Reviews with content warning for Death - Sea of Ruin

After my read of To Kill A Kingdom I found myself really craving a sexy, magical pirate story. I wanted Pirates of the Caribbean meets smut…that’s how I found this book, and oh boy…I DEVOURED EVERY PAGE.

Is this my favorite book of all time with absolutely no criticism? Not at all. But, did I love every page and did it fill my need for such a book? YES.

So what did I love? A strong, sassy, MC who is fierce and not afraid to be the badass she is. A tall dark and handsome love interest that is smooth talking with eyes for only our MC and will slay the world to get her back. A loyal crew that is more like friends that stand by our MC through the worst of times without question. A second love interest that is poised and beautiful that falls apart for no one else.

What didn’t I love? Well…
I hate talking bad about this book, but there were things I wasn’t a fan of. The biggest one would be Bennet’s time on the HMS Blitz. I was so looking forward to watching how Bennet navigated being part of ship that wasn’t hers and had such a different culture, but instead we spent literally the entire time in the bedroom obsessing over sex. Now I am as horny as the next smut reader, but it just seemed like too much and really started to feel repetitive and like I was missing out on any plot during that time.

Also…I understand this was a smutty book, and I went into it with the expectations of there being a lot…but the entire plot revolved around sex, and by the end it started to feel like too much. How is it possible that throughout the entire time of this book and every situation Bennet found herself in the one and only focus and solution to any problem was sex?

Need information? Seduce, repeatedly.
Get captured? Immediate SA attempt.
Saved from SA attempt and need an escape plan? Seduce
Taken to another ship? Repeatedly assaulted.
Saved from ship? Reward with sex.
Need another escape plan? Sex.

And that’s like…only half the book. I just felt that there could have been some other focus in the book instead of everything revolving around sex.

Content Warnings

readyourbookshelf's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? No
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.0

Content Warnings

friends2lovers's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional medium-paced

4.0

Author: Pam Godwin
Series: None, this is a standalone. (There is a prequel short story called King of Libertines, but it's not necessary to read it at all. If you do, it can be read before or after Sea of Ruin.)
Genre: dark historical romance
Setting: mostly 1721 (early Georgian era) in the West Indies
Main Characters: Bennett Sharp, Priest Farrell, Ashley Cutler
Tropes: pirates, adventure, estranged marriage, captor/captive, ménage (MMF)
Format: Kindle ebook (own), published April 28, 2020, © 2020
Length: 555 pages, 151k words
Steam Level: 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥(5 out of 5) - High Steam
Sexual Content:

There were 5 full, explicit sex scenes plus at least 6 additional scenes that I wouldn't count as flames/full scenes. A lot of explicit descriptions and mentions throughout of sexual attraction and arousal. Includes anal (noncon/dubcon), spanking as discipline (dubcon), voyeurism, ménage à trois (MMF with minimal on-page MM interactions), and forced exhibitionism

Spoiler Warning!
I was having trouble with the spoiler tags, so I'm just giving a warning upfront that this entire review contains spoilers!

I can see why this is a 5-star read for a lot of people. For me, there were moments and aspects of this that were worthy of 5-stars. But, I like to reserve a 5-star rating for my absolute favorite books, the ones that I wouldn’t change a thing about. And Sea of Ruin doesn’t quite meet that standard. Overall, I found it a compelling, interesting read that I couldn’t put down once I got to the good stuff around a quarter of the way in. I would recommend it with caveats. This is a dark historical romance. Check the content warnings at the bottom of this review. Rest assured there is an HEA but it's not a traditional one - The book ends with the heroine in a polyamorous MMF relationship with two men.

He was, quite unfortunately, a handsome son of a bitch. Inarguably handsome, but in a rigid, chillingly regal manner.

Hands down, my favorite part of this book is the character of Ashley Cutler. I didn’t truly become engrossed in the story until Bennet is held captive on his ship. There’s just something about a buttoned up, seemingly cold/unfeeling hero bottling up his emotions, hiding secrets, and on the edge of losing control. I also really loved all the adventure! The only other historical pirate romances I’ve read have been low on sea-faring action. This was not at all lacking in that regard! Surprisingly, I also really dug the darker content and themes, if only because it raised the stakes. I’ve said many, many times before that I prefer historical romance to contemporary because it’s usually higher stakes. I think I need to delve into some other subgenres like dark romance or romantic suspense to get the higher stakes that I want. I definitely plan to try more of Pam Godwin’s backlist.

