Scan barcode
adularia25's review
4.0
I very much enjoyed the stories in this collection by Anna Katherine Green. They really stood out from the rest. Even if this book did only include the first chapter of her collection with detective Amelia Butterworth - which means I'll have to hunt down the rest of the tale to find out how it ends!
Other good authors in the collection are:
Andrew Forrester Jr. (a presumed pen-name, no one really knows the true name of the author), also stood out with a story from The Revelations of a Private Detective a series with detective Mrs. G-. The tale was a lot of fun with constant action, and Mrs. G- with her snarky comments feels like she could be transposed into modern times.
C.L. (Catherine Louisa) Pirkis with a tale from her series The Experiences of Loveday Brooke, Lady Detective which is unique for two reasons: (1) Brooke is the first female detective written by a female author and (2) Brooke never ends up married. I'll be hunting down more of her stories.
Grant Allen with Miss Cayley's Adventures, the story itself is highly amusing because of Cayley's voice and there is the bonus that she is definitely not all white - she has a dark complexion, black curly hair, and dark brown eyes. Her voice is strong and refreshing, and I'd gladly read the rest of her adventures.
M. McDonnell Bodkin's story about Dora Myrl which appeared in the collection was good - but I've heard his tale where he has Dora meet Paul Beck (another detective he created) is supposed to be one of the worst written (the author could not write love stories...) so while I might read more of Dora's tales, I'm going to steer clear of when she meets Paul. However, he does get accolades for being the first author to have a crime-solving family that worked on cases together.
Then there are some OK authors:
George R. Sims with a story from Dorcas Dene, Detective: Her Life and Adventures. He was a contemporary with Arthur Conan Doyle and modeled Dorcas off of Holmes to a certain extent - in a good way (unlike some of the other female detectives in the collection who were also based off of Holmes). The story wouldn't be bad, but it was very dated... very Victorian in feel. However, I will be reading more of his works. I'd like to see if other tales about Dorcas are as stilted as this one, or if it is an outlier. Dorcas was fun to read as she solved the crime, it was the crime that was very Victorian. Unlike the next author.
W. S. Hayward with a story from Revelations of a Lady Detective has the distinction of being the oldest "true" detective novel featuring a female detective, but Mrs. Paschal is very Victorian in feel. She does act modern in some ways, she is at least smart enough to remove her petticoats when climbing through trap doors in cellars, but she still obeys a great many restrictions of Victorian society. It would be hard to imagine her transported out of her time, unlike some of the other detectives in the collection, but I'm glad a tale about her was included in the collection.
And then you get to the authors I just didn't like.
Mary E. Wilkins wasn't normally a writer of detective stories, so the tale included by her just wasn't up to the rest of the tales in the collection. Though Sarah Fairbanks was a rather unique amateur detective - she was extremely thorough when searching for clues. Mostly I didn't like the tone of the tale, so I likely won't be searching out her other stories.
Richard Marsh (pen name of Richard Bernard Heldmann) was a prolific writer in his day, and wrote many stories in many genres, but was more famous for his tales of exotic atmospheric horror. I don't like how he writes the female detective in the tale that was included (Judith Lee from Judith Lee, Some Pages from Her Life), but I might look into his collection Curios: Some Strange Adventures of Two Bachelors. I have a feeling he writes male characters a bit better.
And saving the worst for last, Hugh C. Weir, who created Miss Madelyn Mack, Detective. Madelyn isn't just a Mary Sue, she is exactly like Holmes (even down to a Coca - cocaine berry - addiction, which she keeps in a locket around her neck) if you just replace playing the violin with gardening... She is too much of a character to be real! She only ever dresses in all black or all white - we're introduced to her in all white, with even the flowers on her desk matching... it's just bizarre. And not only is her name alliterative, her "Watson" is Nora Noraker a journalist who exclusively covers her exploits. It's too much! It is almost, almost into the territory of a parody, but it takes itself too seriously to ever be one. I'm not likely to read anything else by Weir if that's how he tackles female detectives! (Though I could see these as being made into modern TV shows - they have that sort of tabloid quality to them.)
