Scan barcode
celestialfoxxy's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
funny
mysterious
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
l absolutely loved reading this book! It's full of plot twists and cliff hangers that left me unable to put the book down once I got to the halfway point. The characters are generally witty, intriguing and their dialogue and interactions with eachother were generally very captivating. The plot was a little bit predictable but I was caught off guard a few times as well. The world building was very unique and interesting and the author did a very good job of describing the scenes in the story in a way that was completely immersive and left me able to invision the setting as though I was there with the MC. The love story between the FMC and her love interest was everything I look for in a fantasy romance. Morally grey mysterious love interest meets stubborn rebellious and undeniably good love interest. Forced proximity. Enemies to Lovers. Forbidden love. High stakes romance. *chef's kiss*
My only big issue with this book is that the end of the book felt almost too rushed and I feel like they should have added more to almost every scene at the end of the novel. There were some BIG plot moments that I felt fell flat because they just weren't given the time or wordcount they deserved in the story.
Overall I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book, it kept me very engaged, interested and I could not put it down. It made me feel all the feelings and I would recommend that you read it.
Keep reading for an explanation of why I feel that way and a more spoiler heavy review.
To start I want to just repeat that I absolutely recommend reading this series. That said there were a few things that really frustrated me in this book towards the end.
First, I love MOST of the characters in this book. Elise gets on my nerves sometimes for reasons I'll get into in a minute. I absolutely fell in love with Legion. His guild of shade also grew on me very very quickly and I think I probably love Halvar almost as much as Legion. Elise's friends fall a little flatter for me in this book (however I have started the second book and my opinion there does change). As for the villains of the story....I wish that we had seen more of the king before he was killed. There was never any doubt in my mind that he was evil but it would have been cool to explore his character. He felt more like a vague ominous presence in the background than a major villian. Runa made me hate her in every scene that she appeared in, so did Calder. The kings assassination did take me by surprise but the fact that they were the ones to do it absolutely did not. Jarl also never sat right with me. He said everything Elise wanted to hear some of the time but most of the time made it clear he didn't want her because of who she was, he wanted her as a means to an end and to fulfill a fantasy that could never be real. He liked the idea of having a woman of her station and the more she pushed him away the more he wanted her. His ego was his ultimate downfall. Interestingly I think, Elise's mother was a character that held my attention more than most. She was very rarely every actually IN the scenes of the novel but Elise thinks of her often, usually not in a very flattering way but the one scene we do see her speaking it's in defense of Elise against the king, pleading for forgiveness for her. I think the contrast between the opinion we see Elise has of her and the actual evidence of her character through her actions is so interesting and I'm excited to see more of her in future novels because I think she will turn out to be a better person than Elise thinks that she is.
I also think the world building was done very well. There's a unique political system, unique magic system, the social etiquette and expectations are clearly defined, there is an expansive world described by the author without being too overwhelming to understand and it's expanded on as we need to learn about it. I do wish that the way Fury works was explained a little better. I understand what it is but not why it is or exactly how it works.
As for the plot...I have so many mixed feelings here regarding the plot and the writing of it. As I said before it was a bit predictable for me. I clocked pretty early in the story that Legion was likely the wraith and then again that he was the night prince. It was pretty clear Siv would betray Elise. It was obvious that her sister, jarl and Calder were working together to plot something evil. That said I didn't predict the coup happening when it did, learning how the managed Legion's curse was devastating and learning that the guild didnt know who they truly were caught me by surprise but confirmed my suspicion that Legion must be the night prince. My biggest issue with this book and the reason it didn't get a 5 star rating from me is that I truly feel like the end of the book was lacking so much detail and was executed poorly in some ways. Starting with the coup, Elise's best friend dies and then it's just...not really mentioned again? It feels like her character was sort of just put there to die. Before her death she's just in the background shrinking in fear every time there's a fight around her and then she dies and everyone gets over it pretty quickly. The level of grief we get to see isn't nearly what it should be for the death of someone who was cared so deeply for. Her death had the potential to be gut wrenching and instead fell flat because it just happened and then was forgotten. After she dies Elise needs to make a magically binding promise with Legion. She does. After learning he is the blood Wraith she no longer has the free will to leave his side. Instead of revealing the truth to her and letting her make an informed decision they just stand there repeating there isn't time and force her into this knowing she doesn't know what she's doing. Loyalty who? Legion can coorce a promise while betraying her trust in the same breath but she can't leave his side because it would be disloyal? make it make sense. And then she finally sits down across from him because she has no other choice. Instead of just telling her the whole truth he insists she asks him questions and he will answer honestly. Just...tell her???? Why does she have to ask? You know what she needs to know, tell it to her. The way I was yelling at my kindle the whole time I was reading this for them to just TELL HER instead of dancing around it and making everything worse was insane. So she's so angry with him that she ends up fleeing the first chance she gets and is taken captive and then saved. Woohoo. Could all have been avoided if for once someone just communicated with her. Then we have Siv's betrayal. Again, I don't think Elise was angry with her long enough or strongly enough. This, I think, is the most frustrating part of this book. Elise is written as this good, generous, forgiving and gracious character....but this sometimes translates to her not experiencing the full range of emotions she should be feeling. I want to see rage and anguish and hurt. Instead she forgives the people who betrayed her in such major ways without them ever having to work towards redemption or prove they should be trusted and forgiven. There's redemption over and over again without a redemption arc. Now at the end of the book we see Legion sacrafice himself to save Elise and this breaks his curse. Such an awesome moment in the story...but then he remembers he's the night prince, makes a vow for revenge on the people who killed his family....and promptly abandons the woman he just tried to DIE for. Out of pocket behaviour truly. (I will say, having read the second book his actions are explained and his reasons left me less irritated with him).
