Scan barcode
allisonwonderlandreads's review against another edition
emotional
hopeful
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
1.0
This regency second chance romance throws together a duke crafted from a pristine reputation and flawless arrogance and an inventor engineered from brash foolhardiness and determined ingenuity. The best part was seeing Fiona dress in men's clothes to navigate spaces where she isn't allowed on behalf of her business interests. The subterfuge paired with the subversiveness was a delicious combination. I also liked Fiona's burgeoning friendships with the duke's siblings but was less enamored with the romance. It's a classic "controlling man meets uncontrollable woman," fueling an obvious antagonism that is also somehow attraction. I was frustrated by unnecessary recklessness and lies that came between them, but at least I give them credit for genuine personal growth at the end.
Beyond the lackluster romance, it's the politics that sink this one for me, as is often the case. The duke is a "moderate," a descriptor that dating profiles have taught me to react to with complete and utter despair for the person in question and for humanity at large. At one point our duke remarks, "Protests and pitchforks cause a lot of harm for limited gain." And then he gets to be "haunted" because he was endangered by a protest once, as if his status doesn't endanger people daily where he doesn't have to see it. I understand the concern about mob behavior. A certain recent insurrection attempt comes to mind. I think where I struggle is that painting in broad strokes about the dangers of protest removes any nuance from the conversation around power, privilege, and collective action. It's also irresponsible to suggest that a historical venue for the plot removes the need for deeper thought. The contemporary lens of both the author and readers can't help but draw up recent corollaries and applications as we read. Finally, the duke ponders that "centuries of tradition shouldn't be overturned because of one unusual female" to suggest that Fiona's example of facing unfair barriers to her business success doesn't indicate a broken system but rather her own exceptionalism to seek what other women don't. Boohiss.
Beyond the lackluster romance, it's the politics that sink this one for me, as is often the case. The duke is a "moderate," a descriptor that dating profiles have taught me to react to with complete and utter despair for the person in question and for humanity at large. At one point our duke remarks, "Protests and pitchforks cause a lot of harm for limited gain." And then he gets to be "haunted" because he was endangered by a protest once, as if his status doesn't endanger people daily where he doesn't have to see it. I understand the concern about mob behavior. A certain recent insurrection attempt comes to mind. I think where I struggle is that painting in broad strokes about the dangers of protest removes any nuance from the conversation around power, privilege, and collective action. It's also irresponsible to suggest that a historical venue for the plot removes the need for deeper thought. The contemporary lens of both the author and readers can't help but draw up recent corollaries and applications as we read. Finally, the duke ponders that "centuries of tradition shouldn't be overturned because of one unusual female" to suggest that Fiona's example of facing unfair barriers to her business success doesn't indicate a broken system but rather her own exceptionalism to seek what other women don't. Boohiss.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual content
Moderate: Emotional abuse, Sexism, Abandonment, Classism, Suicide, and Toxic relationship
Minor: Pregnancy, Sexual assault, Alcoholism, Infidelity, Injury/Injury detail, and Physical abuse
More...