Take a photo of a barcode or cover
hornswogglerator 's review for:
A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man
by James Joyce
In browsing the reviews of this book, I've noticed that it seems to be impossible to talk about James Joyce's work without sounding like you're talking with your head up your ass. That said, I have mixed feelings about Portrait.
There was much that I appreciated. Joyce is really fantastic at describing settings. There are stories from Dubliners where the setting is my most vivid memory of the story, to the point where it is the only memory of the story I actually have. I can't think of another writer I've read who does that for me. I can also appreciate how he seemed to wallow in his command of the English language in certain passages. He wrote eloquently and you can tell he was having a good time doing it. This impression might partially derive from a recording I've heard of him reading from Finnegans Wake, because he sounds so plucky and happy in it. Plus, I am only vaguely familiar with the content of Ulysses but I understand it has a very sharp sense of humor about it. I have difficulty believing that there isn't at least a trace of revelry and mirth flowing underneath all the exaggerated seriousness of youth presented in the book. (Like I said, impossible to talk about his work without jamming your head up your ass.)
On the other hand, though I never particularly struggled in making progress but I had this obnoxious and nagging feeling that I was missing out on a lot of things. I am fairly confident that I was due to my lack of knowledge about Catholic tradition and the Latin language, but I can't help think there is something else that should be grabbing my attention and holding it about this book. It may be that I have fallen out of practice for reading stream of consciousness, or a number of other things. Regardless, I intend to come back to this one in a few years with annotations and some more experience under my belt.
I've said it in the past about Moby Dick, but I think some internal conflict about highly regarded works of literature is healthy. It might even be that the ability to stir up such uncertainty in the reader is what makes books like Moby Dick and Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man such enduring classics.
There was much that I appreciated. Joyce is really fantastic at describing settings. There are stories from Dubliners where the setting is my most vivid memory of the story, to the point where it is the only memory of the story I actually have. I can't think of another writer I've read who does that for me. I can also appreciate how he seemed to wallow in his command of the English language in certain passages. He wrote eloquently and you can tell he was having a good time doing it. This impression might partially derive from a recording I've heard of him reading from Finnegans Wake, because he sounds so plucky and happy in it. Plus, I am only vaguely familiar with the content of Ulysses but I understand it has a very sharp sense of humor about it. I have difficulty believing that there isn't at least a trace of revelry and mirth flowing underneath all the exaggerated seriousness of youth presented in the book. (Like I said, impossible to talk about his work without jamming your head up your ass.)
On the other hand, though I never particularly struggled in making progress but I had this obnoxious and nagging feeling that I was missing out on a lot of things. I am fairly confident that I was due to my lack of knowledge about Catholic tradition and the Latin language, but I can't help think there is something else that should be grabbing my attention and holding it about this book. It may be that I have fallen out of practice for reading stream of consciousness, or a number of other things. Regardless, I intend to come back to this one in a few years with annotations and some more experience under my belt.
I've said it in the past about Moby Dick, but I think some internal conflict about highly regarded works of literature is healthy. It might even be that the ability to stir up such uncertainty in the reader is what makes books like Moby Dick and Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man such enduring classics.