Reviews

Blame It on Bath by Caroline Linden

lassarina's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I picked this up on a whim despite it being the middle of a series because the description on a Smart Bitches, Trashy Books sale post looked intriguing. I am so pleased that I did. I devoured this book as fast as I could, because I just loved the relationship dynamic and the writing so much.

Gerard de Lacey is the youngest son of the Duke of Durham, whose sons discover after his death that he was married in secret before he wed his duchess, their mother. It is unknown what became of the duke's first wife, which puts the sons' inheritance at risk: if she did not predecease the duke's second marriage, then he was a bigamist and his sons are not legitimate heirs. This plot starts in the first book of the series and isn't resolved here, but this book (largely concurrent with the first book) follows Gerard's efforts to resolve it, mostly by chasing down what he can in direct action.

As a youngest son, Gerard bought himself a commission in the army, where he has served with pleasure since. He is sometimes reckless, quite brave, and a man of action above all else.

Enter Katherine Howe, a young widow who has a substantial dower portion coming to her from her deceased husband's estate. There's just one problem: the new holder of her husband's title wants to marry her to keep the money in the family, since without it he'd be reduced to penury. Katherine isn't thrilled at this, and she learns of the scandal facing Gerard and his brothers and makes him an offer: her hand in marriage, along with her money, in exchange for getting her away from Viscount Howe. With the uncertainty over his inheritance, it's a good offer for Gerard. He takes it, and they remove to Bath for him to investigate the matter of his father's marriage.

My heart hurt for Katherine a lot in this book, since her deceased husband was abusive and her mother is a narcissistic asshole who has done her best to convince Katherine that she's ugly and will never do better than she has. I know some other reviewers have commented on the dichotomy between Katherine's spirit in other venues and her quiet acquiescence to her mother, but to me that seems perfectly reasonable, in that she has some sense of her own abilities at this point in her life but many of us know that our parents can still make us feel small and young and inexperienced with just a word.

One thing I really liked about Gerard was that he actively wanted to encourage Katherine's spirit; yes, he explicitly marries her for financial gain (as had always been his plan, as a youngest son with a decent inheritance but not an outrageous one) but he's not cruel. He treats her very well most of the time, though he's wary of sharing his family situation with her any more than he has to (then again, given what happened with his brother in the previous book, I really can't blame him). I like that he takes one look at her family situation and just reacts with "nope."

I loved the way the love story grew in this one; it felt real to me in a lot of ways, and it just made me grin because it was so delightful. Also, A+ steamy scenes, would read again.

moviemavengal's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Just wonderful!

cpikas's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It was fine - but not as good as the first in the series. It's more of a formulaic regency -a better one than most

rjordan19's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional funny slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

Overall: 4.5 rounded to ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Plot/Storyline: 📖📖📖📖
Feels: 🦋🦋🦋
Emotional Depth: 💔💔💔💔
Sexual Tension: ⚡⚡⚡
Romance: 💞💞💞💞
Sensuality: 💋💋💋💋
Sex Scene Length: 🍑🍑🍑
Steam Scale (Number of Sex Scenes): 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Humor: Yes
Perspective: Third person from both the hero and heroine

Should I read in order?
Ideally yes because there’s a series long plot of finding if the father is a bigamist – but the relationship itself is fine as a stand alone. (Gerard has minimal page time in book 1)

Basic plot:
Gerard is trying to solve who is blackmailing his family when he’s approached by a mysterious woman that requests a marriage on convenience.

Give this a try if you want:
- Regency
- much of the story takes place in Bath
- marriage of convenience – heroine proposes to the hero to escape an abusive home situation
- rescue plot – loved how they come together to rescue the heroine
- medium to high steam – the scenes aren’t overly long (I listened to audio and it’s hard for me to tell length on there) but there’s a decent amount of scenes in the latter half! I have it at 5 scenes.
- unrequited love from the heroine
- widow heroine
- playful, former soldier hero


Ages:
- Hero is 28, heroine is 30

My thoughts:
I really ended up loving this story! I struggled a bit with the prior book in the series, so picking this one up and having more of the father’s mystery and a widow heroine I was worried it would feel similar. But Gerard’s spunky, playful personality completely won me over here.

The humor in this one was fun – the banter and how silly, sweet, and romantic Gerard was, how gentle with Kate he was had me swooning. I also tend to really like rescue plots and Kate is stuck in the beginning of this book. I love that Gerard went in ready to save the day even with it resulting in marriage. I love marriage of convenience because it totally eliminates the whole hero can’t marry because of xyz that drives me bonkers.

