Scan barcode
shane_tiernan's review against another edition
2.0
I wouldn't have read this except that someone gave it to me and I'm about to start a DC comics reading marathon and these events take place right before the "Infinite Crisis" event that I'll be reading part of so figured why not.
Being 51, I'm not really into comics or movies about kids in high school, so that was a turn off, but the writing was pretty good, and the art wasn't bad. Just not super exciting.
Being 51, I'm not really into comics or movies about kids in high school, so that was a turn off, but the writing was pretty good, and the art wasn't bad. Just not super exciting.
bat_books's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 ⭐️
i've always been a fan of tim as robin, but this is the first stand-alone series of his i've read (not including single issues in bat events). stories balancing the hero & the person behind the mask are typically my favourites & considering the title of the book, it definitely delivered
it introduces bernard and sets up tim & stephanie's storylines for war games. it really feels like essential reading for war games, i'm excited for the added context when i re-read that event. i'll also be seeking out tim/bernard storylines, i'm very intrigued to see their friendship/light rivalry evolve into a relationship
it wasn't an all-time favourite story, but it was enjoyable!
i've always been a fan of tim as robin, but this is the first stand-alone series of his i've read (not including single issues in bat events). stories balancing the hero & the person behind the mask are typically my favourites & considering the title of the book, it definitely delivered
it introduces bernard and sets up tim & stephanie's storylines for war games. it really feels like essential reading for war games, i'm excited for the added context when i re-read that event. i'll also be seeking out tim/bernard storylines, i'm very intrigued to see their friendship/light rivalry evolve into a relationship
it wasn't an all-time favourite story, but it was enjoyable!
nickpalmieri's review
3.0
Collects Robin #121-125.
It seems we're in a cycle where every 20 issues this book radically changes itself with a new location and a new supporting cast. I can't say I'm the biggest fan of Willingham's direction here, as he makes Tim more snarky and gives him an incredibly unlikable new friend. Still, the stories found here are decent, if far more violent than before -- not a bad thing on their own, but definitely a shock compared to the earlier material from this title (some of these scenes terrified me when I first read them a decade ago).
The 3-part Johnny Warlock origin is fine, and the 2-part Unmasked story after is entertaining. I just can't help but feel the editorial hand interfering here. Characters sometimes act in strange ways, and I know some of that and the related plot developments are set-ups for dubious ends over the next few issues. So instead of feeling like a natural build-up for a well-constructed story, it feels more like a hollow attempt to move chess pieces around the board. For example: Tim has an irrationally emotional reaction to the apparent death of Warlock, which feels out of character and contrived. But he needed to do that so he could quit being Robin, so Steph could become Robin for a few issues after this, and even that was only to increase the impact of her death a few issues later. There is so much happening editorially that Willingham is forced to write some contrived material.
And the artist changed two issues in! The second artist isn't terrible, just nowhere near as good as the first.
It's not all bad. Willingham, if nothing else, set up a new section of Gotham for Tim and gives us a new source of antagonists for the future. I guess his specialty is world-building, which shouldn't be a surprise given his work on Fables. I just wish the story held together better.
It seems we're in a cycle where every 20 issues this book radically changes itself with a new location and a new supporting cast. I can't say I'm the biggest fan of Willingham's direction here, as he makes Tim more snarky and gives him an incredibly unlikable new friend. Still, the stories found here are decent, if far more violent than before -- not a bad thing on their own, but definitely a shock compared to the earlier material from this title (some of these scenes terrified me when I first read them a decade ago).
The 3-part Johnny Warlock origin is fine, and the 2-part Unmasked story after is entertaining. I just can't help but feel the editorial hand interfering here. Characters sometimes act in strange ways, and I know some of that and the related plot developments are set-ups for dubious ends over the next few issues. So instead of feeling like a natural build-up for a well-constructed story, it feels more like a hollow attempt to move chess pieces around the board. For example: Tim has an irrationally emotional reaction to the apparent death of Warlock, which feels out of character and contrived. But he needed to do that so he could quit being Robin, so Steph could become Robin for a few issues after this, and even that was only to increase the impact of her death a few issues later. There is so much happening editorially that Willingham is forced to write some contrived material.
And the artist changed two issues in! The second artist isn't terrible, just nowhere near as good as the first.
It's not all bad. Willingham, if nothing else, set up a new section of Gotham for Tim and gives us a new source of antagonists for the future. I guess his specialty is world-building, which shouldn't be a surprise given his work on Fables. I just wish the story held together better.
More...