Scan barcode
A review by jessicalynn_reads
Her Secret by Ivy Fox
3.0
This one wasn't bad but I didn't love it either. I feel like especially with it being 5 guys and with them having history with each other that it needed to be longer. It felt very rushed and no reasoning for why emotions changed besided the fact that they got a taste for her and didn't want to stop. I needed more character building especially with it being friends-to-enemies-to-lovers.
*SPOILERS*
There are 5 brothers total. 2 are older and live in the city and 3 younger who still live next door to the fmc with their parents. Both sets if parents are leaving together for a trip and the fmcs mom doesn't want her staying at home alone due to recent break-ins in the neighborhood so she has arranged for her to stay next door with the guys.
Their history with each other is the 5 brothers and the fmc used to be close friends. But something changes and the fmc basically ghosts them all and stops all communication. The guys are all hurt and it kind of turns into a slight friends to enemies situation. When she moves into their house the first scene she walks into is the 3 guys with multiple other women. They basically tell her to stay out of their way. She leaves crying and hides in her room for the next several days. This is when it feels like a switch was turned because all of a sudden the 3 guys are magically no longer mad at her and start to pursue a friendship and a more sexual relationship with her. The 2 older brothers hear what's happening and come over to the house to also get with her.
It's then revealed that the only reason why she ghosted them was because one of the brothers had kissed her but she got scared because she wants all 5 brothers and didn't know what to do about that. She would rather have none of them if she couldn't have them all. They all don't understand why she didn't just come out and say that when they all want her and are fine sharing. However, she is afraid and wants to end this thing they all have going on when their parents get back from there trip. She is worried how it will work and what people will say. The conversation does not go well and all but 1 of the guys leaves. They are furious that she would leave them again after they have just got her back. The 1 brother that stayed tells her that she could choose one but she can't do that as she loves them all and would rather not have any of them. He thinks they will come back to her and to just give them some time. She ends up having this AHA moment where she doesn't care what anyone has to say or think about all of them being together.
It takes an immediate sharp turn when she wakes up mouth covered and pinned the bed from an intruder. She tries to find the one brother who was with her but he is tied up, beaten and held down by 2 men. When I got to this part I had totally forgotten about how homes were being broken into in the neighborhood. So I was taken aback by this. They try to rape her. She fights back and he ends up hitting her where shes now unconscious.
Meanwhile the other guys have come to their senses and have decided that they want her back so they conveniently go to the house during the same time shit is going down. They put a stop to it all, cops are called, the 4 guys are remorseful from leaving her. She just wants her mom called and to go home after the incident. She originally wanted to go home because of the comfort her own room and house would bring her but after a 2 weeks she finds that she is missing them. But she hasn't tried to contact them and they haven't tried to contact her. She decides she need to tell them how she feels so she sneaks out of the house to see them. They all have this moment of declaring there love for one another. It's kind of feels like a marriage ceramony because she goes to each guy individually and tells them why she loves them lol
Maybe it's because I've read so many why choose romances that I feel like I needed more from this! The reasoning felt silly for her to not talk to them and the transitions of them no longer being angry at her were too abrupt with no why given. The trauma of the intruders was mentioned that she has recurring nightmares but that was it. I just needed more.
*SPOILERS*
There are 5 brothers total. 2 are older and live in the city and 3 younger who still live next door to the fmc with their parents. Both sets if parents are leaving together for a trip and the fmcs mom doesn't want her staying at home alone due to recent break-ins in the neighborhood so she has arranged for her to stay next door with the guys.
Their history with each other is the 5 brothers and the fmc used to be close friends. But something changes and the fmc basically ghosts them all and stops all communication. The guys are all hurt and it kind of turns into a slight friends to enemies situation. When she moves into their house the first scene she walks into is the 3 guys with multiple other women. They basically tell her to stay out of their way. She leaves crying and hides in her room for the next several days. This is when it feels like a switch was turned because all of a sudden the 3 guys are magically no longer mad at her and start to pursue a friendship and a more sexual relationship with her. The 2 older brothers hear what's happening and come over to the house to also get with her.
It's then revealed that the only reason why she ghosted them was because one of the brothers had kissed her but she got scared because she wants all 5 brothers and didn't know what to do about that. She would rather have none of them if she couldn't have them all. They all don't understand why she didn't just come out and say that when they all want her and are fine sharing. However, she is afraid and wants to end this thing they all have going on when their parents get back from there trip. She is worried how it will work and what people will say. The conversation does not go well and all but 1 of the guys leaves. They are furious that she would leave them again after they have just got her back. The 1 brother that stayed tells her that she could choose one but she can't do that as she loves them all and would rather not have any of them. He thinks they will come back to her and to just give them some time. She ends up having this AHA moment where she doesn't care what anyone has to say or think about all of them being together.
It takes an immediate sharp turn when she wakes up mouth covered and pinned the bed from an intruder. She tries to find the one brother who was with her but he is tied up, beaten and held down by 2 men. When I got to this part I had totally forgotten about how homes were being broken into in the neighborhood. So I was taken aback by this. They try to rape her. She fights back and he ends up hitting her where shes now unconscious.
Meanwhile the other guys have come to their senses and have decided that they want her back so they conveniently go to the house during the same time shit is going down. They put a stop to it all, cops are called, the 4 guys are remorseful from leaving her. She just wants her mom called and to go home after the incident. She originally wanted to go home because of the comfort her own room and house would bring her but after a 2 weeks she finds that she is missing them. But she hasn't tried to contact them and they haven't tried to contact her. She decides she need to tell them how she feels so she sneaks out of the house to see them. They all have this moment of declaring there love for one another. It's kind of feels like a marriage ceramony because she goes to each guy individually and tells them why she loves them lol
Maybe it's because I've read so many why choose romances that I feel like I needed more from this! The reasoning felt silly for her to not talk to them and the transitions of them no longer being angry at her were too abrupt with no why given. The trauma of the intruders was mentioned that she has recurring nightmares but that was it. I just needed more.