Other good authors in the collection are:
Andrew Forrester Jr. (a presumed pen-name, no one really knows the true name of the author), also stood out with a story from The Revelations of a Private Detective a series with detective Mrs. G-. The tale was a lot of fun with constant action, and Mrs. G- with her snarky comments feels like she could be transposed into modern times.
C.L. (Catherine Louisa) Pirkis with a tale from her series The Experiences of Loveday Brooke, Lady Detective which is unique for two reasons: (1) Brooke is the first female detective written by a female author and (2) Brooke never ends up married. I'll be hunting down more of her stories.
Grant Allen with Miss Cayley's Adventures, the story itself is highly amusing because of Cayley's voice and there is the bonus that she is definitely not all white - she has a dark complexion, black curly hair, and dark brown eyes. Her voice is strong and refreshing, and I'd gladly read the rest of her adventures.
M. McDonnell Bodkin's story about Dora Myrl which appeared in the collection was good - but I've heard his tale where he has Dora meet Paul Beck (another detective he created) is supposed to be one of the worst written (the author could not write love stories...) so while I might read more of Dora's tales, I'm going to steer clear of when she meets Paul. However, he does get accolades for being the first author to have a crime-solving family that worked on cases together.
Then there are some OK authors:
George R. Sims with a story from Dorcas Dene, Detective: Her Life and Adventures. He was a contemporary with Arthur Conan Doyle and modeled Dorcas off of Holmes to a certain extent - in a good way (unlike some of the other female detectives in the collection who were also based off of Holmes). The story wouldn't be bad, but it was very dated... very Victorian in feel. However, I will be reading more of his works. I'd like to see if other tales about Dorcas are as stilted as this one, or if it is an outlier. Dorcas was fun to read as she solved the crime, it was the crime that was very Victorian. Unlike the next author.
W. S. Hayward with a story from Revelations of a Lady Detective has the distinction of being the oldest "true" detective novel featuring a female detective, but Mrs. Paschal is very Victorian in feel. She does act modern in some ways, she is at least smart enough to remove her petticoats when climbing through trap doors in cellars, but she still obeys a great many restrictions of Victorian society. It would be hard to imagine her transported out of her time, unlike some of the other detectives in the collection, but I'm glad a tale about her was included in the collection.
And then you get to the authors I just didn't like.
Mary E. Wilkins wasn't normally a writer of detective stories, so the tale included by her just wasn't up to the rest of the tales in the collection. Though Sarah Fairbanks was a rather unique amateur detective - she was extremely thorough when searching for clues. Mostly I didn't like the tone of the tale, so I likely won't be searching out her other stories.
Richard Marsh (pen name of Richard Bernard Heldmann) was a prolific writer in his day, and wrote many stories in many genres, but was more famous for his tales of exotic atmospheric horror. I don't like how he writes the female detective in the tale that was included (Judith Lee from Judith Lee, Some Pages from Her Life), but I might look into his collection Curios: Some Strange Adventures of Two Bachelors. I have a feeling he writes male characters a bit better.
And saving the worst for last, Hugh C. Weir, who created Miss Madelyn Mack, Detective. Madelyn isn't just a Mary Sue, she is exactly like Holmes (even down to a Coca - cocaine berry - addiction, which she keeps in a locket around her neck) if you just replace playing the violin with gardening... She is too much of a character to be real! She only ever dresses in all black or all white - we're introduced to her in all white, with even the flowers on her desk matching... it's just bizarre. And not only is her name alliterative, her "Watson" is Nora Noraker a journalist who exclusively covers her exploits. It's too much! It is almost, almost into the territory of a parody, but it takes itself too seriously to ever be one. I'm not likely to read anything else by Weir if that's how he tackles female detectives! (Though I could see these as being made into modern TV shows - they have that sort of tabloid quality to them.)
