Scan barcode
jbleyle63's review
3.0
New material not as good as the first DC Rebirth Holiday title with very short 8 to 10 page stories featuring many characters from the DC universe. Not much compelling storytelling in the first half. Thankfully the second half features encore tales from the past with longer and more entertaining stories.
justabookholic's review
1.0
This was BAD.
I literally can't find any other word to describe this comic. From a story about evil Santa fighting a war against sentient trees to ringing in the year with the big three only to end on the most depressing note I have read in a comic to date (a list that includes Watchmen and V for Vendetta)... like wtf?! This was a collective disaster as all stories had different writers.
Bless the artists, man. They are to be commended, especially when the writing was overall very rushed and super hacky. Each story felt like it needed another page (or three!) to feel complete but I guess DC has never heard the phrase to many cooks spoil the broth...The broth (this comic) was spoiled guys!
Just read the first DC Rebirth Holiday collection, save yourself from the confusion and annoyance. Bah Humbug.
I literally can't find any other word to describe this comic. From a story about evil Santa fighting a war against sentient trees to ringing in the year with the big three only to end on the most depressing note I have read in a comic to date (a list that includes Watchmen and V for Vendetta)... like wtf?! This was a collective disaster as all stories had different writers.
Bless the artists, man. They are to be commended, especially when the writing was overall very rushed and super hacky. Each story felt like it needed another page (or three!) to feel complete but I guess DC has never heard the phrase to many cooks spoil the broth...The broth (this comic) was spoiled guys!
Just read the first DC Rebirth Holiday collection, save yourself from the confusion and annoyance. Bah Humbug.
booknooknoggin's review against another edition
3.0
This was much better than the prior volume. Stories seemed to have more to them than just being holiday themed.
More...