3.28k reviews for:

Anne of the Island

L.M. Montgomery

4.27 AVERAGE


Good ending!

Anne attends college and learns to fall in love. For all that this focuses on romance, it's less dated or frustrating than the previous installation--perhaps because the many featured romances are so varied and compassionate. Anne's romantic entanglements are almost overdrawn, but they function as a platform for her character growth, for the quiet conflict between storybook ideals and happy realities, and by pulling double duty they don't overstay their welcome. Her college life goes relatively unexplored, and I wish it were otherwise--Anne's scholastic achievements would help ground the narrative. Daily life with her classmates rises to fill that gap, and performs well; Patty's Place is exactly what one would hope for from this series, charming and gently idealized. I liked this, didn't love it--probably none of the sequels will live up to Anne of Green Gables, but that's an unfair standard to hold them to.

“There is so much in the world for us all if we only have the eyes to see it, and the heart to love it, and the hand to gather it to ourselves--so much in men and women, so much in art and literature, so much everywhere in which to delight, and for which to be thankful.”


This book wasn't as memorable for me as the first two, but I still had a good time seeing Anne grow up and adjust to a new environment while maintaining her optimism and creativity. While I liked reading about her time at Redmond College with her new friends and her new home, I couldn't wait for Anne to return to Green Gables.

One thing to mention is that I felt very disturbed by a scene where Anne and her friends try to chloroform a cat to avoid taking care of it. It felt so jarring and cruel, and soured the book overall for me.
emotional hopeful inspiring lighthearted reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
emotional lighthearted reflective relaxing fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

The book regained some of that whimsy magic that the first one held for me and the second one seemed to be missing. Anne is a bit annoying and clearly precious to the author as she is treated like the center of the world, but she is still enjoyable and I really enjoyed her university life adventures.

Thought her entire time at uni is crammed into one book it didn't feel rushed and the author truly captured the essence of growing up and the bittersweet feeling of letting go of girlhood.

Anne's college years! I read this book when I was in college and despite going to my state college, this book gave me the feelings of that "quintessential college experience" that movies depict. It's nice to read about just girls being girls, but also being such high achievers. This was my second favorite book in the Anne series and I've read it again and again since the first time!
inspiring relaxing
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes

When I first started reading the Anne of Green Gables series I was a pre-teen. I had never left my hometown at that point, and knew that Canada lay north. I imagined that Canada was just the Niagara Falls because that's all I ever saw about it on television. To read a story about an orphaned girl that comes to live with a brother and sister and slowly worms her way into the hearts of them and her neighbors living on Prince Edward Island in the 1900s.

I chose to read book #3 of the series because honestly this is my favorite. We get to see Anne, Gilbert Blythe, Charlie Sloane and Priscilla Grant (all old friends of Anne's) going to Redmond College in Nova Scotia.

Anne is definitely more mature in this book, and a lot of subjects that are looked at definitely are more somber than previous books. I loved Anne a lot in this book because even though she didn't want to admit how everyone and everything is changing, she realizes that she can't keep herself and others frozen based on how they behaved as children. Anne has a falling out with Charlie Sloane (has a chilly reconciliation) and starts to see that she feels something for Gilbert Blythe, but doesn't think it's love. When Anne meets someone else who is her romantic ideal, she initially is happy, but starts to wonder if this is what she's looking for.

We have the introduction of a new characters in this one, Phillipa Gordon, who I found to be funny. We also get to revisit with old characters such as Anne's kindred spirit, Diana Barry, Marilla, Mrs. Lynde, and Dora and Davy Keith who Marilla took in during book #2 (Anne of Avonlea).

The writing is not really complex in these books and honestly I like that. Once you read the first Anne of Green Gables books you will get a better idea about the people and past escapades of Anne.

The flow for this one was not that great though. I think it's because you have a huge passage of time in just a short amount of pages. A lot of events felt rushed and summed up in just a few short paragraphs.

The setting of Redmond College does come alive in this book. One great thing that L.M. Montgomery always did in these books was set a perfect scene of where places are and how they looked.

The ending was one of my favorites in this series. We have Anne having her eyes truly opened about what she wants and who she wants to share her future with. I always thought it was a wonderful the way things wrapped up.

I always enjoy spending time with Anne and am probably going to go back and read the other books in this series later this year.

r e l e c t u r a

dioj mío cuánto amo y aprecio a gilbert blythe

Absolutely delightful. I loved following anne at Patty's place and watching her grew up.