northerly_heart_reads's review
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
secretbookcase's review
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
bev_reads_mysteries's review
3.0
It is very difficult for me to rate this one. The stories represent a nice selection of early detective fiction--particularly those that feature female protagonists. They are all interesting and well-written. And I certainly recommend the anthology to anyone interested in this era of detective fiction. My difficulty? Well, Michael Sims makes a point of saying that he has made an effort to include stories that have not been reprinted--or that have not been reprinted as much as other stories by the same authors. It's odd then that of the eleven stories here, only four are new to me--I don't count the excerpt from Anna Katherine Green's longer work. And I've read all of the others within the last two years. I was looking forward to some fresh stories and I guess the disappointment of that expectation has somewhat colored my response to this anthology. If you haven't read much of the early works of detective fiction, then you're in for a treat. As for me, I'm giving the collection a solid three star rating.
Here's a run-down of the stories:
"The Mysterious Countess" (1864, possibly 1861) by W. S. Hayward. This is the first story to feature a female professional detective--Mrs. Paschal. She is adept at putting herself into any role requested. In this one she poses as a servant so she might discover the source of the Countess of Vervaine's seemingly endless supply of money....despite the lack of visible signs of support. Mrs. Paschal braves underground tunnels and has to track her quarry down in a distant village before she gets to the bottom of the mystery.
"The Unknown Weapon" (1864) by Andrew Forrester. It is about the death of the son of a miserly old man who is killed while apparently in the the process of breaking into his own father's house. He has been stabbed with a weapon that no seems to be able to identify. This story has the honor of being quite probably the first novel about the Metropolitan Police (formed in 1829) , the first modern detective novel, and the first novel featuring a professional female detective. She is absolutely unnamed in this particular outing, but in other stories by Forrester, she is referred to as Mrs. G---- of the Metropolitan Police. She makes reference to herself and another female officer as constables...and I find it interesting to have references to female constables at this early date. Mrs. G---- is a thoroughly scientific detective, reminding the reader of Holmes. Had she the advantages of his training at university, I'm sure she would have examined her own bits of fluff under the microscope rather than sending them off in a tin box and directing "it to the gentleman who is good enough to control these kind of investigations." She faithfully takes up every piece of evidence, giving it a more thorough going-over than the local constable, looks over the scene of the crime, and thinks the problem through with logic that Holmes could not fault. There is no "feminine intuition" at work; it is a thoughtful, orderly investigation. The grand finale is a bit of a let-down--but over all a very good early detective story.
"Drawn Daggers" by C. L. Pirkis (1893). Starring Loveday Brooke--the first known female detective created by a female author. Miss Brooke is presented as not only an intelligent and independent young woman, but as a woman who has taken up the profession because she is good at it. She's not supporting a sister or a disabled husband. She's not ultra-feminine to make up for her brains. She's just a good detective. I have long had The Experiences of Loveday Brooks, Lady Detective on my list of books to look for. "Daggers Drawn" pays homage to Sherlock Holmes and I find Miss Brooks' way of keeping clues to herself very much in the Holmes style. Very feminist characterization for the time period.
"The Long Arm" by Mary Wilkins (1895). Not really a female detective. Sarah Fairbanks finds herself suspected of her father's murder--because her father disapproved of the man she loved. There are other suspects--and several clues, like where are her father's overalls and where did the yellow ribbon come from?
The Affair Next Door, Ch. 1 (1897) by Anna Katherine Green. I'm a bit disappointed with this one--not in the writing itself, but that our editor chose to include a chapter of a longer work. It doesn't really give us a feel for Amelia Butterworth and since it's not a self-contained story, it leaves me unsatisfied.
"The Man with the Wild Eyes" by George Robert Sims (1897). Starring Dorcas Dene, a former actress who seems adept at assuming any role. In this one she masquerades as a private nurse in order to find out why a man's daughter claims to have had a fainting fit when it's obvious she's been attacked--and nearly strangled at that.
