Scan barcode
A review by dinipandareads
A Marvellous Light by Freya Marske
adventurous
emotional
funny
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
TL;DR: Despite a bit of a rocky and slow start, I did end up enjoying this book! This was a fun historical fantasy set in the regency era that balanced the romance and mystery well. Although the mystery wasn't entirely surprising, there were still some neat little twists that had me eager to learn more! Robin and Edwin were wonderful main characters and I loved their dynamic and romance—I found it swoony, romantic and sweet. 🥰 Not to mention, it got unexpectedly steamy! Overall, a great read and I can't wait to pick up the next book!
As I mentioned, the book starts slowly and remains pretty consistently slow-paced throughout. It's not necessarily a bad thing, of course, and it gave me cosy historical mystery vibes that I enjoyed. One thing that I did struggle with more than expected was the writing. I don't know why because I read my share of Regency-era books but some of the sentences read very oddly, and although I got used to the writing the more I read, it did continue to trip me up on occasion. Whenever that happened, it sadly took me out of the story because I'd have to re-read the section (sometimes multiple times) to make sure I understood what the author was saying, and that was a little frustrating!
I thought the world-building was pretty solid and aside from the writing style, the author did a great job in making it hard to forget what time period the book was set in! The magic system was initially confusing but I thought it was unique. I don't think I've ever read about magic that was so focused on specific hand gestures and movements (like playing cat's cradle!) but I also liked the more "natural" element to the magic that's introduced later on. I hope that gets explored a bit more in the next book especially as it relates to Sutton House! As for the mystery, although the 'baddie" was rather obvious from the beginning, there was a twist or two that I didn't expect and that has me intrigued to see where the story goes next and how Edwin, Robin, and the rest of the crew will come out on the winning side! FYI: while you do find out who the baddie is in this book, the mystery itself isn't entirely solved so it doesn't have a neatly wrapped-up ending.
The best part of the story for me though was the characters and the romance. Edwin and Robin are total opposites—the former is a grumpy librarian type and the latter is a bit of a himbo. Together, they were wonderful and I loved getting to know both of them! Although Edwin was a bit cold and standoffish, to begin with, I loved watching him thaw the more time he spent around Robin, who was genuinely fascinated by Edwin and who truly enjoyed his company. So often I found myself infuriated on Edwin's behalf because his family is just the worst—their brand of casual cruelty and straight-up viciousness is so ugly and nasty and I hate that it was something Edwin had to endure his whole life. I was ready to take up arms to protect this timid and braintastically wholesome man! In contrast, Robin was a "paperwork error" who found himself thrust into the world of magic entirely by accident but who took to it like a fish in water. Like Edwin, he also had a pretty dismal upbringing with horrible parents who treated him and his sibling like paper copies to do with as they liked. I wouldn't say he's a himbo but he does have that slightly clueless sunshine energy that presented a nice contrast to Edwin. I loved that you could feel how comfortable they were with each other.
Their romance was pretty instalust but I loved watching that grow into something more solid the longer they spent together. There were so many wonderful quotes about their interactions, how they saw each other, and what they made each other feel and it made my heart so full because both of them so deserve to be loved! 🥹 You could say this "instalove" since by the end they'd technically only known each other a week but I still maintain it was instalust! 😂 Also, don't let this innocent cover fool you either—this gets very steamy in the latter half of the book once Robin and Edwin admit their feelings for each other. There are a few instances of on-page sex and they are explicit but tastefully so.
Overall, I'm very excited to see what happens next. I hope we still get to see a lot of Robin and Edwin in the next book even though it's going to be told from a different perspective and about a different couple (I assume?)! Either way, this was a solid debut and I'm looking forward to more from this author.
As I mentioned, the book starts slowly and remains pretty consistently slow-paced throughout. It's not necessarily a bad thing, of course, and it gave me cosy historical mystery vibes that I enjoyed. One thing that I did struggle with more than expected was the writing. I don't know why because I read my share of Regency-era books but some of the sentences read very oddly, and although I got used to the writing the more I read, it did continue to trip me up on occasion. Whenever that happened, it sadly took me out of the story because I'd have to re-read the section (sometimes multiple times) to make sure I understood what the author was saying, and that was a little frustrating!
I thought the world-building was pretty solid and aside from the writing style, the author did a great job in making it hard to forget what time period the book was set in! The magic system was initially confusing but I thought it was unique. I don't think I've ever read about magic that was so focused on specific hand gestures and movements (like playing cat's cradle!) but I also liked the more "natural" element to the magic that's introduced later on. I hope that gets explored a bit more in the next book especially as it relates to Sutton House! As for the mystery, although the 'baddie" was rather obvious from the beginning, there was a twist or two that I didn't expect and that has me intrigued to see where the story goes next and how Edwin, Robin, and the rest of the crew will come out on the winning side! FYI: while you do find out who the baddie is in this book, the mystery itself isn't entirely solved so it doesn't have a neatly wrapped-up ending.
The best part of the story for me though was the characters and the romance. Edwin and Robin are total opposites—the former is a grumpy librarian type and the latter is a bit of a himbo. Together, they were wonderful and I loved getting to know both of them! Although Edwin was a bit cold and standoffish, to begin with, I loved watching him thaw the more time he spent around Robin, who was genuinely fascinated by Edwin and who truly enjoyed his company. So often I found myself infuriated on Edwin's behalf because his family is just the worst—their brand of casual cruelty and straight-up viciousness is so ugly and nasty and I hate that it was something Edwin had to endure his whole life. I was ready to take up arms to protect this timid and braintastically wholesome man! In contrast, Robin was a "paperwork error" who found himself thrust into the world of magic entirely by accident but who took to it like a fish in water. Like Edwin, he also had a pretty dismal upbringing with horrible parents who treated him and his sibling like paper copies to do with as they liked. I wouldn't say he's a himbo but he does have that slightly clueless sunshine energy that presented a nice contrast to Edwin. I loved that you could feel how comfortable they were with each other.
Their romance was pretty instalust but I loved watching that grow into something more solid the longer they spent together. There were so many wonderful quotes about their interactions, how they saw each other, and what they made each other feel and it made my heart so full because both of them so deserve to be loved! 🥹 You could say this "instalove" since by the end they'd technically only known each other a week but I still maintain it was instalust! 😂 Also, don't let this innocent cover fool you either—this gets very steamy in the latter half of the book once Robin and Edwin admit their feelings for each other. There are a few instances of on-page sex and they are explicit but tastefully so.
Overall, I'm very excited to see what happens next. I hope we still get to see a lot of Robin and Edwin in the next book even though it's going to be told from a different perspective and about a different couple (I assume?)! Either way, this was a solid debut and I'm looking forward to more from this author.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood, Toxic relationship, Injury/Injury detail, Violence, Sexual content, Murder, and Death
Moderate: Bullying and Misogyny
Minor: Racism and Homophobia