Reviews with content warning for Gun violence - Eileen

I wanted to love this book. It was very well written and literary in its exploration of dark themes. I wanted to go on a Hitchcockian caper, filled with questionable people and questionable situations. But whereas some of my favourite noirs are populated with bad people doing bad things entertainingly and with some sort of catharsis in consequences, this novel has mediocre people doing inane to depraved and evil things in an ongoing trudge of monotony and horror. The pacing of the novel makes it far more an exploration of complicity in wrong doing, generational trauma, substance abuse, neurotic coping mechanisms, shame, arrested development in a tragic moment between girlhood and womanhood, sexual deviance routed in trauma... Darkness in general, really, more than it reads as a thriller. Eileen sucks. The people around her suck. The world she inhabits is morally corrupt and also painted with the strokes of her narrating brush. This is a novel I might recommend to those who like unreliable narrators, can stomach misery porn, have interest in uncommon narration approaches and who don't mind a slog in pacing. I didn't like Eileen. But it's worth reading, analyzing and discussing. It's a book I could write an essay about but would never casually recommend to a friend. Trigger warnings for sexual abuse, eating disorders, substance abuse, trauma, generational abuse and mistreatment of minors should all be flagged here.

Content Warnings

desired_moon's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional sad tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

2.5

maybe i expected to much ?? it was just a really slow read. the ending not as surprising as I thought. it was okay, But not worth the hype.

Content Warnings

ariana3's review

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional sad tense slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.0

I was not a fan of this at all. It was recommended by a friend and I can see why she liked it, but it was not my cup of tea. The book was slow and ambling, it just felt like it was stream-of-consciousness writing, like the author was supposed to be telling a story but then would get themselves down a different rabbit hole. It was just odd, the timeline, the story, everything. Only in the last half of the last chapter did it kind of get good. And even when it ended I was confused and was just left with a "that's it?" feeling. Like the entire book was a waste.
Plot summary:

The main character, Eileen, lives with her dad who used to be a renowned police officer. After her mom died, he became a terrible drunk and was emotionally abusive. Eileen herself is a slob, gross, frumpy, doesn't care about her appearances and yet is utterly obsessed. As a young adult, she thinks she's the only "higher being" in her small Massachusetts town. She's a secretary at a youth prison and has been for several years since she was pulled out of school to care for her sick mom. Her childhood sucked, her parents sucked, her life sucks. Then this mysterious woman starts at the prison. She's obsessed with her and wants to be her lover or friend? It's confusing what she wants, she just wants attention and admiration from this woman, Rebecca. Rebecca reads a case file from one of the boys at the prison that disturbs her (a father was raping his son, so the son killed him). The mom did nothing about it and would help facilitate it. So in the last half of the last chapter, you find out that Rebecca has tied up this mom to elicit the confession. Eileen gets it and Rebecca is pissed but doesn't know what else to do. Eileen comes up with a plan to frame her dad for the mom's murder, since he's a drunk, but they would kill her. She knows Rebecca won't join her, so she says "bye" to her dad, gets her money, drives north to a pretty part of the forest, and leaves her beat up old truck running with the mom inside (passed out from pain pills) to die from carbon monoxide poisoning while she hitches a ride back south to NYC to start a new life. That's it. Literally nothing else happens...

Content Warnings