Scan barcode
cobycoyle's review against another edition
3.0
Tw: SA
So, I liked some of it.
I am a social worker. Cabel clearly has PTSD. He’s confused/scared how to fully love, fine. I understand. BUT.
You’re just gonna ignore your girlfriend and act like an ass because she *could* have been raped/hurt/whatever else after something traumatic happened to her? She got drugged and sexually assaulted/violated and you’re like “aw man idk if I can deal with this” ? Fuck you, guy. Liked you a lot up until that, now I’m a tad soured on him.
I also don’t have an answer to where/how/why “dream catching” happens. Is it a gene? Is it magic? Hereditary? Like, it just manifests randomly for no rhyme or reason in anyone, which makes it less believeable (I know it’s a fantasy/YA/fiction but still). Also I get the entries follow actual thought processes and stuff but some of it is still so choppy.
Regardless, I did enjoy enough to read in its entirety, and feel anger and other emotions about the bust on the teachers and Janie finding out she’ll deteriorate fast.
So, I liked some of it.
I am a social worker. Cabel clearly has PTSD. He’s confused/scared how to fully love, fine. I understand. BUT.
You’re just gonna ignore your girlfriend and act like an ass because she *could* have been raped/hurt/whatever else after something traumatic happened to her? She got drugged and sexually assaulted/violated and you’re like “aw man idk if I can deal with this” ? Fuck you, guy. Liked you a lot up until that, now I’m a tad soured on him.
I also don’t have an answer to where/how/why “dream catching” happens. Is it a gene? Is it magic? Hereditary? Like, it just manifests randomly for no rhyme or reason in anyone, which makes it less believeable (I know it’s a fantasy/YA/fiction but still). Also I get the entries follow actual thought processes and stuff but some of it is still so choppy.
Regardless, I did enjoy enough to read in its entirety, and feel anger and other emotions about the bust on the teachers and Janie finding out she’ll deteriorate fast.
heathercottledillon's review against another edition
2.0
I like the idea behind this series, but I haven’t enjoyed the stories themselves much. I feel like some parts of the plot are oversimplified while others are made more complicated than they need to be. The resolution of the sex predator storyline is really predictable, and the trouble between Janie and Cade seems forced and unnecessary, like the author just threw it in for dramatic effect. I don’t particularly like the characters, either. I don’t think I’ll be reading the rest of this series.
jsc55's review against another edition
4.0
i liked this book, like i liked wake, however, i feel there is a little too much profanity and sexuality for a book for teenagers... i hate that!
vanikr's review against another edition
4.0
Richtig toll das Buch, aber das Ende ist ein bisschen traurig.
vicky30312's review
5.0
Athough Wake felt like it could have been the end, Lisa always gives us more and it never feels tacky. The extended story is always done so well. The development between Cade and Janie is nicely done as well.
brendalovesbooks's review against another edition
4.0
I didn't like this quite as well as the first book. The story was good, but something failed to connect with me. I also was annoyed with the partial sentences on separate lines. Like this:
She woke up.
And found a cookie.
Then ate it.
It was worse at the beginning, and then either it stopped, or I didn't notice it anymore, but it was bad enough to take me out of the story when I did notice it. This is also one of the most depressing books I've ever read. It almost seems hopeless, although the author does give the reader a small ray of hope at the end. I will continue on with the series, but I really hope something happy happens, even if it doesn't necessarily have a happy ending.
She woke up.
And found a cookie.
Then ate it.
It was worse at the beginning, and then either it stopped, or I didn't notice it anymore, but it was bad enough to take me out of the story when I did notice it. This is also one of the most depressing books I've ever read. It almost seems hopeless, although the author does give the reader a small ray of hope at the end. I will continue on with the series, but I really hope something happy happens, even if it doesn't necessarily have a happy ending.
rballenger's review against another edition
1.0
I've copied my review from 'Wake' (1st book in the series) below as most of it still applies. The only thing I would add is that this book gives me hope for writers everywhere. If this can be published and enjoyed there's truly a niche for everyone. Ever the glutton for punishment, I'll probably still read the 3rd book in the series...mainly because I know my coworker will ask about it and also because it's almost comical how annoyed I am at this book right now and I might as well give myself a little bit of laughable closure.
***
Type of read: Lunch read (print copy)
What made me pick it up: My coworker borrowed me her copies of Wake, Fade, and Gone (Dream Catcher Series)
Overall rating: This book reminded me of many that I used to read back in high school. It was a quick read that was easy to jump in and out of. Some of the writing was a little tough to work out, I had to read and reread a few pages just with the formatting. I would categorize this as a travel book...it holds your attention enough (maybe because you're trying to figure out what is exactly going on?) but it's something that you don't really want to (or have to) get super invested in because you might have to start a conversation, take a nap, or move to your next destination at any moment. I'll probably still finish the series...more because I know my coworker will ask about it and less because I'm actually interested in the books.
***
Type of read: Lunch read (print copy)
What made me pick it up: My coworker borrowed me her copies of Wake, Fade, and Gone (Dream Catcher Series)
Overall rating: This book reminded me of many that I used to read back in high school. It was a quick read that was easy to jump in and out of. Some of the writing was a little tough to work out, I had to read and reread a few pages just with the formatting. I would categorize this as a travel book...it holds your attention enough (maybe because you're trying to figure out what is exactly going on?) but it's something that you don't really want to (or have to) get super invested in because you might have to start a conversation, take a nap, or move to your next destination at any moment. I'll probably still finish the series...more because I know my coworker will ask about it and less because I'm actually interested in the books.
abaugher's review against another edition
4.0
Another read-it-in-one-day book by Lisa McMann. I enjoy her stuff and like her use of short sentences, and mini-chapters with the time they start. it adds an unwritten element to the story. nice touch. will be reading thrid in this series soon.
saks1717's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.75