SO having said all of that..I still couldn't put this book down, the series of emotions it pulled from me while reading was intense and I 100% recommend reading this series. I think if I could pretend this book and the second book were one single book I would rate it 5 stars but on its own with the way the ending was written it gets a 4 star review from me.
My only big issue with this book is that the end of the book felt almost too rushed and I feel like they should have added more to almost every scene at the end of the novel. There were some BIG plot moments that I felt fell flat because they just weren't given the time or wordcount they deserved in the story.
Overall I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book, it kept me very engaged, interested and I could not put it down. It made me feel all the feelings and I would recommend that you read it.
Keep reading for an explanation of why I feel that way and a more spoiler heavy review.
To start I want to just repeat that I absolutely recommend reading this series. That said there were a few things that really frustrated me in this book towards the end.
First, I love MOST of the characters in this book. Elise gets on my nerves sometimes for reasons I'll get into in a minute. I absolutely fell in love with Legion. His guild of shade also grew on me very very quickly and I think I probably love Halvar almost as much as Legion. Elise's friends fall a little flatter for me in this book (however I have started the second book and my opinion there does change). As for the villains of the story....I wish that we had seen more of the king before he was killed. There was never any doubt in my mind that he was evil but it would have been cool to explore his character. He felt more like a vague ominous presence in the background than a major villian. Runa made me hate her in every scene that she appeared in, so did Calder. The kings assassination did take me by surprise but the fact that they were the ones to do it absolutely did not. Jarl also never sat right with me. He said everything Elise wanted to hear some of the time but most of the time made it clear he didn't want her because of who she was, he wanted her as a means to an end and to fulfill a fantasy that could never be real. He liked the idea of having a woman of her station and the more she pushed him away the more he wanted her. His ego was his ultimate downfall. Interestingly I think, Elise's mother was a character that held my attention more than most. She was very rarely every actually IN the scenes of the novel but Elise thinks of her often, usually not in a very flattering way but the one scene we do see her speaking it's in defense of Elise against the king, pleading for forgiveness for her. I think the contrast between the opinion we see Elise has of her and the actual evidence of her character through her actions is so interesting and I'm excited to see more of her in future novels because I think she will turn out to be a better person than Elise thinks that she is.
I also think the world building was done very well. There's a unique political system, unique magic system, the social etiquette and expectations are clearly defined, there is an expansive world described by the author without being too overwhelming to understand and it's expanded on as we need to learn about it. I do wish that the way Fury works was explained a little better. I understand what it is but not why it is or exactly how it works.
As for the plot...I have so many mixed feelings here regarding the plot and the writing of it. As I said before it was a bit predictable for me. I clocked pretty early in the story that Legion was likely the wraith and then again that he was the night prince. It was pretty clear Siv would betray Elise. It was obvious that her sister, jarl and Calder were working together to plot something evil. That said I didn't predict the coup happening when it did, learning how the managed Legion's curse was devastating and learning that the guild didnt know who they truly were caught me by surprise but confirmed my suspicion that Legion must be the night prince. My biggest issue with this book and the reason it didn't get a 5 star rating from me is that I truly feel like the end of the book was lacking so much detail and was executed poorly in some ways. Starting with the coup, Elise's best friend dies and then it's just...not really mentioned again? It feels like her character was sort of just put there to die. Before her death she's just in the background shrinking in fear every time there's a fight around her and then she dies and everyone gets over it pretty quickly. The level of grief we get to see isn't nearly what it should be for the death of someone who was cared so deeply for. Her death had the potential to be gut wrenching and instead fell flat because it just happened and then was forgotten. After she dies Elise needs to make a magically binding promise with Legion. She does. After learning he is the blood Wraith she no longer has the free will to leave his side. Instead of revealing the truth to her and letting her make an informed decision they just stand there repeating there isn't time and force her into this knowing she doesn't know what she's doing. Loyalty who? Legion can coorce a promise while betraying her trust in the same breath but she can't leave his side because it would be disloyal? make it make sense. And then she finally sits down across from him because she has no other choice. Instead of just telling her the whole truth he insists she asks him questions and he will answer honestly. Just...tell her???? Why does she have to ask? You know what she needs to know, tell it to her. The way I was yelling at my kindle the whole time I was reading this for them to just TELL HER instead of dancing around it and making everything worse was insane. So she's so angry with him that she ends up fleeing the first chance she gets and is taken captive and then saved. Woohoo. Could all have been avoided if for once someone just communicated with her. Then we have Siv's betrayal. Again, I don't think Elise was angry with her long enough or strongly enough. This, I think, is the most frustrating part of this book. Elise is written as this good, generous, forgiving and gracious character....but this sometimes translates to her not experiencing the full range of emotions she should be feeling. I want to see rage and anguish and hurt. Instead she forgives the people who betrayed her in such major ways without them ever having to work towards redemption or prove they should be trusted and forgiven. There's redemption over and over again without a redemption arc. Now at the end of the book we see Legion sacrafice himself to save Elise and this breaks his curse. Such an awesome moment in the story...but then he remembers he's the night prince, makes a vow for revenge on the people who killed his family....and promptly abandons the woman he just tried to DIE for. Out of pocket behaviour truly. (I will say, having read the second book his actions are explained and his reasons left me less irritated with him).
SO having said all of that..I still couldn't put this book down, the series of emotions it pulled from me while reading was intense and I 100% recommend reading this series. I think if I could pretend this book and the second book were one single book I would rate it 5 stars but on its own with the way the ending was written it gets a 4 star review from me.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Kidnapping, Violence, Confinement, Death, Misogyny, Sexual assault, Sexual content, Blood, and Injury/Injury detail
Moderate: Grief, Torture, and Slavery
More...