Scan barcode
catgiven94's review against another edition
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
csdaley's review against another edition
dark
emotional
funny
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
dwintaylor's review against another edition
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
vorpalblad's review against another edition
5.0
It's no coincidence that McKinty is the editor of a book of short stories titled Belfast Noir. His series following Detective Sean Duffy is gritty noir to its core. Gun Street Girl is the fourth novel in the series, and if you haven't read the rest, I'd suggest starting with The Cold Cold Ground, but you can certainly pick this up as a stand-alone.
I've written prior reviews of this series praising the way McKinty's writing pulls you into the grim, claustrophobic world of 1980s, Troubles Belfast, but something that tickles the hack historian in me is the way he always manages to center his tale around a real event. This time he has loosely (or not so loosely... "I can't recall") based the central mystery around some missing missiles from one of the last manufacturers in Northern Ireland. I would highly recommend reading about the original characters on which it is based. Truth, in this case, is just as strange as fiction.
I've written prior reviews of this series praising the way McKinty's writing pulls you into the grim, claustrophobic world of 1980s, Troubles Belfast, but something that tickles the hack historian in me is the way he always manages to center his tale around a real event. This time he has loosely (or not so loosely... "I can't recall") based the central mystery around some missing missiles from one of the last manufacturers in Northern Ireland. I would highly recommend reading about the original characters on which it is based. Truth, in this case, is just as strange as fiction.
emckeon1002's review against another edition
5.0
There's nothing more satisfying than fine writing, Irish troubles, a disreputable Catholic detective in the RUC, stolen missiles, and an Ollie North-like character roaming Belfast like an ugly bully. Another great one by McKinity, who even name-checks John Nields in the wry conclusion to this un-put-downable fiction.
kcfromaustcrime's review against another edition
5.0
GUN STREET GIRL is the fourth book to feature Irish cop Sean Duffy. The Duffy series, has been winning plaudits, praise and awards in all corners of the world and hugely deserved they have all been, which meant fans of both the writer and the earlier three books (THE COLD, COLD GROUND, I HEAR THE SIRENS IN THE STREET and IN THE MORNING I'LL BE GONE) were well pleased when the fourth book was announced. Now all we need is more of these and we'll stay happy. (No pressure or anything of course).
Of most interest to this reader was how a fourth book would slot into what had originally been planned, and seemingly executed as a trilogy. Whilst there were storylines that could be extended at the end of IN THE MORNING I'LL BE GONE, there was much that had been explored, prodded, drawn out, and tied off. It was more than gratifying to find much in GUN STREET GIRL that raises the standards of the 3 earlier books even more.
A lot of that is helped by the glorious, understated dry dialogue, observation and writing of this author. There's no padding, no overstatement and none of your shilly shallying about in here. At the same time it's wonderfully descriptive, frequently hilarious, and absolutely skewering.
"But I'm not in charge and that is not what happens. This being an RUC-Gardai-FBI-MI5-Interpol operation we are headed for debacle ... "
"'Farce isn't my cup of tea,' I tell him, wind the window up and pull out of the car park. The me in the rear-view mirror shakes his head. That was a silly remark. Far out here, on the edge of the dying British Empire, farce is the only mode of narrative discourse that makes any sense at all."
Given that the action centres around Belfast in the mid 1980's, during the Troubles and the time of Thatcher's British Government, the social observations and the insider view of policy decisions like the Anglo-Irish Agreement (of 1985 - not to be confused with the Treaty of 1921 or the Trade Agreement in the 1960's...) are as much a factor in what makes these books work as are the strong characters, and the even stronger sense of place.
"'Here the politics are centrifugal, not centrist. Extreme Nationalists and extreme Unionists will condemn the Agreement as a sell-out of their principles and the moderates in the middle who support it will look like fools.'"
Balanced elegantly against that backdrop is a real, and intriguing plot. The murder of a very wealthy couple and the suicide of their son is soon revealed to be something much bigger than the easy solution of murder-suicide. And it is Duffy's copper instincts that tell him something's not right. And it is his copper instincts that keep them digging even when things start to get very grown up and very weird. The lurking presence of the intelligence bods - US and UK, and the possibility of career moves for Duffy all contribute to a bigger picture which gets more and more complicated the deeper Duffy and his colleagues dig.
At the heart of these books, however, is Sean Duffy. He's not perfect, he's not above a bit of pilfering of drug seizures, he's not above the occasional joint or line, and he's certainly not lucky at love. He's determined to stay a Catholic man in the centre of a Protestant area, even when that sometimes means he's got to have a deep and meaningful with the neighbours who keep the tensions at bay. He tries to play fair with everyone he deals with, and he's a very very good cop. He's also in a no-win position in his job. Trapped at his current level, constantly viewed with suspicion by the higher-ups he is absolutely loyal to his team and very supportive, albeit in a slightly haphazard manner at times. It's impossible not to read his stories and not think he deserves more. A happy home life, a job where he's appreciated, people around him who aren't constantly trying to get at him. At the same time you kind of hope that some of that doesn't happen. A happy, contented, comfortable Sean Duffy may not be quite the edgy copper he is right now. Either way, let's hope that GUN STREET GIRL has broken the back of McKinty's trilogy habit and there's a lot more in this series to come.
http://www.austcrimefiction.org/review/review-gun-street-girl-adrian-mckinty
Of most interest to this reader was how a fourth book would slot into what had originally been planned, and seemingly executed as a trilogy. Whilst there were storylines that could be extended at the end of IN THE MORNING I'LL BE GONE, there was much that had been explored, prodded, drawn out, and tied off. It was more than gratifying to find much in GUN STREET GIRL that raises the standards of the 3 earlier books even more.
