3.41 AVERAGE

jehanne's review

2.75
challenging dark emotional mysterious reflective medium-paced

nina0's review

3.5
dark reflective fast-paced
abiveeke's profile picture

abiveeke's review

2.5
dark emotional reflective sad slow-paced

It was okay. Some of the poems were thought-provoking and interesting. 
alainaaraee's profile picture

alainaaraee's review

3.5
dark sad medium-paced
laurelinwonder's profile picture

laurelinwonder's review

3.0

I don't recall ever having read any of Oate's poetry previously, and I'm a big fan of her prose. And this covers a lot, this is a big complex collection. I'm just going to say it's not my favorite of her work, I enjoy the short stories, or her more horrific tales and novellas.
azure_dawn's profile picture

azure_dawn's review

2.0

DNF
I can’t read poetry cuz there is no ryhmes
Can’t understand what author was going on about

scoobygirl93's review

3.0

3.5*
Favorites:
Jubilate: An Homage in Catterel* Verse
American Sign Language

gvenezia's review

2.0

Pop Culture Melancholy: In which a celebrated author commits her musings on American culture to verse.
The musings are mostly just okay.

There are some weird, cold, atonal poems about psychology experiments, including the cliched Milgram. I've never read any poems about social science, Oates's examples didn't inspire much confidence in their potential.

There's a long, somewhat uncomfortable ode to Marlon Brando—man of many tribulations and triumphs.

There's a very Billy-Collins, serious-cheeky concrete poem about a kite that's about America.

The best poem is a tribute to William Carlos William and it borrows his style.

The shortest poems hold the most potential, but seems to stop too short:

"Exsanguination"
Life as it unspools
ever more eludes
examination

We wonder what is best—
exsanguination in a rush,
or in 1,000 small slashes.

The best stanza that does stand well alone is the last one (context: "In hospice time ceases . . . Until at last the deepest sigh of a lifetime . . .):

After such struggle
you must love
the unrippled dark
water in which a
the perfect cold O
of the moon floats.

signedmary's review

4.0

So many beautiful poems. Some where challenging- which is very much what I needed and wanted. she puts many feelings of hope and loss and hopelessness and discontent with human cruelty into beautiful words.
trippalli's profile picture

trippalli's review

3.0
informative reflective medium-paced

Informative feminist poetry, often citing acts of ethical failures in real history