1. CANDLES: A Book With a White or Black Cover (107 books added)

2. ATHAME: A Book In A Genre You Don't Normally Read (110 books added)

3. CAULDRON: A book featuring a magical object (72 books added)

4. BELLS: A Comfort Read (99 books added)

bonus
5. Free Space (111 books added)

6. Ancient Grimoire: A book that's four hundred pages or more (103 books added)

7. Bag of Teeth: A Creepy Book (76 books added)

8. Incense: A book in your favorite genre (106 books added)

9. Chalice: A book with something elemental (70 books added)