Take a photo of a barcode or cover
lovelylibrarian 's review for:
One for the Murphys
by Lynda Mullaly Hunt
While I enjoyed this book for the unique perspective it gives, there were many misgivings that I had about this book.
I think that the resistance Carly first meets from the various family members, and feeling of not being good enough seem genuine. The perception that people have of foster kids is probably pretty tough to over come and show trust and care. I really enjoyed that part of the book. The triumph over a difficult situation, a current common situation, is powerful.
However, my issue with the book is the lack of the proper representation of the foster system. There was very little legal representation, the idea that she would talk to her mom without anyone there with her was extremely odd, and Carly not having anyone to talk to about the situation seems so unrealistic.
I realize this book is probably supposed to introduce the idea to younger readers. Overall, I really enjoyed the book and the experience. Some tears were certainly shed.
I think that the resistance Carly first meets from the various family members, and feeling of not being good enough seem genuine. The perception that people have of foster kids is probably pretty tough to over come and show trust and care. I really enjoyed that part of the book. The triumph over a difficult situation, a current common situation, is powerful.
However, my issue with the book is the lack of the proper representation of the foster system. There was very little legal representation, the idea that she would talk to her mom without anyone there with her was extremely odd, and Carly not having anyone to talk to about the situation seems so unrealistic.
I realize this book is probably supposed to introduce the idea to younger readers. Overall, I really enjoyed the book and the experience. Some tears were certainly shed.