A lot of that is helped by the glorious, understated dry dialogue, observation and writing of this author. There's no padding, no overstatement and none of your shilly shallying about in here. At the same time it's wonderfully descriptive, frequently hilarious, and absolutely skewering.
"But I'm not in charge and that is not what happens. This being an RUC-Gardai-FBI-MI5-Interpol operation we are headed for debacle ... "
"'Farce isn't my cup of tea,' I tell him, wind the window up and pull out of the car park. The me in the rear-view mirror shakes his head. That was a silly remark. Far out here, on the edge of the dying British Empire, farce is the only mode of narrative discourse that makes any sense at all."
Given that the action centres around Belfast in the mid 1980's, during the Troubles and the time of Thatcher's British Government, the social observations and the insider view of policy decisions like the Anglo-Irish Agreement (of 1985 - not to be confused with the Treaty of 1921 or the Trade Agreement in the 1960's...) are as much a factor in what makes these books work as are the strong characters, and the even stronger sense of place.
"'Here the politics are centrifugal, not centrist. Extreme Nationalists and extreme Unionists will condemn the Agreement as a sell-out of their principles and the moderates in the middle who support it will look like fools.'"
Balanced elegantly against that backdrop is a real, and intriguing plot. The murder of a very wealthy couple and the suicide of their son is soon revealed to be something much bigger than the easy solution of murder-suicide. And it is Duffy's copper instincts that tell him something's not right. And it is his copper instincts that keep them digging even when things start to get very grown up and very weird. The lurking presence of the intelligence bods - US and UK, and the possibility of career moves for Duffy all contribute to a bigger picture which gets more and more complicated the deeper Duffy and his colleagues dig.
At the heart of these books, however, is Sean Duffy. He's not perfect, he's not above a bit of pilfering of drug seizures, he's not above the occasional joint or line, and he's certainly not lucky at love. He's determined to stay a Catholic man in the centre of a Protestant area, even when that sometimes means he's got to have a deep and meaningful with the neighbours who keep the tensions at bay. He tries to play fair with everyone he deals with, and he's a very very good cop. He's also in a no-win position in his job. Trapped at his current level, constantly viewed with suspicion by the higher-ups he is absolutely loyal to his team and very supportive, albeit in a slightly haphazard manner at times. It's impossible not to read his stories and not think he deserves more. A happy home life, a job where he's appreciated, people around him who aren't constantly trying to get at him. At the same time you kind of hope that some of that doesn't happen. A happy, contented, comfortable Sean Duffy may not be quite the edgy copper he is right now. Either way, let's hope that GUN STREET GIRL has broken the back of McKinty's trilogy habit and there's a lot more in this series to come.
http://www.austcrimefiction.org/review/review-gun-street-girl-adrian-mckinty
bkdrgn303's review against another edition
4.0
Dark and gritty. Sean Duffy is smart and imperfect. Really enjoying this series.
constantreader471's review against another edition
3.0
I rate this book 3.5 stars rounded down. It is an entertaining mystery. Detective Inspector Sean Duffy is called to the scene of a double murder. Duffy is a Catholic in an overwhelmingly Protestant RUC(Royal Ulster Constabulary). He is also determined to solve this murder, since it could be his last case. He has been offered a job with MI5.
He does solve the case, with unsatisfying results. He tangles with American spies, Special Branch, and Protestant terrorists.
I find that Duffy's use of drugs to be upsetting. He confiscates a bag of cocaine from an American Celebrity and keeps half for his personal use.
One quote: "In the last fourteen hours I'd had tea, coffee, pharma cocaine, hashish, tobacco, codeine, whiskey, bourbon, beer, and as a sleep aid: Valium and vodka and lime."
This is book 4 in the series and they are best read in order.
This was a library book that I read in 2 days.
He does solve the case, with unsatisfying results. He tangles with American spies, Special Branch, and Protestant terrorists.
I find that Duffy's use of drugs to be upsetting. He confiscates a bag of cocaine from an American Celebrity and keeps half for his personal use.
One quote: "In the last fourteen hours I'd had tea, coffee, pharma cocaine, hashish, tobacco, codeine, whiskey, bourbon, beer, and as a sleep aid: Valium and vodka and lime."
This is book 4 in the series and they are best read in order.
This was a library book that I read in 2 days.
kenlaan's review against another edition
5.0
I will never stop saying that Adrian McKinty would be more popular than the likes of Michael Connelly if there were any justice in the world.
A detective procedural set in Carrickfergus, Northern Ireland, during the 80s - I cannot heap enough praise on this novel and it has my strongest recommendation for fans of the genre.
A detective procedural set in Carrickfergus, Northern Ireland, during the 80s - I cannot heap enough praise on this novel and it has my strongest recommendation for fans of the genre.
amn028's review against another edition
4.0
Sean Duffy returns in a story that stays true to his character. The book draws you in from the beginning. This series really is an enjoyable read. The good news is the book ends in such a manner that there is little doubt book five will be published at some point (hopefully soon). It really is a mystery – who killed, who stole, how large the conspiracy and just who’s involved, etc – but the true point is watching the Duffy character being fleshed out as not quite an anti-hero but threading the thin line. The death of a secondary character was shocking as it seems to completely change the course Duffy was taking. It will be interesting to see how it affects him and where he winds up in the next book.