Reviews

Night at the Vulcan by Ngaio Marsh

tarshka's review

Go to review page

2.0

One of Ngaio Marsh's many theater-related mysteries. It doesn't stand out to me.

cardica's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

On Death of the Reader's 2020 recommendations this Review Season, we placed Opening Night/Night at the Vulcan in fifteenth. This novel, amongst her other contributions to revitalising theatre in New Zealand led to [a:Ngaio Marsh|68144|Ngaio Marsh|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1237946649p2/68144.jpg]'s Damehood in 1966, and as such makes a fascinating look into the theatre culture she loved so much.

The Vulcan begins by following the frantic thoughts of our heroine, Martyn Tarne, a young woman who acts as our point of view and as our humanising Watson throughout the story, she is desperate for work and ends up having greatness thrust open her as she finds an important part in the grand re-opening night of the Vulcan theatre. She begins as the makeup lady of the lead actor but ends up on stage for the titular opening night. This leads to various promises and threats kicking off in the background as the characters squabble both openly and quietly over how the play should be handled, and this is one of the great strengths of the work. The book spends the bulk of its time exploring the character dynamics within this theatre and Marsh really works to capture the atmosphere in the final week before a big play is opened. As a student of drama myself I felt recollections of my own experiences bubbling beneath the surface of my memory, both positive and negative, from the well-meaning stagehand Jacque to the overbearing lead actors and actresses giving Miss Tarne all the trouble that they’re worth. Without telling all the plot is full of flavour and intrigue, right up until the final moments.

The Vulcan theatre is the true star of our story with its dim passageways and claustrophobic actors quarters, its ostentatious stage and the shifty characters found within. The murder of the story doesn’t occur until nearly the end of the tale, and as such we don’t spend a lot of time actually looking for clues, but rather stumbling across them as Tarne travels from person to person and explores the ins and outs of the creaky building, brought to life once more and seeking to forget its tragic past. And this is the hook, of course, when the murder finally does occur it echoes the murderous tragedy that closed it down years ago, and Roderick Alleyn is brought in to put a stop on the case and to close the theatre’s bloody history once and for all.

This is where the wheels start to fall off the proverbial theatre. The characters on the stage and the stage’s character are the stars of the show, but the mystery suffers from being obtuse at best. The clues are laid out in such a manner that figuring out this mystery is only feasibly if you are well studied on the ins and outs of murder mystery tropes, and a little lucky. As I mentioned before the mystery only really comes to the forefront in the last couple of chapters and so the story doesn’t lend itself enough stagetime in the final act to properly wrap things up. A half-hearted attempt is made to justify our murder and then everybody goes home. For our detective Alleyn this is no doubt an internally cathartic mystery, as he was involved in the previous murderous disaster at the Vulcan theatre years prior, but for the reader you’re left with some solid character arcs but a lacking conclusion to the tumultuous tale.

Opening Night at the Vulcan occupies a respectable position at 15th place being an interesting read with a genuine insight into the theatre and the chaos that is the opening week, I myself have a theatre background and I have to say that the feelings Martyn Tarne expresses and the strange cocktail of dread tension and excitement that all of the members of the production proclaim are true to life. For me personally I felt a wave of nostalgia and can tell you that though I’ve never had a murder at one of the plays I’ve been a part of, there’s always at least one moment where murder is considered among the cast. For striking a personal chord I recommend this one to any theatre buffs and fans of Ngaio Marsh’s work, getting to see one of the four great queens of crime in action at the height of her majesty was fascinating but perhaps it would be worth getting to know her detective for more than two and a half chapters.

You can hear our full thoughts on Opening Night at the Vulcan on Death of the Reader's podcast, featuring three weeks of solving, misdirection and discussion.

kudeern1's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional mysterious fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

coops456's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

My copy - bought from a charity shop - was a 1979 Fontana Books edition entitled Opening Night. Tiny print!