Some parts of this one are a bit slow but as I reread some parts and went through my notes I felt it tugging on my heart again so I had to round up. The sex in this one was really special to me – it was super emotional and always seemed to really progress their relationship and character connection. I found myself swooning and smiling through many parts of this story.

Quotes/spoiler-y thoughts:

I LOVE when the hero holds the heroine’s neck and head.

That was enough for Gerard. He slid his hand around the curve of her skull to hold her just so and took ownership of her mouth.
---
But now she was also his wife.
His to kiss.
His to hold.
His to bed.
And his to bring to the pinnacle of pleasure.
---
“You always look so surprised when I kiss you,” he murmured. “Do you not like it?”
She flinched as it she’d just been accused of some terrible crime. “I-I don’t know know.”
Gerard smiled a little. He couldn’t help it.
“Don’t worry love. You will.”

---
I love how tries to ease her worries

He stepped out of his trousers and drawers as she put out the last lamp. The room was plunged into darkness, the fire having died down to coals. Her white nightdress stood out as his eyes adjusted, and Gerard caught her when she would have hurried past him to the bed. “Don’t be afraid,” he murmured. He slipped one arm around her waist and threaded the fingers of his free hand into her hair. “Trust me.” And he kissed her.

---
And when she sees him out with another woman (that helps him choose jewelry for her) and thinks he’s cheating on her

“And I am not having an affair with her,” he added, fastening the chain at the nape of her neck.
“I didn’t think…” Her voice died away as she fingered the pendant.
“Yes, you did.” He leaned back. “Aren’t you going to thank me?”
“Thank you,” she said at once. “Very much.”
“Not like that.”
/
“Do you want to go upstairs?”
He rather liked this; sitting on his lap, she had to hold tight to him, and her breasts, with the amethyst pendant nestled between them, were right at eye level. “There’s not need for that. Lift your skirt.”
She jumped as he tickled the inside of her ankle. “We are in the dining room!” she whispered in horror.
“Bragg won’t come in.” Gerard nuzzled the underside of her jaw. “You smell delicious…”
“Somone else might!” She ducked away from his kiss. “To clear the dishes!”
Gerard sighed and lifted her off him. He strode across the room, catching up a chair as he went, and wedged the chair under the doorknob of the door into the hall. He went to the sideboard and shoved it until the corner of it blocked the other door. He turned back to Kate, who was watching with her mouth open and bright spots of pink in her cheeks, and took of his jacket and tossed it aside. “Now, lift your skirt.”
/
She grasped her skirt and pulled it upward a few inches.
“Good,” he murmured, unbuttoning his waistcoat as he watched her. “Further, please.”
Her face was hot as she complied. Her knees shook as she exposed them.
He dropped into a chair and crooked one finger at her. “Come here.”

---
Ugh and this whole scene ripping my fn heart out – she lies to him about why she wanted to marry him and he knows she’s lying and basically fucks the answer out of her. Takes her from behind on a table facing a public square in Bath…

“How calculating.” He flicked his thumb, then squeezed, very delicately, and she almost screamed. “Why me?”
“Because…” She could feel her climax building, sending shimmering waves of heat through her veins. “Because…”
“Why?” He rocked back and forth, a tormenting slow motion. “Why, Kate?” Is it so terrible? Are you carrying another man’s child? Is there some other threat to your fortune you neglected to reveal to me? Did Charlie and Edward refuse you before you asked me?”
“No...None of that…” She closed her eyes.
“Why, Kate?” He leaned over her, his breath scalding on the nape of her neck. He bit her there, his teeth scraping her skin. He was moving deep inside her now – she could hear in his voice that he was just as close to oblivion as she was -

---
And one of my favorite love declarations I’ve read

“Very well,” he muttered, and his voice boomed out, so loudly she jumped. “Katherine de Lacey, before God as my witness, I love you more than any man should ever love a woman.” A clutch of birds burst out of the hedges and flew away in a chorus of squawks. “I love the way your eyes snap when you’re irked at me. I love the way your nose wrinkles when you laugh at some nonsense I say. I love the way you ask old ladies for help finding a blackmailer. I love the way you look with your skirt up around your – Ah!”
Kate shrieked as his hand thrust through the hedge and seized her wrist. She pulled, fighting down the hysterical laughter that threatened to burst forth as Gerard peered at her through the leaves and branches, a perplexed but determined expression on his face. “There you are,” he said.
“And there you are,” she retorted, motioning to the hedge that divided them. “What did you plan to do next?”
He glanced up, and from side to side, as if measuring the hedge. Then to her astonishment, he wedged his shoulder into the tangle of branches, and pushed and shoved his way right through, never once letting go of her.
“You knocked a hole in the maze!” Kate gawked at the ragged, broken gap in the hedge.
“It will grow back.” He brushed some leaves from his hair and fixed his gaze on her. “I didn’t dare loose my grip on your again.”

