kaylaswhitmore's profile picture

kaylaswhitmore 's review for:

The Sword of Kaigen by M.L. Wang
4.5
adventurous dark emotional inspiring sad tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

At the behest of my husband (who easily would give this book a 5/5) I read The Sword of Kaigen on the plane to and from our trip overseas. I didn’t honestly know what to expect coming into the story—only that my husband strongly believes  men should read this story to better understand the cost of motherhood and pregnancy on women—and it thoroughly surprised me.

 Right from the get go, Wang’s rich and vibrant Theonite universe pulled me in with no hesitation. I’ll admit that at first—not having been familiar with her previous writing for the universe—the lore and jargon was a bit overwhelming. However, I think anyone who is familiar with fantasy fiction or power scales will be able to grasp it quickly. 

Wang created a very intriguing plot full of conspiracy and adventure from the beginning, and her writing rarely left us wishing for more. I felt that her use of different narrative POVs added to the depth of the story, and I genuinely wasn’t expecting the main MC to be Mamoru’s mother as opposed to him. And the third POV that we eventually get later in the book? That was beautiful done and illuminated both the events and characters of the story in a unique light that I hadn’t thought we would get. Wang managed to take several  tropes commonly seen in fantasy and give them a new spin that felt grounded in Asian culture as well as real, raw human emotion. 

By way of critiques, I don’t have many. If I were to list one or two, it would perhaps be that I personally felt that while the slow-burn relationship in the story was well thought out, it may not have quite lived up to the expectation or hopes that I had come to hold for it. That’s not to say that I didn’t enjoy it or find their endgame satisfactory—it’s more that I thought we spent so much time setting up the hardships of the relationship that I had wanted a longer, more hard-won partnership in the second half of their journey together. And I personally felt that while the work up to their union was hard-won, the actual fruition of their conflicts were a bit too clean for my tastes. Secondly, my other critique is less of a critique and more of a petty complaint, haha. There’s almost nothing more disappointing to me as an audience member than falling in love with a world, seeing the potential for its continuation, then coming to find out that the creator has no intention of adding more to it. This isn’t truly a “fault” of Wang, per se, but I did find it underwhelming that we had so many avenues left to explore by the end of the story, and yet a few pages later had her announcement that she would no longer be exploring the Theonite universe. Alas, I suppose it’s much worse to be left wanting less from an author than to be left wanting more, so even this is still a praise to Wang’s ingenuity!

Altogether, I hope to return to this book in another year or so to reread Misaki’s adventure—and this time I most likely won’t be on a public plabe where I have to conceal my tears and will be able to sob freely as I wanted to the first time lol.  Congrats to Wang for writing such a fabulous story! 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings