A review by rg9400
Petition by Delilah Waan

adventurous dark mysterious fast-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? Yes
• Loveable characters? Yes
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

I don't think I've really read fantasy that puts us in the perspective of a second-generation immigrant, and I found the protagonist's struggles with a supposedly "equal opportunity" city where privilege and class inevitably create barriers to be compelling. I also thought it created a nice dynamic between her and her mother. But most of all, I loved the different examinations she had to go through, especially when paired with a bunch of different characters with tons of personality. As the story progressed and we learn more about some of the insidious things happening in the background, I was glued to the book, especially as it took some darker turns. I do wish we got more with some of these moments because they were really engaging, and I feel like the book only gives us a few snippets of what is actually going on. It's also possible that I didn't understand some of it because some of the house names are a bit similar and easy to confuse for me (Isom, Issolm, Isonn) and while the magic system is very unique (all about emotions and the push/pull of seeking and obfuscating them across time and space), it is a bit technical with the reader getting thrown right into it. 

Regardless of those minor quibbles, I loved it and already have it on my best books of 2024 list. I am very glad I decided to check it out. Side note, it said book 2 was coming out in 2023, so would love to know where I can find it