Scan barcode
A review by gotem
The Ruthless Lady's Guide to Wizardry by C.M. Waggoner
Did not finish book. Stopped at 48%.
adventurous
funny
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
I'm sorry, I tried. I love books about ruthless ladies and guides and magic. Unfortunately this books did not meet what the title (or honestly even book description) said.
The most ruthless lady was Winn's landlady. Everyone else was really just mean at best, annoying at worst.
I couldn't make heads or tails of some of the plots and world-building aspects of the book. What is the currency and value of goods? why can 50 gold pieces cover 6 months of rent and a place for your addict mother but also only cover a 2 weeks stay in rehab? And also be an acceptable amount for two weeks' worth of work but also not be a substantial amount of money for most of the hired party members to actually care about? Actually, what is the class system and marriage system here, why does a woman need an all-female group to guard her before her wedding if gay marriage is also well and good here? An actual guide to this world would have been much appreciated.
Lastly, the magic was over, rarely to be brought up again, after the first 40% of the book. And also complicated - are people innately born with magic or not? Do you need training or not? Are glyphs (???) required or not? Why are oaths so arbitrary?
To be completely fair, the first hundred or so pages of this are entertaining and fast-paced. There's murder, attempted murder, magic, badass ladies, and a quirky upper-class marriage etiquette to bring it all together. But then it all dropped rather quickly into what felt more like a daily diary of a novice detective and their various assistants.
After the 5th chapter of "wake up, clean, have tea, have lunch, buy clothes and spend money after establishing how much the MC does NOT want to spend money, eat, go to sleep", I finally conceded defeat and put the book down.
I wanted to like this book. It is campy, makes fun of itself (see page 189 for some adorable meta-humor), and has a clearly complex cast of characters. The realistic approach to drug addiction and poverty helped bring the character's surroundings to life.
But the thought of picking up the book to slough through even one more chapter of grown women playing junior detective slash new drug dealers on the block (which, in my opinion, is where the entire book lost the plot) filled me with dread.
The most ruthless lady was Winn's landlady. Everyone else was really just mean at best, annoying at worst.
I couldn't make heads or tails of some of the plots and world-building aspects of the book. What is the currency and value of goods? why can 50 gold pieces cover 6 months of rent and a place for your addict mother but also only cover a 2 weeks stay in rehab? And also be an acceptable amount for two weeks' worth of work but also not be a substantial amount of money for most of the hired party members to actually care about? Actually, what is the class system and marriage system here, why does a woman need an all-female group to guard her before her wedding if gay marriage is also well and good here? An actual guide to this world would have been much appreciated.
Lastly, the magic was over, rarely to be brought up again, after the first 40% of the book. And also complicated - are people innately born with magic or not? Do you need training or not? Are glyphs (???) required or not? Why are oaths so arbitrary?
To be completely fair, the first hundred or so pages of this are entertaining and fast-paced. There's murder, attempted murder, magic, badass ladies, and a quirky upper-class marriage etiquette to bring it all together. But then it all dropped rather quickly into what felt more like a daily diary of a novice detective and their various assistants.
After the 5th chapter of "wake up, clean, have tea, have lunch, buy clothes and spend money after establishing how much the MC does NOT want to spend money, eat, go to sleep", I finally conceded defeat and put the book down.
I wanted to like this book. It is campy, makes fun of itself (see page 189 for some adorable meta-humor), and has a clearly complex cast of characters. The realistic approach to drug addiction and poverty helped bring the character's surroundings to life.
But the thought of picking up the book to slough through even one more chapter of grown women playing junior detective slash
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death and Drug abuse