Scan barcode
A review by ollieshark
Traitor's Blade by Sebastien de Castell
adventurous
dark
funny
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
**this book contains rape, dismemberment, character death, suicide by bombing, sexism, self harm, torture, and mentions of animal abuse. if you are sensitive to any of these themes, this may not be an enjoyable read for you.**
*this review contains spoilers.*
falcio is kvothe and i'm disgruntled about it. aside from that, tho, i quite enjoyed traitor's blade.
there are several tropes i despise present in this novel, the most glaring of which is that the main character falcio is not motivated to do anything unless a woman is involved. his wife had to be violated and killed before falcio was incited to become a greatcoat, a woman murdering falcio's current employer is the inciting incident, a young girl by the name of his wife is what prompts the longest arc of the novel (in which falcio is alone in rijou and surrounded by enemies, trying to protect the girl), and the final, main antagonist who has set everything into motion is revealed to be a woman. i hate that. stop it, sebastian.
some sections of prose were infuriatingly mansplainy. a lot of those parts could have been completely cut out, as some of it was purely "weeelllll, i COULD do this, these are all my options, but i'm gonna do something else instead" or explaining how each offensive or defensive maneuver is broken down. i don't particularly care about each and every move falcio makes in a fight scene, just put the pointy end in the other guy and get on with it. if falcio pops out a "not all men" in any of the future books i will personally put all my reviews of this series down to the lowest ratings possible. he's already done it with "not all greatcoats."
there are times when i wanted to beat kvothe--I MEAN FALCIO'S head in. i can't tell if de castell wrote him to be cocky or just plain dumb, to be always jumping into fights or situations meant for (or better suited to) other people, such as kest's fight at the end of the novel. does he have an inflated ego or is he literally just convinced he Has To Be The One? his tone is condescending at times and at others too idealistic, and coming from a manly man with a tragic past like falcio, it just rubs me the wrong way. how did falcio end up leading the greatcoats?
but the humor was great and the banter between falcio, kest, and brasti was great. i also really loved all the women more than falcio, valiana, trin, the tailor, and aline. i even liked patriana and monster more than i liked falcio and was sad when monster didn't bite his head off. i was really pleased that aline actually yelled at falcio and talked back to him instead of being a defenseless little thirteen year old the whole time.
despite all my gripes with some of the choices de castell made regarding falcio and character motivations, i enjoyed traitor's blade enough that i want to continue the series in the future. it's probably the humor and relationships falcio has with kest and brasti that makes me want to keep reading. will i ever get around to it? maybe, but not before i've forgotten everything in this novel. but it'll happen one day.
*this review contains spoilers.*
falcio is kvothe and i'm disgruntled about it. aside from that, tho, i quite enjoyed traitor's blade.
there are several tropes i despise present in this novel, the most glaring of which is that the main character falcio is not motivated to do anything unless a woman is involved. his wife had to be violated and killed before falcio was incited to become a greatcoat, a woman murdering falcio's current employer is the inciting incident, a young girl by the name of his wife is what prompts the longest arc of the novel (in which falcio is alone in rijou and surrounded by enemies, trying to protect the girl), and the final, main antagonist who has set everything into motion is revealed to be a woman. i hate that. stop it, sebastian.
some sections of prose were infuriatingly mansplainy. a lot of those parts could have been completely cut out, as some of it was purely "weeelllll, i COULD do this, these are all my options, but i'm gonna do something else instead" or explaining how each offensive or defensive maneuver is broken down. i don't particularly care about each and every move falcio makes in a fight scene, just put the pointy end in the other guy and get on with it. if falcio pops out a "not all men" in any of the future books i will personally put all my reviews of this series down to the lowest ratings possible. he's already done it with "not all greatcoats."
there are times when i wanted to beat kvothe--I MEAN FALCIO'S head in. i can't tell if de castell wrote him to be cocky or just plain dumb, to be always jumping into fights or situations meant for (or better suited to) other people, such as kest's fight at the end of the novel. does he have an inflated ego or is he literally just convinced he Has To Be The One? his tone is condescending at times and at others too idealistic, and coming from a manly man with a tragic past like falcio, it just rubs me the wrong way. how did falcio end up leading the greatcoats?
but the humor was great and the banter between falcio, kest, and brasti was great. i also really loved all the women more than falcio, valiana, trin, the tailor, and aline. i even liked patriana and monster more than i liked falcio and was sad when monster didn't bite his head off. i was really pleased that aline actually yelled at falcio and talked back to him instead of being a defenseless little thirteen year old the whole time.
despite all my gripes with some of the choices de castell made regarding falcio and character motivations, i enjoyed traitor's blade enough that i want to continue the series in the future. it's probably the humor and relationships falcio has with kest and brasti that makes me want to keep reading. will i ever get around to it? maybe, but not before i've forgotten everything in this novel. but it'll happen one day.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Self harm, Death, Sexism, and Suicide
Moderate: Rape, Animal cruelty, Torture, and Cursing