Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.93 AVERAGE
3.93 AVERAGE
It started well and the summary made it sound interesting and engaging. The cross between fantasy and SciFi is also good.
But God, the characters drove me crazy. At one point, they make an U-Turn in behaviour and become whiny and boring. I couldn’t care less about them.
The plot meanders. The summary made it sound like it’s quick paced with action and political intrigue and a dash of romance. Instead the romance is suddenly there without a suiting arc that builds it up. It’s pretty much insta love and I hate it.
The magic system is interesting but the author did info dumping at the begin and the reader has to be able to tell the different kinds of magic apart, which is difficult because the Greek words sound all the same to me. It might be easier if you read the printed version because there’s a diagram at the first pages but it’s a pain in the ass as eBook.
The writing is very modern. It feels though as if the author wrote the book at different times because the chapters feel off after a while. The writing style is different. (Which is something that I know from myself if I pick up a writing project after months or years.)
But God, the characters drove me crazy. At one point, they make an U-Turn in behaviour and become whiny and boring. I couldn’t care less about them.
The plot meanders. The summary made it sound like it’s quick paced with action and political intrigue and a dash of romance. Instead the romance is suddenly there without a suiting arc that builds it up. It’s pretty much insta love and I hate it.
The magic system is interesting but the author did info dumping at the begin and the reader has to be able to tell the different kinds of magic apart, which is difficult because the Greek words sound all the same to me. It might be easier if you read the printed version because there’s a diagram at the first pages but it’s a pain in the ass as eBook.
The writing is very modern. It feels though as if the author wrote the book at different times because the chapters feel off after a while. The writing style is different. (Which is something that I know from myself if I pick up a writing project after months or years.)
Writing felt amateur for me and i just wasn't enjoying myself reading it. The plot did have potential and I do appreciate the opportunity to read the ARC, this book just wasn't for me
At first this seems like a typical queer ya book with strict parents and negative attitudes from friends. Soon everything shifts, and the MMC finds himself in Novilem, in a galaxy far away, in a city where people have different superpowers according to their astrology, and where he’s Telos, the chosen one with the ability to control all those houses.
The start was a bit slow and I was struggling to understand all the astrological stuff, but after a while the book really sucked me in, and I couldn’t wait to find out how things would turn out for Casper, and what would be one of his relationship with Helix.
This book is a queer ya dystopian fantasy adventure romance all wrapped into one.
The start was a bit slow and I was struggling to understand all the astrological stuff, but after a while the book really sucked me in, and I couldn’t wait to find out how things would turn out for Casper, and what would be one of his relationship with Helix.
This book is a queer ya dystopian fantasy adventure romance all wrapped into one.
adventurous
hopeful
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
I had been looking for a little sci-fi to sprinkle in my chronic fantasy TBR, and A Circle of Stars was the perfect addition! With a magic system based in astrology, jumping into this story was a delight for my brain - figuring out how it all worked while being immersed in the world of Novilem was a wonderful adventure. If you are looking for relatable characters, a world with lots of secrets to explore, and a wonderfully sweet queer romance, do not hesitate to pick up A Circle of Stars!
I received an ARC of this book and am leaving this review voluntarily.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Homophobia, Sexual assault
Moderate: Drug use
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
This is a captivating YA science-fiction fantasy novel that immerses its readers in a world where astrology and zodiac signs shape both magic and social status. The biggest strength of the book lies in its rich and imaginative world-building, offering a hidden lunar city and a treacherous surface world filled with dangers. The exploration of a society where acceptance of queer individuals coexists with hidden oppression adds depth and complexity.
Casper, the protagonist, undergoes a transformative journey as he is thrust into a new world after facing rejection and violence due to his sexual orientation. The portrayal of Casper's struggle to find acceptance and his quest for belonging is poignant and relatable, shining a light on the emotional toll of societal prejudice. The soft and supportive romance he finds with Helix unfolds in the story and adds a tender layer to the story.
Another of the notable strengths of the book is the politics, as it delves into themes of rebellion against power, difficult choices for the greater good, and the intricate nature of effecting change. The exploration of the dark underbelly beneath the seemingly utopian society adds layers of intrigue.
While the world-building and overall storytelling are strong, it is worth noting that some readers may find the emotional impact of the book slightly restrained. Given the complexity of the topics addressed, a deeper exploration of the characters' emotions and the resonance of their experiences could have intensified the overall impact of the story. This was beautifully done with Casper's beginning but did not follow throughout the story. This might have been a problem with pacing, as good communication between characters tended to resolve things too quickly to hit me emotionally.
Thank you to the author who provided an advanced reader copy. This is an honest review.
Casper, the protagonist, undergoes a transformative journey as he is thrust into a new world after facing rejection and violence due to his sexual orientation. The portrayal of Casper's struggle to find acceptance and his quest for belonging is poignant and relatable, shining a light on the emotional toll of societal prejudice. The soft and supportive romance he finds with Helix unfolds in the story and adds a tender layer to the story.
Another of the notable strengths of the book is the politics, as it delves into themes of rebellion against power, difficult choices for the greater good, and the intricate nature of effecting change. The exploration of the dark underbelly beneath the seemingly utopian society adds layers of intrigue.
While the world-building and overall storytelling are strong, it is worth noting that some readers may find the emotional impact of the book slightly restrained. Given the complexity of the topics addressed, a deeper exploration of the characters' emotions and the resonance of their experiences could have intensified the overall impact of the story. This was beautifully done with Casper's beginning but did not follow throughout the story. This might have been a problem with pacing, as good communication between characters tended to resolve things too quickly to hit me emotionally.
Thank you to the author who provided an advanced reader copy. This is an honest review.
adventurous
challenging
emotional
hopeful
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
“Sometimes the world breaks and we have to learn to live with the pieces left behind.”
