits of themselves back together, so it wasn't a problem for me (see also the brilliant Samuil Petrovich by Simon Morden). Her former Bel Dame sisters made for incredibly effective villains, they are ruthless in their pursuit of Nyx and her crew and I found myself truly believing that they wouldn't stand a chance against the trained assassins.
God's War is a beautifully scenic story about violence and desperation on a planet that's learned to live around the constant every day horrors of war. It's characters are flawed and imperfect but lovable, and the reluctance to admit trust between Nyx and Rhys was just so much more satisfying to read then the usual pinned on romance that a lesser writer would have shoe horned in here. The next installment, Infidel, is out next month so now is the perfect time to pick this diamond up.
Woman who's so tough she took one look at The Expendables and pissed herself laughing? Check. Mysteriously robed dude with his little creepy crawly friends? Check. Plus the dismembered head and gorgeously tiled background make this a double cover win for being both beautiful and specifically relevant to the story. Extra special bonus points for featuring dark skinned protagonists (because, you know, the characters are dark it would be nonsensical to have white people on the cover, they may as well have a picture of a roller coster) especially considering the picture they nearly ended up with.
The Angry Angry Caterpillar
On a desert planet with multiple suns, two powerful countries, the heavily religious Chenja and the 'ungodly' Nasheen, have all but wiped out each other's menfolk fighting their centuries old holy war. Nyx is trying to scrape out a living in Nasheen, a country now run by women while all the men are sent to the front to fight. After losing her coveted position as a Bel Dame assassin and finishing a prison sentence, she runs a small bounty hunting service with the help of her rag tag crew featuring a shapeshifter, a teenage weapons expert and her subpar magician Rhys, a man capable of controlling the ubiquitous energy all their technology runs on. Bugs.
Accepting a suspiciously well paid mission for the Nasheen Queen, Nyx is trailing a missing off worlder who claims to possess the power to finally end the war. But in which side's favour?
Entomology 101
What an incredible world Ms Hurley has created here! We've all seen desert based worlds before in sci fi and fantasy, they can be (ironically) rather fertile settings for writers to explore, although too often you are left with a Dune or Firefly taste in your brain. What I enjoyed about God's War was the way she completely embraced this arid environment as her world, and then fully mapped out of all the problems it would cause with things like travel, health and food and how civilizations would adapt to these difficulties. No hermetically sealed underground cities or widely available flying machines here. Here people deal with the deadly environment with nothing but the basics. They develop cancers as easily as we grow our nails, with a war-zone choking on deadly gases clean organs are freely traded for cash and male children are smuggled across neutral borders to save them from a lifetime fighting at the front. Weirdly it seems so alien and at the same time familiarly human.
Personally, my favorite part of this world was the technology. Everything on this planet, from weapons to cars to radios, is run using bugs. Creepy crawlies spill out of exhaust pipes on organically run cars and seal up wounds. They can be controlled to varying degrees by the magicians, men and women born with this ability that sets them apart and, they seem to think, above everyone else. Nyx's magician, Rhys, is not exceptionally gifted but as a devoutly religious Chejan man in very prejudiced Nasheen, he's got little option but to stay with Nyx and aid her on any mercenary work she picks up. Regardless of how much he may disapprove of the work and, especially, the woman herself.
"Nyx sold her womb somewhere between Punjai and Faleen, on the edge of the desert. Drunk, but no longer bleeding, she pushed into a smoky cantina just after dark and ordered a pinch of morphine and a whiskey chaser. She bet all of her money on a boxer named Jaks, and lost it two rounds later when Jaks hit the floor like an antique harem girl.
Nyx lost every coin, a wad of opium and the wine she'd gotten from the butchers as a bonus for her womb. But she did get Jaks into bed, and - loser or not - in the desert after dark, that was something.
"What are you after?" Jaks murmired in her good ear. They lay tangled in the sheets like old lovers: a losing boxer with a poor right hook and a tendency to drop her left, and a wombless hunter bereft of money, weapons, food and most her clothing.
"I'm looking for my sister," Nyx said. It was partly the truth. She was looking for something else too, something worth a lot more, and Jaks was going to help her get it."
Nyx is a deeply complex character and I loved her complete honesty in everything she did, even when telling an outright lie. It's fair to say she's not your average 'kick ass heroine' (which is a good thing, no tight trousers and an alpha male for her) she's barely even heroic, except maybe in her ability to withstand punishment. Nyx deals with all types of pain in this book and it gets pretty graphic at points, but then I love those stories where the protagonist spends most of the book just barely surviving and trying to pull bits of themselves back together, so it wasn't a problem for me (see also the brilliant Samuil Petrovich by Simon Morden). Her former Bel Dame sisters made for incredibly effective villains, they are ruthless in their pursuit of Nyx and her crew and I found myself truly believing that they wouldn't stand a chance against the trained assassins.
God's War is a beautifully scenic story about violence and desperation on a planet that's learned to live around the constant every day horrors of war. It's characters are flawed and imperfect but lovable, and the reluctance to admit trust between Nyx and Rhys was just so much more satisfying to read then the usual pinned on romance that a lesser writer would have shoe horned in here. The next installment, Infidel, is out next month so now is the perfect time to pick this diamond up.