Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.4 AVERAGE
3.4 AVERAGE
adventurous
challenging
dark
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
A preposterous book. It lay on my shelf at home for years, party to some uncompleted summer reading requirement with a topic irrelevant to my thirteen year-0ld self, now intriguing in our current political context and my presumed maturity.
Well. Half the book is an appreciable depiction of LA racism, stereotypes the root of confirmation bias and irrational responses dreamed up to punish people that the book goes to lengths to depict as helpless if not intermittently criminal. Yes, it is very profound to demonstrate that not all people of a race are the same, but another entirely to subject the reader to the sadist voyerism of a man losing everything he has over and over again and still, because he is mysteriously noble, able to demonstrate kindness to those who have pressed their boot heels to his face over and over again. This behavior seems to ignore any trace of actual human nature and, barring that, all previous experience of this specific character and indeed the entire contents of the book are thrown out because golly gee ain't people good inside.
The main character, a stand-in for the author, demonstrates some kind of forced, non-sequitur insight amidst acting like another cog in his racist machine, but for some reason spins completely out of control at the same time that he continuously admits how wrong he is and how irrationally everyone else is acting. I'm not sure that level of cognitive dissonance is supported by any human psychology. Some might say that's the point.
Altogether, though, the biases inherent in the book skew heavily white privileged and seem to neglect any quality of justice in lieu of the idea that the perpetrators of suffering are excused and deserving of forgiveness because they're white and too narcissistic to emotionally manage the truth of other people's lives.
There is some reflection of reality in that, and there is not always justice in the world, but my general sense after reading this book is that it was designed to re-assure a privileged class that no matter how much they hurt others and how much others suffer, everything will be okay for them. And I'm not sure that sort of postulate should be conveyed to teenagers.
Well. Half the book is an appreciable depiction of LA racism, stereotypes the root of confirmation bias and irrational responses dreamed up to punish people that the book goes to lengths to depict as helpless if not intermittently criminal. Yes, it is very profound to demonstrate that not all people of a race are the same, but another entirely to subject the reader to the sadist voyerism of a man losing everything he has over and over again and still, because he is mysteriously noble, able to demonstrate kindness to those who have pressed their boot heels to his face over and over again. This behavior seems to ignore any trace of actual human nature and, barring that, all previous experience of this specific character and indeed the entire contents of the book are thrown out because golly gee ain't people good inside.
The main character, a stand-in for the author, demonstrates some kind of forced, non-sequitur insight amidst acting like another cog in his racist machine, but for some reason spins completely out of control at the same time that he continuously admits how wrong he is and how irrationally everyone else is acting. I'm not sure that level of cognitive dissonance is supported by any human psychology. Some might say that's the point.
Altogether, though, the biases inherent in the book skew heavily white privileged and seem to neglect any quality of justice in lieu of the idea that the perpetrators of suffering are excused and deserving of forgiveness because they're white and too narcissistic to emotionally manage the truth of other people's lives.
There is some reflection of reality in that, and there is not always justice in the world, but my general sense after reading this book is that it was designed to re-assure a privileged class that no matter how much they hurt others and how much others suffer, everything will be okay for them. And I'm not sure that sort of postulate should be conveyed to teenagers.
What I enjoyed most about this book was the juxtaposition between poverty and a middle class life style. It was amazing how normal is can seem to listen to the problems of the pseudo wealthy and then suddenly transition into the (real) hardships of the illegal Mexican immigrants living in a shanty. The Tortilla Curtain really makes you think about things, even if sometimes Boyle tries a little too much to make the stark comparison between the have's and have nots.
The beginning was an interesting draw in. But as I continue it's become nothing but a dull, rollercoaster of a read that becomes infuriating. The extreme view of two ethnics and their classes became annoying as the constant events progress. These events were overly drawn out in a short span of time which make it unreal. The over detail in the repeated rape scenes are very uncomfortable and maybe sentitive to some readers. The story could have been simple and great if it hadn't over turned into something so dramatic, toxic, chaotic and sadly a ball of ignorance.
Not a happy book. Nor was it in any way a satisfying book.
Not a happy book. Nor was it in any way a satisfying book.
At the least, everyone living in a border state should read this book, although I think every American should read it. It is a realistic story that introduces the reader to the various types of illegal aliens...good and bad. Although I still feel that immigrants should follow the legal path into this country, I now know that this is an idealistic opinion. I know that if I had been unlucky enough to been born into Mexico, I would do anything it takes to give my children a better life.
Probably not a bad book per se but T.C. Boyle's style of writing definitely made it *very* infuriating to finish this book.
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
challenging
emotional
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
I was really excited to read this book, and I hated every page. I just couldn't get beyond how depressing it was. It was all just too much.