Reviews

A Biased Judgement: The Sherlock Holmes Diaries 1897 by Geri Schear

iam_griff's review

Go to review page

4.0

I received this audiobook for free from MX Publishing & has no influence to my review. I will say this book was the best of the lot with all the free audiobooks from MX Publishing (IMO). The narration was perfect & took a turn in the story that I'd never expect a Sherlock Holmes & Dr. Watson to take in it all of the stories I've read. I don't want to ruin it at all, but this book is definitely worth a read.

claudia_is_reading's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

As with every book that takes Holmes by the road of romance, I approached this one with caution *laughs*

But I really, really liked it. Probably because: one, Sherlock Holmes is still him, he stays the man we all know and love; and two, Lady Beatrice is a very good character, a smart, strong lady with a very defined set of ideas about what she wants from life.

Having the story told from Holmes' POV was a great way to present it. I just love how skillfully and yet, subtly he writes about his emotions; it's simply perfect :D

And the mystery and the conspiracy's plots are concise and tightly written; interesting and compelling.

I will be searching for more stories by this author, that's for sure.

booksandbacon's review

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes

5.0

My thanks to Steve at @mxpublishing for a review copy.

Europe is in turmoil, it's heading for total chaos, and heads of state, Monarchs and influential people are been assassinated. Who is capable of orchestrating these terrible deeds, there is (or was) someone more than capable of it, Moriarty, but he's dead Sherlock took care of that. Has someone taken over Moriarty's organisation which has its claws around the world?

That's how the story begins and it's a really fantastic start.

There is another plot in which we find murdered a servant girl from a prestigious family but is she as innocent as her colleagues say?

It's really a fascinating story, I'm certainly no Sherlock expert but I believe Geri has captured Sherlock's essence. What I love about that era is the language, for example:

Blackguard:"A man who behaves in a dishonourable or contemptible way"

Brown Study:"A mood in which you are very involved in your own thoughts and not paying attention to anything else". Sherlock has many of those lol. There are a few modern words or references but I'm fine with it, it's the story that counts.

Love it!!

My favourite character is the lovely Lady Beatrice, a woman ahead of her time thanks to her father who believed women should have education on par with their male counterparts. Very forward thinking for the 1800s.

Geri is a great storyteller and I shall check out her other works.

Highly recommended.
More...