Then he takes her to the center of the maze and fucks her. Ugh, I love it. I LOVE IT.
 


Content warnings:

- Toxic parents
- Unsatisfying marriage (heroine’s prior marriage)
- Using religion to pressure/control others


Locations of kisses/intimate scenes:
 
22% - kiss
26% - kiss
30% - kiss
36% - nipple play and some light kisses at the inn
42% - 🔥 kisses, light breast play, well endowed hero, fingering for her, missionary
50% - 🔥 kisses, playful her on top sex at the dining table with dinner still waiting
61% - 🔥 hand job for him, missionary
75% - 🔥 bent over a table overlooking Queen’s Square in Bath
98% - 🔥 kisses, sex in the maze 
 

ithiliens's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This was sooo sweet. I was expecting to slog through the middle book on my quest to the thottie brother in the last one but I really liked this. Do you have depression and want to be loved by your local himbo... if so this is the book for you

gonturans's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

We stan a depressed bitch who falls in love with the local himbo bc he was nice to her once twelve years ago. Extremely relatable.

witandsin's review

Go to review page

5.0

Just before he died, the Duke of Durham revealed to his three sons that he was being blackmailed. Why? Because the duke had married someone before he married his sons’ mother. Normally that wouldn’t be a problem, except for the fact that the duke never bothered to divorce his first wife and he doesn’t know if she was still living when he married his second wife. Now whispers abound that the de Lacey brothers may be illegitimate and they need to discover the truth about their father’s first marriage.

Gerard de Lacey, the youngest brother, is determined to catch the blackmailer and question him. But just before he leaves for Bath, a mysterious woman presents him with an interesting proposition: marriage. Gerard hadn’t planned on entering a marriage with a woman he barely knows, but Katherine Howe is a wealthy widow who needs to get married before her dead husband’s nephew tries to marry her for her fortune. Gerard can’t deny that Katharine’s money is very appealing – after all, he might soon lose his inheritance – but it’s the woman herself who tempts him like nothing and no one else has. Will a hasty marriage of convenience turn into something more than either the bride or groom ever expected?

It was almost impossible for me to put Blame It on Bath down once I started it. Caroline Linden has delivered an engaging, delightful story with two incredibly likeable protagonists that will have you reading Blame It on Bath all through the night. Gerard is caring, considerate, wonderfully sexy. It’s easy to see why Katharine falls hard and fast for him. Katharine, in turn, was the heart of Blame It on Bath for me. She’s had her confidence and personality beaten down all her life and it’s not until she meets Gerard that she starts to let her true self shine through. I loved watching Katharine come into her own over the course of the story. She and Gerard are such a great pair that I’m sure it won’t be long before I re-read their book — seeing them fall in love was that delightful.

Blame It on Bath is the second full length book in Ms. Linden’s The Truth About the Duke series. Ms. Linden provides enough backstory that readers new to the series don’t have to have read One Night in London to follow along. However, I expect that both One Night in London and Blame It on Bath should be read before the final book is released, as the overarching storyline about the duke’s first marriage will be resolved in the next book. I can’t wait to learn the truth about the duke. And speaking of dukes, after reading Blame It on Bath, I’m more excited than ever before to find out what Ms. Linden has in store for the current Duke of Durham, Charles de Lacey. If his book is even half as good as Blame It on Bath is, readers will be in for a treat!

Reviewed for Joyfully Reviewed.

rachelini's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This was great. A bit unsatisfying at the end, since the story is continuing in the next brother's book, but I enjoyed the relationship, and she writes a good romance.

showmethemonet's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

3.5 Stars. Upon finishing this book I realized that I should have learned more about it before reading -- and then read the first book and proceeded to read the trilogy in order.
As a standalone, the hero's purpose ends on a seriously lame note as the mystery isn't resolved and the story sort of just...ends (and I would've known this had I better prepared...) and I couldn't help but feel its' lack as a point against it without the context of the first book (especially since the setup was well done.)
Other books where a thread weaves throughout have done this in a far more satisfying fashion for the 2nd entry [go read Tessa Dare's unfortunately titled yet incredible Stud Club trilogy!]
Luckily the characters are interesting and their relationship so satisfying that it still earned 3.5 Stars in my book (imagine if the mystery/ending had been handled better!)
Gerard is one of those loveable, jovial, friend to everyone kinds of guys that can be a breath of fresh air after brooding/wounded heroes.
Katherine/Kate is a heroine I felt for when it became so clear
Spoilerher mother was basically the worst and had been holding her back and keeping her down (and downtrodden) for years,
which made her transformation that much more enjoyable. I did feel for her, even at her silliest.