"The Adventure of the Cantankerous Old Lady" by Grant Allen (1899). This one features Lois Cayley, a recent graduate of Girton College, and down to her last two pence. She agrees to be the companion to a rather cantankerous old lady--saving the lady's jewelry in the process. Not a strict mystery, but a lovely period piece showing the "New Woman" of the late Victorian era--and one of the few stories I hadn't encountered before.
"How He Cut His Stick" by M. McDonnell Bodkin (1900). Starring Dora Myrl, a glamorous professional detective known at the time her stories came out as "A Sherlock Holmes in petticoats." She is no-nonsense and definitely know how the stick got cut in this tale of the missing 5,000 British pounds.
"The Man Who Cut Off My Hair" by Richard Marsh [aka Richard Bernard Heldmann] (1912). Judith Lee is a young girl who has the gift of reading lips. This gift and her fierce anger when the man cuts off her hair allow her to help the police bring a gang of jewel and precious metal thieves to justice.
"The Man With Nine Lives' by Hugh C. Weir (1914). Madelyn Mack, an "ordinary working detective" who is very Holmes-like--complete with a faithful Watson in the form of a female reporter and an addiction of her own (to a cola stimulant that helps her go without sleep and almost without food while on a case). A man sends a letter to Miss Mack claiming that eight attempts have been made on his life and he fears that a ninth will be made--successfully. He begs her to hurry to aid him. She does, but too late, and finds herself searching for an apparent madman as the culprit.
"The Second Bullet" by Anna Katherine Green (1915). This one features Green's other female detective, Violet Strange. Miss Strange is the most upper-crust of all the detectives in this anthology. She is a society girl for the most part who takes on cases that suit her so she can earn money to help a sister who was unjustly disinherited. "The Second Bullet" is the most tragic of the stories included...Miss Strange must prove that a woman's husband did not commit suicide--a death that resulted in the loss of her child as well. To do so, she must discover what happened to the second bullet.
This was first posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.
Here's a run-down of the stories:
"The Mysterious Countess" (1864, possibly 1861) by W. S. Hayward. This is the first story to feature a female professional detective--Mrs. Paschal. She is adept at putting herself into any role requested. In this one she poses as a servant so she might discover the source of the Countess of Vervaine's seemingly endless supply of money....despite the lack of visible signs of support. Mrs. Paschal braves underground tunnels and has to track her quarry down in a distant village before she gets to the bottom of the mystery.
"The Unknown Weapon" (1864) by Andrew Forrester. It is about the death of the son of a miserly old man who is killed while apparently in the the process of breaking into his own father's house. He has been stabbed with a weapon that no seems to be able to identify. This story has the honor of being quite probably the first novel about the Metropolitan Police (formed in 1829) , the first modern detective novel, and the first novel featuring a professional female detective. She is absolutely unnamed in this particular outing, but in other stories by Forrester, she is referred to as Mrs. G---- of the Metropolitan Police. She makes reference to herself and another female officer as constables...and I find it interesting to have references to female constables at this early date. Mrs. G---- is a thoroughly scientific detective, reminding the reader of Holmes. Had she the advantages of his training at university, I'm sure she would have examined her own bits of fluff under the microscope rather than sending them off in a tin box and directing "it to the gentleman who is good enough to control these kind of investigations." She faithfully takes up every piece of evidence, giving it a more thorough going-over than the local constable, looks over the scene of the crime, and thinks the problem through with logic that Holmes could not fault. There is no "feminine intuition" at work; it is a thoughtful, orderly investigation. The grand finale is a bit of a let-down--but over all a very good early detective story.
"Drawn Daggers" by C. L. Pirkis (1893). Starring Loveday Brooke--the first known female detective created by a female author. Miss Brooke is presented as not only an intelligent and independent young woman, but as a woman who has taken up the profession because she is good at it. She's not supporting a sister or a disabled husband. She's not ultra-feminine to make up for her brains. She's just a good detective. I have long had The Experiences of Loveday Brooks, Lady Detective on my list of books to look for. "Daggers Drawn" pays homage to Sherlock Holmes and I find Miss Brooks' way of keeping clues to herself very much in the Holmes style. Very feminist characterization for the time period.