A lot of what I didn’t like about Sea of Ruin is related to being in the heroine’s first person point of view for the entire narrative. The focus on the heroine was probably the best choice for the story Godwin was telling, but it did not work for me on several levels. The suspense is magnified, but there were many times I would have liked to see what was happening with other characters or get inside their heads. Despite being in Bennett's head the whole time, I didn’t get a good sense of her characterization beyond a surface level archetype - beautiful and badass. Since the heroine is a hoydenish type, I didn’t always like her perspective and could have used a break.

Typically, a first-person POV would be effective at conveying the emotional depth of the main character. While Bennett is obviously distressed and in pain while these things are happening to her, the violence and torture she endures throughout the book do not traumatize, change, or otherwise affect her long-term in a profoundly meaningful way. Without those plot points being a catalyst for dynamic character growth, the constant violence just seems over the top and gratuitous. Perhaps Godwin deliberately chose not to dwell on the trauma so as not to bog down the narrative or create too morbid of a mood. To me, it kind of felt like a repetitive loop where Bennett is abused and violated, she escapes or is rescued, she does a reset to normal, then is thrown back into a dire situation. Violence, escape, return to normal, repeat.

Most importantly, the centrality of the heroine and her POV detracted from the most compelling relationship in the story: Priest/Ashley. I quite honestly would not give a fig if the ending of this had excluded Bennett from the picture. I guess I just love a forbidden romance between characters with a history. (I had a similar affinity for Val and Peter in Kate Pearce’s House of Pleasure series, whose relationship has parallels to Priest/Ashley) All the good romantic angst in this book is happening between Priest and Ashley, but since they’re only shown through Bennett’s limited perspective, their connection within the MMF triad is somewhat diminished.

I hated that we aren’t privy to any of their private conversations or interactions, especially between the time when Priest rescues them from Madwulf’s ship and Bennett wakes after her fever. In the single on-page MMF sex scene, Ashley and Priest kiss, but that’s it. And when summarizing their sexual encounters thereafter, Bennett’s narrative says Priest and Ashley “[...] never showed an inclination to fuck each other. I was their one and only focus.” This was extremely disappointing considering the build up to the reveal that Ashley was the secret lover that Priest cheated on Bennett with. To my disappointment, up until this point the romance was MFM, not MMF. Thankfully, things turn around and the way Godwin wrote their relationship actually serves a purpose and makes sense; the why of it just didn’t dawn on me until later. The last time they had seen each other, Ashley rejected Priest and they’ve been estranged ever since. It’s only after Ashley gives up everything and returns to them that Ashley and Priest finally have sex. It’s recounted after the fact from Bennet’s POV, but it does happen! So, my interpretation of all this is that Priest would not want to resume relations with Ashley unless he knew that Ashley was in it for the long haul and no longer in denial about his feelings.

“I don’t know what to call it…this invisible thing that wraps so tightly around us. All I know is that I want to protect it, guard it with my life, and never let it go. This isn’t something that needs mending or burying. It’s raw and honest and perfect, and you damn well know it.” Priest leaned back enough to hold Ashley’s gaze. “I love you.”
Ashley’s chest hitched, his expression so unguarded I felt his longing in my bones.
“You like hearing me say that to you?” Priest tangled his hands in Ashley’s hair, holding their faces together. “I love you, and I will keep fighting for us."

The longing! I’m glad the relationship moving forward will be a true MMF one. I just…sigh…would have loved to see more of Priest/Ashley untangling all their complicated feelings on-page in their own POVs, not through someone else’s.

Finally, I would like to know if the reader is meant to be completely in the dark about Priest/Ashley just like Bennett was. I read a spoiler review of this before starting it, so I knew that Ashley was the person that Priest cheated with. So perhaps that's why I picked up on all the breadcrumbs throughout and it seemed so obvious to me. I couldn't tell if the reveal was supposed to be shocking or not.

Content Warnings

adhara13's review against another edition

Go to review page

Content Warnings

sydney_foshee's review against another edition

Go to review page

This one maybe was a bit too dark for me and pretty graphic... I may have to circle back around to it when I can handle it... or not.

Content Warnings

ameliajag's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional mysterious tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.25

Content Warnings

vero_lee's review against another edition

Go to review page

A+ for effort. unfortunately, this isn’t my cup of tea. I couldn’t even bring myself to finish it.

I highly recommend skipping the first five chapters, minimum.

I understand it’s a pirate story, so violence should be expected. However, I thought the amount of rape and torture was too much. Gratuitous, even.

Content Warnings

elishaj's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

A Pirate Erotica.
I completely,fell in love w both love interest.
I felt every pain the protagonist went through but her heart was her greatest enemy & her best asset. Her love has no borders and it’s so true and that was the driving force of the book.
I did not expect the plot twist but it was a definitely a surprise.
At times reading this book was extremely difficult but the author is talented. And I admire that she was able to tell this whole story in one book.

Content Warnings

More...