Reviews

The Anatomical Shape of a Heart by Jenn Bennett

faeriesparks's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

reread May 2017: nearly two years later and this is still one of my favorite books ever.

heabooknerd's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I love Jenn Bennett’s adult romance series so I was very curious about her writing young adult. I was very happy with this book; it had the quirky, interesting characters, great romance, and wonderful writing that Bennett is known for. I liked that Beatrix was different but didn’t consider herself the misunderstood, moody teenager. She was comfortable with who she was and didn’t feel like she didn’t belong in this world. She was very mature for her age, but considering I was the same way growing up I probably related very strongly to this part of her personality. I also liked the way Bennett portrayed the side characters in the book. For instance, Beatrix’s brother is an openly gay man but his character isn’t used to make a point or be a stereotype; he’s just a character. Bennett always does a great job with characterization so I felt like I really knew the characters as if they were real friends of mine.

I also really liked Jack, though he was pretty perfect in that way that young adult romance heroes often are. But I was ok with that because it’s fiction and sometimes you want your characters to be better than regular people. The reasoning behind Jack’s graffiti was very sweet if a little misguided in terms of legalities but he just wanted to make his sister happy. Though Jack was reluctant to be in a serious relationship he was fascinated by Beatrix and their sweet romance was great to read. This book is very sex-positive with a very open and mature look at sex between teenagers. I respected how Bennett handled this topic as it can be very sensitive but often gets handled poorly in books for young adults.

I loved the book but it didn’t have the same kick that Bennett’s adult romances have for me. This is purely personal preference and I think it mostly comes from not being a teenager anymore and struggling to really connect with young adult books. There was nothing wrong with Bennett’s writing or storytelling, I’m just looking for more adult characters now.

rachd24's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Check out my full review here: https://confessionsofabookgeek.com/2016/04/22/review-night-owls/

I picked up this read based on the beautiful cover (yes, sometimes I am that shallow).

Jack and Bex are reasonably complex teen characters – Jack is from a privileged background and has some family issues going on (mental health related), he’s also an anonymous graffiti artist (in a loveable rogue kind of way). Bex comes from a single parent household, has an out gay brother, and wants to be a medical artist (which is a pretty unusual career choice). For a story that centres on two teen characters and their immediate families, there’s quite a lot going on, which is reflective of real life, but often difficult to translate in a standalone contemporary – Bennett achieves this and then some. On top of all this, parents play an active role in the storyline, which is refreshing as parents are so often absent in contemporary YA, and the story is sex-positive. This in itself was such a winner for me, because realistic portrayals of teen sex scenarios, teen sex conversations, and the reality of teenage hormones and lust are so often avoided, given unnecessary euphemisms, or played down in order to be “safe”.

Overall, this book gave me a big smack in the feels, and was just the right amount of cute and fluffy for a contemporary YA read, while providing a bit more depth and sexy times to entertain an older reader. Highly recommended, and I’d be interested in trying out Bennett’s adult urban fantasy series too!

Rating: 4/5

suzreads95's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional funny fast-paced
  • Loveable characters? Yes

4.5

thesimplereader's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

4.25 ⭐️

I loved Jack & Bex's relationship. Great read.

gillianw's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I'm not generally a huge lover of YA books but once in awhile, one just quietly sneaks up and charms the pants off of you. Rainbow Rowell did it with Eleanor and Park, Jandy Nelson did it with I'll Give You The Sun and Jenn Bennett has done it with The Anatomical Shape Of A Heart. I loved Bennet's Arcadia Bell series and was curious how she would handle the transition to YA. Thankfully, she did not disappoint with this sweet, slightly quirky novel about two teens who bond over a shared love of art while dealing with their own separate family tragedies. A great YA debut for Jenn Bennett.

deepower7's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This was a nice read, but there isn't really much more to say.

fantasynovel's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Three stars is kind of generous for this book. It's really more of a two star book. It has numerous issues: super hot guy who is just so hot omg hot hot hot who OFC falls in love in-freaking-mediately with our MC, Bex. And get this . . . he's Buddhist! Bc that's a trope that has never been used before. "Punk dude searches for mindfulness." THAT'S HOW YOU KNOW HE HAS A HEART. OH, and GET THIS. He GRAFFITIS. What a Punk Buddhist Dude TM is he, amirite? Andhehasatorturedpast. Again, trademarked by YA authors everywhere.

...buuuuut I liked this book. I liked it for a few reasons. I liked Bex's unusual aspirations (I love morbid stuff. Like, love love love it.) And I just . . . I've been so stressed out lately, guys. 11th grade is super hard. I'm tired all the time, stress is literally making me sick, and this book gave me a brief moment of distraction. Bc sometimes all I want to do is read about an unrealistically hot guy who falls in love with a Mary Sue. The book read like high-quality fanfiction. And you know what? Sometimes high-quality self-insert fanfiction is the best way to unwind. You mean I get to ensnare the Punk Buddhist Dude on the train and then we get to make out for the rest of the book? Count me in.

(Also, I found the book was improved if I pictured a young Dean Winchester as Jackson.)

erinbritt's review

Go to review page

5.0

I absolutely adored this book from the way it talks about art and mental health. Sure the romance parts of it might seem cliche to some but it made me really happy. Art and mental health are two very important things to me and to read a book that touched on both was great for me.

mabelyn's review against another edition

Go to review page

lighthearted slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? N/A
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? N/A
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

2.5