Scan barcode
A review by ada_elisabeth
Chouette by Claire Oshetsky
adventurous
dark
emotional
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
Welcome back to my Hot Takes on Random Books! This one was absolutely wild.
I do not know what to make of this book. It's surreal, it's confusing, yes. But it's also oddly enchanting? The writing was very good-- although some people have critiqued Claire Oshetsky's unique writing style in this novel, I loved it. However, that was pretty much the only thing that I loved. I read the first one hundred and forty pages ravenously, thinking that Chouette would be another easy five-star book. But by page one sixty, my excitement had worn off and I was beginning to dislike the story. Ten pages later, I was once again enthralled, but by page two hundred, I was back to loathing it. While there were a few high points between page two hundred and the end, I overall did not enjoy most of it, which is a shame because the rest of the book was fairly decent.
Basically, Tiny gives birth to an owl-baby having cheated on her husband with her owl-lover. (Not a spoiler, this is all established from the very beginning.) Tiny's husband thinks that the owl-baby, Chouette, can become more like a normal human with a series of therapies, surgeries, and treatments. Tiny wants to leave her owl-baby how it is. If interpreted literally, I would agree with Tiny's father. If there was an option to have my owl-child turned into a normal child, then of course I would take it. If I had chosen to interpret this book in a literal sense, I would have given it one star. However, if the owl-baby is seen as a metaphor for a child who is human, but different from other kids due to something like autism, the book becomes a whole lot better. I won't bore you with all of my thoughts, but I will say this: I think that a mix of what Tiny wants and what her husband wants is okay for Chouette, until she is old enough to express what she wants .
Other than that, this book was just decent. Not a single character was likable, I wanted them all to just shut up and go away. The writing was great, and it almost made up for everything else being mediocre. Also, I do really like the cover. The only other thing I could think of to say is that I didn't understand or enjoy the ending at all. I usually rate a book based on how good I thought the ending was, and this one was very vague, which wasn't my favorite. (view spoiler) I also suspect that Tiny might be gay? (view spoiler)
I would describe this book as surreal, haunting, and enchanting, but I doubt I would ever recommend it to someone. I'm not sure if I'll read Oshetsky's next novel, Poor Deer, but I will continue to follow their reviewer account on Goodreads. 4.25/5 stars, rounded down.
Update from, like, twenty minutes after I wrote this review: I do realize this book is about motherhood, and because I am not a mother, I can't really relate to it. It doesn't change how I feel about it, I just think that this book would definitely hit mothers a little harder than it hit me.
I do not know what to make of this book. It's surreal, it's confusing, yes. But it's also oddly enchanting? The writing was very good-- although some people have critiqued Claire Oshetsky's unique writing style in this novel, I loved it. However, that was pretty much the only thing that I loved. I read the first one hundred and forty pages ravenously, thinking that Chouette would be another easy five-star book. But by page one sixty, my excitement had worn off and I was beginning to dislike the story. Ten pages later, I was once again enthralled, but by page two hundred, I was back to loathing it. While there were a few high points between page two hundred and the end, I overall did not enjoy most of it, which is a shame because the rest of the book was fairly decent.
Basically, Tiny gives birth to an owl-baby having cheated on her husband with her owl-lover. (Not a spoiler, this is all established from the very beginning.) Tiny's husband thinks that the owl-baby, Chouette, can become more like a normal human with a series of therapies, surgeries, and treatments. Tiny wants to leave her owl-baby how it is. If interpreted literally, I would agree with Tiny's father. If there was an option to have my owl-child turned into a normal child, then of course I would take it. If I had chosen to interpret this book in a literal sense, I would have given it one star. However, if the owl-baby is seen as a metaphor for a child who is human, but different from other kids due to something like autism, the book becomes a whole lot better. I won't bore you with all of my thoughts, but I will say this: I think that a mix of what Tiny wants and what her husband wants is okay for Chouette, until she is old enough to express what she wants .
Other than that, this book was just decent. Not a single character was likable, I wanted them all to just shut up and go away. The writing was great, and it almost made up for everything else being mediocre. Also, I do really like the cover. The only other thing I could think of to say is that I didn't understand or enjoy the ending at all. I usually rate a book based on how good I thought the ending was, and this one was very vague, which wasn't my favorite. (view spoiler) I also suspect that Tiny might be gay? (view spoiler)
I would describe this book as surreal, haunting, and enchanting, but I doubt I would ever recommend it to someone. I'm not sure if I'll read Oshetsky's next novel, Poor Deer, but I will continue to follow their reviewer account on Goodreads. 4.25/5 stars, rounded down.
Update from, like, twenty minutes after I wrote this review: I do realize this book is about motherhood, and because I am not a mother, I can't really relate to it. It doesn't change how I feel about it, I just think that this book would definitely hit mothers a little harder than it hit me.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Animal cruelty and Animal death