Scan barcode
A review by dr_matthew_lloyd
Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season Nine, Volume 1: Freefall by Andrew Chambliss, Joss Whedon, Jane Espenson
4.0
Freefall, the first volume of Season 9, has something of a Season 6 feel, with the focus on personal drama rather than large-scale apocalypses; although there is also a feel of early Season 7, with Buffy, Dawn, and Xander the main Scoobies, Willow dealing with a magic fallout, Spike skulking around potentously, and Giles unavailable. The point is, unlike Season 8, from the off this feels like Buffy, albeit a Buffy where the game has changed. But the game is always changing; this time it doesn't seem quite so distant from core-Buffy as the beginning of Season 8.
Not unlike Angel Season 5, the new playing field was piloted at the end of the previous season and now we're just seeing it bedded in. Apologies for probably mixing several metaphors, there. Buffy is living in San Francisco, waitressing and slaying, along with the main Scoobies; Riley and Andrew are apparently within visiting distance, and Stalky the Clown remains in his usual disturbing proximity to Buffy. The focus of this volume is firmly on Buffy. We see her settling in to her new flat-share, with two new characters to enjoy; and we see her coping with what she's done and what she's lost. Or, if you listen to Willow, not coping. Refusing to accept that she has made things angry, disturbed the order of things, and should be preparing herself. But Buffy has more to deal with than just the consequences of destroying the world's source of magic - Stalky keeps on warning her that something is coming, while demons are out to get her for any number of reasons - some funny, others not. She has very little time togrieve for the loss of Giles - again, not unlike the beginning of Season 7 when much of the mourning for Tara appeared to have taken place off-screen; except that here there is the constant reminder of his sole bequeathment to her: the VAMPYR book . Riley and Stalky both give her pep talks about how she did the right thing, but Buffy is nothing if not self-effacing. All in all, it's a clear realization that these stories need to keep one thing in focus, and it isn't the apocalypse: it's Buffy, her character, and how she copes.
The others get perhaps less attention than they deserve, although there is some recompense for this in the fact that Willow has her own mini-series coming up. Xander and Dawn require less attention as they get on with their lives together - although not without some unclear turbulence. Stalky is pretty much as he was in much of the television show, just there being annoying and perving on Buffy, although her down-attitude makes it one of those times when she seems to enjoy it. Buffy's new housemates get very little attention; nor do the police officers who seem to be becoming major characters. The senior one doesn't even get a name. But we do get an exciting new character in Severin and a little clue as to whom the villain of the piece will be in the reappearance of Simone the bad slayer (more bad than Faith). Hopefully, these new characters will manage to not drown out the old ones while getting enough space to develop.
There is something slightly off about the art, although it's hard to pinpoint what. Especially in "Slayer, Interrupted" Karl Moline's art looks much more rushed than in previous volumes; there also seems to be an attempt to make Buffy look a little older than perhaps she has previously. The colours are bright, looking a lot more like a comic book than an adaptation of a television show - although arguably that's an improvement, as it does give the series a chance to grow beyond its original trappings. I don't, personally, find that the art is poor enough to detract from the story, although it's disappointing as I've enjoyed Moline's versions of these characters for so long (less so Jeanty's, admittedly). But it certainly gives Season 9 a new feel.
Not unlike Angel Season 5, the new playing field was piloted at the end of the previous season and now we're just seeing it bedded in. Apologies for probably mixing several metaphors, there. Buffy is living in San Francisco, waitressing and slaying, along with the main Scoobies; Riley and Andrew are apparently within visiting distance, and Stalky the Clown remains in his usual disturbing proximity to Buffy. The focus of this volume is firmly on Buffy. We see her settling in to her new flat-share, with two new characters to enjoy; and we see her coping with what she's done and what she's lost. Or, if you listen to Willow, not coping. Refusing to accept that she has made things angry, disturbed the order of things, and should be preparing herself. But Buffy has more to deal with than just the consequences of destroying the world's source of magic - Stalky keeps on warning her that something is coming, while demons are out to get her for any number of reasons - some funny, others not. She has very little time to
The others get perhaps less attention than they deserve, although there is some recompense for this in the fact that Willow has her own mini-series coming up. Xander and Dawn require less attention as they get on with their lives together - although not without some unclear turbulence. Stalky is pretty much as he was in much of the television show, just there being annoying and perving on Buffy, although her down-attitude makes it one of those times when she seems to enjoy it. Buffy's new housemates get very little attention; nor do the police officers who seem to be becoming major characters. The senior one doesn't even get a name. But we do get an exciting new character in Severin and a little clue as to whom the villain of the piece will be in the reappearance of Simone the bad slayer (more bad than Faith). Hopefully, these new characters will manage to not drown out the old ones while getting enough space to develop.
There is something slightly off about the art, although it's hard to pinpoint what. Especially in "Slayer, Interrupted" Karl Moline's art looks much more rushed than in previous volumes; there also seems to be an attempt to make Buffy look a little older than perhaps she has previously. The colours are bright, looking a lot more like a comic book than an adaptation of a television show - although arguably that's an improvement, as it does give the series a chance to grow beyond its original trappings. I don't, personally, find that the art is poor enough to detract from the story, although it's disappointing as I've enjoyed Moline's versions of these characters for so long (less so Jeanty's, admittedly). But it certainly gives Season 9 a new feel.