Scan barcode
billyjepma's review against another edition
dark
informative
mysterious
reflective
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
I loved this way more this time than when I first read it upon release. Maybe I’m older now and have grown even fonder of Star Wars’ political escapades, or maybe this particular story’s portrayal of how corruption interjects into politics is more prescient than ever. Whatever the reason, listening to the new version of the audiobook was a top-notch experience. Luceno’s writing is sometimes a little too dense for its own good—I think he enjoys the Star Wars lore a little too much, as the volume of references, names, and dates thrown around is more disorienting than immersive. But for most of the title, I was totally immersed. The recent Star Wars audiobooks have excellent production value, and the sound effects and music cues they add alongside the narration make it feel like a properly cinematic experience. It is a book for harder core Prequel fans, though, and essentially demands a willingness, if not enthusiasm, to engage with that era’s political jargon and slow-burn machinations. It’s not for everyone, but is definitely for me, a big ol’ nerd.
Daniel Davis’ narration is phenomenal, too. His impression of Palpatine is frighteningly good—some of his enunciations sound like they came from Ian McDiarmid’s mouth—and he does a great job of giving the broader cast enough differentiating characteristics so you can tell who’s speaking. I’ll never cease to be impressed by how talented voice actors and audiobook narrators are.
The book itself isn’t perfect—Plagueis takes a backseat about halfway in, and I wish we got more of how he trained Palpatine—and it has some minor pacing issues. But for a novel that covers a significant length of time, Luceno’s emphasis on critical moments works in the story’s favor, as it highlights the decisions and events that formed Palpatine into the initially charismatic and eventually manipulative dictator we know from the films. Naming the book after Plagueis is somewhat misleading, but we still get enough of him to make him into someone of substance. His depth is lacking when compared to Palpatine, at least a little, but again, this is ultimately Palpatine’s story, and on those terms, it functions as well as anyone could hope for.
I’m definitely going to count this as one of the better Star Wars novels, even though it’s no longer strictly canonical. It engages with the Prequel trilogy in fascinating ways. It all makes me want to rewatch the films and The Clone Wars animated series with the additional perspective into Palpatine this book provides. Good stuff.
Daniel Davis’ narration is phenomenal, too. His impression of Palpatine is frighteningly good—some of his enunciations sound like they came from Ian McDiarmid’s mouth—and he does a great job of giving the broader cast enough differentiating characteristics so you can tell who’s speaking. I’ll never cease to be impressed by how talented voice actors and audiobook narrators are.
The book itself isn’t perfect—Plagueis takes a backseat about halfway in, and I wish we got more of how he trained Palpatine—and it has some minor pacing issues. But for a novel that covers a significant length of time, Luceno’s emphasis on critical moments works in the story’s favor, as it highlights the decisions and events that formed Palpatine into the initially charismatic and eventually manipulative dictator we know from the films. Naming the book after Plagueis is somewhat misleading, but we still get enough of him to make him into someone of substance. His depth is lacking when compared to Palpatine, at least a little, but again, this is ultimately Palpatine’s story, and on those terms, it functions as well as anyone could hope for.
I’m definitely going to count this as one of the better Star Wars novels, even though it’s no longer strictly canonical. It engages with the Prequel trilogy in fascinating ways. It all makes me want to rewatch the films and The Clone Wars animated series with the additional perspective into Palpatine this book provides. Good stuff.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Blood, Death, Injury/Injury detail, Murder, Toxic relationship, and Violence
Minor: Death of parent, Alcohol, and War
More...