aconstellationoftomes 's review for:

Echoes by Maeve Binchy

3.0

---

Maeve Binchy’s talent shines in this ambitious character study of Castlebay’s residents. The narrative skillfully juggles a large cast of characters, multiple viewpoints, and intertwining storylines. However, the book is overly long and the ending is underwhelming.

The vivid setting is the highlight of Echoes. Binchy brings the small beach town of Castlebay, Ireland, to life, capturing both the charm and challenges of the era. Themes of class, prejudice and religion are expertly woven alongside the problematic attitudes of the time, such as white saviorism, sexism, and rigid gender roles. The characters feel authentic to their period, their behaviours shaped by societal norms.

While most characters are well-developed, some stand out more than others. Angela O’Hara is a standout as she is progressive, sharp, and unafraid to challenge conventions. Clare, the central character, and David, her love interest, are far less compelling. Their romance feels sudden, and its resolution is deeply frustrating.

Spoiler

David’s infidelity and Clare’s easy forgiveness at the end of the book, despite his lingering concerns about his affair partner, is so unsatisfying. While this may be realistic, it's so disappointing.

In contrast, while it's a small part of the book, I appreciated the dependable relationship between David’s parents.

Despite its flaws, Echoes excels in atmosphere, thematic depth, and the nuanced portrayal of its characters, even if the pacing and conclusion isn't up to par.