3.61 AVERAGE

slow-paced
adventurous challenging dark informative reflective sad tense medium-paced

A comprehensive short story collection between June and December of 1943, during the second world war. 
Most stories are enticing and keep you on your knees, begging the men to see the light of a new day. 
The book does a beautiful job of showing gruesomeness without vulgarizing it. 
The main issue with this format is that I felt disconnected from the characters. Not even to the narrator. 

Glad I read it. I enjoyed the introduction where Steinbeck talks about the pressure to support the war effort while he was working. You can definitely see it in his writing. There were some genuinely funny moments: the rumination on the way that the English v Americans eat vegetables, the soldier who carried a giant mirror through a war zone because he wanted to take it home with him, Lt. Goat.
challenging emotional informative inspiring lighthearted sad slow-paced
fast-paced
challenging informative sad tense slow-paced
dark funny informative medium-paced

I thought it was great for what it is. Do not think it’s a novel or a cohesive story, it isn’t. And do NOT take it at face value. Please read Steinbeck’s own introduction. He says plainly that his writings are only barely true because of the propaganda elements and “war effort” and censorship he was under sling with all war correspondents. However, his writing is charming and vivid and poignant nonetheless. It felt like watching MASH and specifically the episodes where the characters were writing letters home and narrating their lives in their day to day moments.

I loved how he wrote but know that what he wrote is at least partly fiction for the sake of getting it published and he is very up front about it himself.
informative medium-paced
roenfoe's profile picture

roenfoe's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH: 6%

I've decided I don't care to read this after all. The introduction was enough to tell me this will likely not be my speed.