Scan barcode
halkid2's review
3.0
I was so looking forward to this book based on my own genealogy work and particularly an interest in learning more about pogroms. (There seems to be very little written about them, certainly not in historical fiction.) But I’m afraid I was very disappointed.
To completely ‘fess up, I wound up skimming most of this book. Just keep that in mind if you read on.
First, my mistake. I thought this was historical fiction and I was looking forward to a fictionalized and emotionally rich account that would show me the human side of the thousands of Jews killed during the period of the pogroms. Unfortunately, the book turned out to be NON-fiction. Not my preferred genre.
Second, I found this very dry non-fiction — a compilation of chronological facts taken from the author’s considerable and detailed research into her family history. With tons of people (some with identical names) to keep track of.
On the plus side, I give the author kudos for shedding light on this seldom addressed chapter of history. And I did get a general sense of the impoverished and ever-threatened lives of Jews living in the Pale of Settlement, along with the many and time-consuming difficulties they faced in trying to leave their homeland for Palestine, another European country, or the United States. I just didn’t expect to have to also wade through the detailed stories of the lives of the author’s many relatives once they came to the U.S. To me, it all became tedious.
I wish Lisa Brahin had used her family story to illuminate the wider picture of Jewish persecution during this period. Instead, reading her book felt more like getting through a too-long and extremely personal term paper.
To completely ‘fess up, I wound up skimming most of this book. Just keep that in mind if you read on.
First, my mistake. I thought this was historical fiction and I was looking forward to a fictionalized and emotionally rich account that would show me the human side of the thousands of Jews killed during the period of the pogroms. Unfortunately, the book turned out to be NON-fiction. Not my preferred genre.
Second, I found this very dry non-fiction — a compilation of chronological facts taken from the author’s considerable and detailed research into her family history. With tons of people (some with identical names) to keep track of.
On the plus side, I give the author kudos for shedding light on this seldom addressed chapter of history. And I did get a general sense of the impoverished and ever-threatened lives of Jews living in the Pale of Settlement, along with the many and time-consuming difficulties they faced in trying to leave their homeland for Palestine, another European country, or the United States. I just didn’t expect to have to also wade through the detailed stories of the lives of the author’s many relatives once they came to the U.S. To me, it all became tedious.
I wish Lisa Brahin had used her family story to illuminate the wider picture of Jewish persecution during this period. Instead, reading her book felt more like getting through a too-long and extremely personal term paper.
More...