"The Long Arm" by Mary Wilkins (1895). Not really a female detective. Sarah Fairbanks finds herself suspected of her father's murder--because her father disapproved of the man she loved. There are other suspects--and several clues, like where are her father's overalls and where did the yellow ribbon come from?
The Affair Next Door, Ch. 1 (1897) by Anna Katherine Green. I'm a bit disappointed with this one--not in the writing itself, but that our editor chose to include a chapter of a longer work. It doesn't really give us a feel for Amelia Butterworth and since it's not a self-contained story, it leaves me unsatisfied.
"The Man with the Wild Eyes" by George Robert Sims (1897). Starring Dorcas Dene, a former actress who seems adept at assuming any role. In this one she masquerades as a private nurse in order to find out why a man's daughter claims to have had a fainting fit when it's obvious she's been attacked--and nearly strangled at that.
"The Adventure of the Cantankerous Old Lady" by Grant Allen (1899). This one features Lois Cayley, a recent graduate of Girton College, and down to her last two pence. She agrees to be the companion to a rather cantankerous old lady--saving the lady's jewelry in the process. Not a strict mystery, but a lovely period piece showing the "New Woman" of the late Victorian era--and one of the few stories I hadn't encountered before.
"How He Cut His Stick" by M. McDonnell Bodkin (1900). Starring Dora Myrl, a glamorous professional detective known at the time her stories came out as "A Sherlock Holmes in petticoats." She is no-nonsense and definitely know how the stick got cut in this tale of the missing 5,000 British pounds.
"The Man Who Cut Off My Hair" by Richard Marsh [aka Richard Bernard Heldmann] (1912). Judith Lee is a young girl who has the gift of reading lips. This gift and her fierce anger when the man cuts off her hair allow her to help the police bring a gang of jewel and precious metal thieves to justice.
"The Man With Nine Lives' by Hugh C. Weir (1914). Madelyn Mack, an "ordinary working detective" who is very Holmes-like--complete with a faithful Watson in the form of a female reporter and an addiction of her own (to a cola stimulant that helps her go without sleep and almost without food while on a case). A man sends a letter to Miss Mack claiming that eight attempts have been made on his life and he fears that a ninth will be made--successfully. He begs her to hurry to aid him. She does, but too late, and finds herself searching for an apparent madman as the culprit.
"The Second Bullet" by Anna Katherine Green (1915). This one features Green's other female detective, Violet Strange. Miss Strange is the most upper-crust of all the detectives in this anthology. She is a society girl for the most part who takes on cases that suit her so she can earn money to help a sister who was unjustly disinherited. "The Second Bullet" is the most tragic of the stories included...Miss Strange must prove that a woman's husband did not commit suicide--a death that resulted in the loss of her child as well. To do so, she must discover what happened to the second bullet.
This was first posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.
bookchantment's review
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
whats_margaret_reading's review
4.0
This anthology collects short stories and an excerpt from a novel, all detective fiction in the late Victorian era that all feature female detectives. These characters investigate locked room mysteries, thefts, and other now standard devices in modern detective fiction. What I found especially impressive was that these stories are all very forward looking. These detectives, in addition to being women, use forensic science to analyze fingerprints and, in one case, "fluff" on a murder victim. With the forward looking science and methods of investigation, there are also a couple instances where the attitudes of the time period in which these were written (the average of the years is about 1895) is obviously apparent. In one case, the reporter side-kick of the detective recommended that she just needed a good cry (as advice from one professional woman to another). Overall, the detective story is emerging with a new type of investigator in this collection which makes a fun read as well as an interesting insight into the evolution of the detective story.
meghan_is_reading's review
delightful, only how annoying that most of the referenced books are out of print or otherwise not easily available! I suppose I should be grateful these were reprinted.
lizdesole's review
4.0
Fun book of short stories that depict Victorian women as protagonists: mostly detectives. I had expected more to be written by women but the stories were interesting and the author bios were as well. I did enjoy the portrayals of pioneering women in the crime-fighting field