I was delighted to receive an advanced copy of “A Circle of Stars” and am leaving this review voluntarily.
A Circle of Stars introduces you to three protagonists and rotates through their perspectives, each presenting a different view into the alien refugee world of Novilem. As you get to know Casper, a homeless, queer teen from Earth who discovers he’s the chosen one, Helix, the dreamboat member of the ruling class, and Talleah, Helix’s friend and member of the mercantile class, the story unfolds at a measured pace, giving you just enough to keep you hooked (and I do mean hooked) but not so much where you’re rushing through the story or slogging along.
The world-building, the politics and the magic system that are the foundation of Novilem’s society are meticulously crafted and present a fresh and modern take on the story of a chosen one. As the story progresses, the attention to detail makes the story really compelling and interesting and really deepens your connection to the characters.
I’ll admit that I found myself occasionally groaning when the POV brought me to Casper, as I found him to be annoying at certain points. But I’m pleased to also report that he grew on me as the story progressed and the shock of being not only kicked out of his home after coming out but also being abducted to an alien world faded and his personality became more prominent.
Also worth noting is the warmth and care with which Casper’s queerness is handled. Helix, in particular, surprised me with how frequently his maturity and empathy served as a salve not just to Casper’s situation, but how it affected me as well. Montgomery writes with compassion and humor, and his characters are complex and relatable.
Ultimately, I found this to be a pretty standard romance embedded within a STUNNER of a sci-fi / fantasy epic. I highly recommend this book to anyone who is looking for a new approach to a “chosen one” narrative, relishes innovation and creativity in their world-building and/or magic systems, or has a penchant for queer visions within genre work.
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
A Circle of Stars by Craig Montgomery is book one in The Stardust Duology. This is the first book I’ve read by this author and what a book it was… it’s queer young adult fantasy filled with plenty political intrigue and romance. But at its core it’s a story of redemption… of becoming a hero that you’re destined to be. This book was so well written I found myself completely lost in the mystique. I read this book cover to cover before I even realized how much time had passed. The magic was described so well… you get powers based on your astrological sign. (How cool is that!?!) The world was and plot was astounding, I found myself trying to imagine how I would do in this world multiple times.
The characters were fantastic, was a huge fan Casper felt so real to me, I felt like I could relate to him. Never feeling like you fit in anywhere; that really struck a chord with me. But then suddenly you meet someone and they give you a reason to fight…to live…a home. I was so invested in Casper and Helix and their fight to try and create a better world. This was such a solid fantasy book, I can’t wait to see what’s in store with book two!
Final review:
4 out of 5 stars
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
**I received an advanced copy of this book and I am leaving this review voluntarily**
If you are looking for an MM sci-fi+fantasy, please read this book! This is a coming of age story that follows Casper, a recently outed high-school senior who is disowned by his family and his journey to being 'the chosen one' to balance an old civilization that lives among the stars.
The magic system and world building are unique and intriguing, Craig does an amazing job of weaving the knowledge throughout the story and doesn't dump it all on you at once. The characters are rich and vibrant (I felt like they were going to jump off the page), I laughed, cheered, and cried with the characters. Craig really made me feel apart of the story experiencing every heartache, celebrations, and mistake.
This book was fantastic and I am definitely looking forward to next one!
If you are looking for an MM sci-fi+fantasy, please read this book! This is a coming of age story that follows Casper, a recently outed high-school senior who is disowned by his family and his journey to being 'the chosen one' to balance an old civilization that lives among the stars.
The magic system and world building are unique and intriguing, Craig does an amazing job of weaving the knowledge throughout the story and doesn't dump it all on you at once. The characters are rich and vibrant (I felt like they were going to jump off the page), I laughed, cheered, and cried with the characters. Craig really made me feel apart of the story experiencing every heartache, celebrations, and mistake.
This book was fantastic and I am definitely looking forward to next one!
adventurous
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
'A Circle of Stars' by Craig Montgomery is an extraordinary queer young adult sci-fi fantasy that captivated me from beginning to end. The electric chemistry between the main characters, Casper and Helix, is beautifully portrayed, and their relationship is a true highlight of the book. Montgomery's masterful storytelling skillfully weaves a sweet and tender romance amidst a backdrop of political intrigue, resulting in a truly engaging story.
The plot follows Casper Bell, a young man who faces the harsh reality of being outed and abandoned by his loved ones. However, his life takes an unexpected turn when he is abducted by the inhabitants of Novilem, a world where magic is granted by the stars. Casper discovers that he possesses the extraordinary ability to harness power from all twelve astrological signs, making him a valuable pawn for the Estellar Council's political agenda. As rebellion looms and the council fractures, Casper and Helix embark on a journey to unravel the secrets of Casper's abilities, as the survival of Novilem hangs in the balance.
One of the standout aspects of 'A Circle of Stars' is the expertly developed political elements within the narrative. Montgomery delves into the complexities of power dynamics and the consequences of political maneuvering, creating a suspenseful atmosphere that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. The book also introduces a unique and enjoyable magic system, adding an extra layer of excitement to the story.
The action scenes in 'A Circle of Stars' are nothing short of exhilarating. Montgomery's vivid descriptions and fast-paced writing style bring these moments to life, making them both thrilling and entertaining. The supporting characters are equally compelling, each contributing depth and complexity to the overall narrative. The interactions between the characters form a tapestry of heartwarming, fun, tense, and intriguing moments that kept me fully immersed in the story.
For fans of queer young adult fiction, sci-fi, and fantasy, 'A Circle of Stars' is an absolute must-read. Craig Montgomery's skillful storytelling and well-developed characters make this novel a joy to experience. Prepare to be swept away by the enchanting tale woven within its pages.
