Scan barcode
bonriki's review against another edition
adventurous
informative
medium-paced
3.0
Some of these essays were quite good, vividly describing the deserts and ancient peoples of the Southwest. Some of the essays also smack of white male privilege, Childs camps on a butte that is taboo to visitation per Native Americans, sasses a border patrol agent, and tries breaking rules to get into Burning Man despite being explicitly told not to several times. Like, my guy, the world doesn’t revolve around you
thenaturelibrary's review against another edition
3.0
This short collection of 8 essays by Craig Childs centering on the Colorado Plateau area captures the harsh, raw, and beautiful elements of the desert. I've lived in two different desert ecosystems (one being in the Colorado Plateau), and there so much that Childs was able to capture with his writing that reflects the nature of the desert. He touches on the magic of finding water in the desert, the way the desert doesn't hide its dangers, and the way that the desert grows on you and challenges you. I loved the imagery he uses with the bookend essays "Virga" and "Bone" to describe the desert, of rain that evaporates before it touches the ground and of bones that remain after everything else has worn away.
There were moments in the book where the author described his experiences in a way where I was taken aback- he describes running into law enforcement officers at the border and being able to joke around with them, continuing to hike in an area after several vehicles approached him and told him to turn back, and camping in an area considered taboo to camp at by indigenous folks (he didn't realize at the time, but he brushes it off). It felt like he was unaware of how some things he was doing affected other people or how another person might not be able to get away with the same behavior.
Overall, I came for the desert essays, enjoyed those essays, but left with a feeling that Childs hadn't acknowledged the privileges he holds that allowed him to do some things that others aren't able to.
There were moments in the book where the author described his experiences in a way where I was taken aback- he describes running into law enforcement officers at the border and being able to joke around with them, continuing to hike in an area after several vehicles approached him and told him to turn back, and camping in an area considered taboo to camp at by indigenous folks (he didn't realize at the time, but he brushes it off). It felt like he was unaware of how some things he was doing affected other people or how another person might not be able to get away with the same behavior.
Overall, I came for the desert essays, enjoyed those essays, but left with a feeling that Childs hadn't acknowledged the privileges he holds that allowed him to do some things that others aren't able to.
lmoser's review against another edition
4.0
Beautiful collection of essays about the western United States, the wildness and personality of the desert, and the relationship between us and the elements. I'm not originally from the southwest, but after spending 10 years here, I know what it's like to stand in a big city, and imagine that the streets look like canyons. I also love when autobiography & poetry combine, so this was an easy 4 stars for me.
tman7499's review
adventurous
emotional
funny
hopeful
informative
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
relaxing
medium-paced
4.75
talesuponmyshelf's review against another edition
3.0
Very well written. The words used to describe different things was beautiful! The only reason for three stars is I didn't care much about the subject matter but I still enjoyed it.
More...