Scan barcode
scrooge3's review against another edition
2.0
A bit better than the first volume, but still highly predictable and dated. The racism is a bit toned down from the first volume, but it's still there.
skjam's review against another edition
3.0
Another of the boys' adventure books from the early 20th Century I love so much. Young Tom acquires the motor-boat seen towards the end of the previous volume, repairs and improves it, and has a series of adventures on the local (very large) lake.
It illustrates how much the technology of gasoline motors has advanced in the intervening century--Tom and the other motorboat pilots must frequently tinker with the engines mid-race to get the best performance or prevent breakdowns.
The last quarter of the book sets up the airship that will be the focus of the next volume.
The character of Eradicate may come off as offensively stereotyped, and Tom shows some mild sexism when it comes to girls and motors. (The romantic interest gets better at it, but only because of his tutoring.) And towards the end, one character suddenly reveals he has more political power than he'd let on, with no foreshadowing.
But these are minor quibbles, and I think this book would be fine to share with a son, grandson or nephew.
For more adventure reviews, see http://www.skjam.com/tag/adventure/
It illustrates how much the technology of gasoline motors has advanced in the intervening century--Tom and the other motorboat pilots must frequently tinker with the engines mid-race to get the best performance or prevent breakdowns.
The last quarter of the book sets up the airship that will be the focus of the next volume.
The character of Eradicate may come off as offensively stereotyped, and Tom shows some mild sexism when it comes to girls and motors. (The romantic interest gets better at it, but only because of his tutoring.) And towards the end, one character suddenly reveals he has more political power than he'd let on, with no foreshadowing.
But these are minor quibbles, and I think this book would be fine to share with a son, grandson or nephew.
For more adventure reviews, see http://www.skjam.com/tag/adventure/