My first experience of Inspector Alleyn but he was more of a background character than I expected, not appearing until page 108 of 192.

saedith's review against another edition

Go to review page

BBC radio dramatisation.

me2brett's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Marsh loved the theatre and her mysteries set in its world are some of the most engaging, as she clearly understood the intricacies of backstage. A fun mystery with a somewhat blah b plot.

rhie's review against another edition

Go to review page

mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.0

A solid whodunit! 

bev_reads_mysteries's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Opening Night (aka Night at the Vulcan; 1951) finds Ngaio Marsh returning to the world of theatre--comfortable home turf for an author who claimed the theatre as her first passion. This time Marsh focuses on the back-stage antics going on as the players at the Vulcan Theater prepare for the opening of a new play by a brilliant, but difficult playwright. We see everything through the vantage point of Martyn Tarne, a young actress-in-waiting who has recently arrived from New Zealand with the hopes of landing a part on a London stage. After making a discouraging round of the theater casting calls, she comes to the Vulcan just a tad too late to audition for a part. She's down to the last bit of her money and has no idea what do when she overhears Bob Grantley, the business manager, frantically calling round for a replacement dresser for Helen Hamilton--the play's leading lady.

Helen's dresser has been rushed to the hospital and Grantley needs a substitute quick. Martyn needs a job--at this point any job will do and she offers herself as dresser. She immediately finds herself in a seething cauldron of backstage emotions and interactions. Helen Hamilton is married to the leading man, Clark Bennington. Bennington is an aging, alcoholic actor who is thoroughly disliked by just about everyone...including his wife. Helen has been having an affair with Adam Poole, the Vulcan's actor-manager. Bennington's niece, Gay Gainsford, has been cast in a rather important role--as a blood relation to Pool's character who (supposedly) looks remarkably like him and is a somewhat depraved version of himself. She's been making a rather bad showing in the part (not helped by the fact that she really looks nothing like Poole) and is having a case of the nerves. Dr. John James Rutherford, the playwright and another thoroughly unpleasant man, is having fits over Gay's inability to play the part, making himself generally disagreeable to all and sundry, and is quoting Shakespeare at everyone. J. G. Darcy and Parry Percival, the remaining actors, add their nerves and emotional outbursts to the mix.

Martyn's arrival doesn't help matters. Because you see, she does look like Poole (they wind up being second cousins or some such) and could absolutely play the part. To Gay's dismay, Martyn is made her understudy in addition to the dresser's role and on opening night, Gay has a fit of hysterics and is unable to go on. Martyn, of course, steps in to save the day and winds up being a sensation. She barely has time to take in her good fortune (and all the applause) when Clark Bennington doesn't show up for his curtain calls and is discovered dead in his dressing room. To the actors, it has every appearance of suicide. But when Inspector Roderick Alleyn arrives from the Yard, he is not convinced. And, of course, he and Inspector Fox will find all the clues and discover the culprit.

There were several things that I enjoyed about this one: The opening scenes with Martyn--learning of her journey round the theaters and her bad luck at the auditions; her interactions with the fellow-hard luck actress outside the Vulcan; and her conversations with Fred Badger, the nightwatchman. In fact, I liked Fred Badger so much that I kind of hoped that we'd see more of him. But, alas. Jacko, Adam Poole's right-hand man and jack of all trades is also an interesting character--again, particularly in his interactions with Martyn. Overall, I'd say that I enjoyed the characters' interactions with each other--barring a few jarring exceptions (Gay Gainsford gets on my last nerve, for instance). I really do think Marsh was in her element when writing about the theatre and the people of that world. She creates interesting and realistic characters and it's evident that she's writing from experience.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.

verityw's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It took me a little while to get into this, but once I did I found it absolutely fascinating. I had a fairly good idea who I wanted to have done it - but it took me a while to work out the solution. I'm still loving this series - so Golden Age, so much fun and so twisty.

missn80's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous lighthearted mysterious relaxing medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

5.0