Reviews

Mr. Dickens and His Carol by Samantha Silva

valmeac's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Festive, fun to read around Christmas. I kept thinking I was close to then ending and then there was a lot more left in the book.

the_schaef's review

Go to review page

4.0

A very pleasant tale

A great read in the prelude to Christmas to help us remember that the perspective we choose is how we will see our environment. Sometimes we are fortunate enough to have people around us to help us see this perspective in a better light.

lpeterson's review

Go to review page

adventurous emotional hopeful reflective medium-paced

4.0

sara_toone's review

Go to review page

3.0

3.5 stars. This was just okay. Adding a half a star because I really liked the ending.

alyssajcori's review

Go to review page

2.0

As a fan of Charles Dickens I was excited to read this novel and get someone else’s take on his world. You can move through this book quickly and I’d definitely recommend reading it around Christmas time to get in the spirt. I wasn’t blown away with the writing or the creative take on Dickens’ inspiration, so I’d say you only need to read this one if you’re feeling like a Scrooge around Christmas and want to change that.

kathleenguthriewoods's review

Go to review page

5.0

A friend gave this to me. Wasn’t sure what to expect, but saved it till late in the year since it seemed to be a Christmassy story. I enjoyed it. It’s clever and charming. The author utilizes a style of writing similar to Dickens’ own and has fun imagining the characters who might have crossed his path in real life–and ended up as characters in his books. Definitely makes me want to re-read "A Christmas Carol".

allistoria's review

Go to review page

Didn’t like the affair aspect of the book 

jena_33's review

Go to review page

challenging dark informative mysterious tense slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

mellhay's review

Go to review page

5.0

Samantha has taken an old tale and sprinkled it into the life of the original creator, creating a new story of her own with links to the original story and history drizzled in for our enjoyment. Samantha touched on emotions in me. There were a few places that I smiled, but she did have me tear up as well. It was toward the end and with Timothy, of course. But it was the moment that felt right, like Charles was starting to make that last turn to himself again and even feeling better about himself. Then, in the end, I did cry. Such a great moment to be brought to.

****FULL REVIEW****
*I was given this free review copy audiobook at my request and have voluntarily left this review.

A November warm day, Charles Dickens is lost in writing his next adventure for Chuzzlewit. However, his publishers show up. Chuzzlewit is not selling and they have an idea. They "suggest" Charles writes a short Christmas book. With a ghost. And it's scheduled to be read on Christmas Eve. Charles doesn't like the idea, but finds his family has become use to a style of living and he likes to make donations so in order to continue with life as they know it he'll have to write the Christmas book he doesn't want to write. His feeling of the book idea seeps through into his life and he'll have an eye opening season.

I've never listened to Euan Morton until now. I found I enjoyed his proper sound and accent from the beginning. It fit for the time setting and people present in the book. I felt as though I was sitting, drawn to his voice, listening to him tell me a Christmas story. Euan also gets to voice parts of Christmas Carol at the end as well. So well done with all the voices. Euan has the tone that fits a Christmas story, perfectly.

I adore Charles's interaction with his kids and wife. There is so much love there, and they have fun. But Charles always wants to give them everything, which helps drive home that his chapters for his current adventure isn't doing as well. This is what starts to drive a wedge between him and his family.

As Charles lives his life, after learning he will lose money if he doesn't do the Christmas book, you see sparks of what influences A Christmas Carol. He tries to teach his children there is more to Christmas than toys, in a means to try to "cut back". It doesn't go well, but there is truth in his words and a hint of what will come in his book he'll ultimately end up writing. I understand Charles's worries over income. He's seeing how his family lives and his attempts to "cut back" are squashed at every try. Though, in his families defense, they didn't know what he was trying to do or why. So, he decides to write the Christmas book.

Charles seems to struggle to find his own way through Christmas. He grows frustrated by the threat of losing income, and that his family has grown to love spending so much (they don't realize it). He tries to point out others and needs at this time of year, but it goes unnoticed or acknowledged. He wants his kids to see more in the holiday than what they get. Charles starts to lose his way and the feel of the holiday while frustrated with events around him. Charles goes looking for his muse to get through. This book is Charles living his own Christmas Carol, while crossing flashes of the story to come.

Samantha has taken an old tale and sprinkled it into the life of the original creator, creating a new story of her own with links to the original story. There is also history drizzled in for our enjoyment. Samantha touched on emotions in me. There were a few places that I smiled, but she did have me tear up as well. It was toward the end and with Timothy, of course. But it was the moment that felt right, like Charles was starting to make that last turn to himself again and even feeling better about himself. Then, in the end, I did cry. Such a great moment to be brought to.

This book felt true to the characters present and was a wonderful Christmas Carol rendition to highlight Charles Dickens. Wonderful story.

redrobot's review

Go to review page

4.0

Dear Reader,
If you are optimistic, and in need of re-charging, this book is a delightful blessing to lift you up! If you are jaded, pretend that you are open to having your heart lifted, and this is the book that will do it! I loved this in so many ways, at least once because I am entranced, of late, with "A Christmas Carol", and in another, because this is a book about writers and the business of writing, and in yet a third, because the author is able to describe Dickens being at some times bereft of inspiration, and at others, overflowing with it, yet never once jarred me out of that special reverie one falls into when reading a good book.