1.48k reviews for:

Binas historia

Maja Lunde, Lotta Eklund

3.66 AVERAGE


Possibly my favourite book, has to be too 3.

Read for book club. I really enjoyed the structure of 3 different time periods and the characters relationships with bees. It told a good story while also being really informative. The story set in the future without bees was especially eye opening! My gripe is that the characters weren’t particularly likable. I want to feel connected to the main character, to root for them. I wasn’t and I didn’t. But I do recommend the book overall. And the hardback wins the award for most beautiful cover.

linnealofgren's review

3.75
inspiring reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Meh.

I'll give this book 3,5 stars because it started out quite weak but really improved towards the end. The more you read, the clearer is the author's (and maybe even the worlds) message. Really enjoyed the three different narratives embedded in different generations. When I read the blurb I was worried that the writing would be artificial at times due to stressing the different times but I was very positively surprised that it was not like this at all. A marvellously natural writing style that tucks into a lovely story of parenthood, an awareness of nature, and looking at life from a different dimension.
challenging hopeful informative reflective slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated
reflective tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No

I was sold when the blurb compared it to Station Eleven and Never Let Me Go, two of my favourite books ever. While the similarities with Never Let Me Go are maybe more related to the writing style this is absolutely enchanting. A parable on family and nature told through the stories of Tao, William and George, a hundred years apart. I would have loved to read a whole book from Tao's perspective, but it was an interesting choice to do it this way. I think a lot of books suffer a little in translation, but I didn't even realise this was a translation until I came to review it, that's how well done it was.

Comparisons to Station Eleven and Never Let Me Go probably set this up to fail for me; a plodding audio production didn’t help.

Give to patrons looking for more dystopian fiction or stories with parent-child relationships who have a tolerance for slow burn plots.

William lebt im England des 19. Jahrhunderts, George in den USA der heutigen Zeit und Tao in China im Jahre 2098.
Klingt erstmal nicht nach vielen Gemeinsamkeiten. Was alle drei verbindet sind die Bienen 🐝
William, der einen neuartigen Bienenstock entwickeln möchte, George, der als Imker versucht um die Runden zu kommen, und Tao, die - weil es in der Zukunft keine Bienen mehr gibt - Bäume von Hand bestäuben muss.
"Die Geschichte der Bienen" wurde viel gelobt, gewann viele Preise. Entsprechend hoch waren meine Erwartungen. Die wurden jedoch ein wenig enttäuscht. Alle drei Hauptpersonen waren mir einfach nicht sympathisch. Sie alle führten unglückliche Ehen und hatten kein sonderlich gutes Verhältnis zu ihren Kindern. Ich hatte Schwierigkeiten, mich wirklich für ihre Probleme (die ja die zentrale Handlung des Buchs war) zu interessieren 🙈
Und über Bienen lernt man auch nicht so viel, wie ich gedacht hätte.
Trotzdem ist es ein informatives Buch, und die dystopische Zukunftsvision ist bedrückend, weil erschreckend realistisch.