mdpenguin 's review for:

A Small Charred Face by Kazuki Sakuraba
4.0

Another 3.5 star book that I'm rounding up. If you pick this up and really like the first two stories, skip the last one: it's out of place. The first two are kind of dreamy and have a strange draw to them. It's not like the story really pushes them along so much as I felt drawn along by some odd charm. The first story was very moving. There was a lot that I liked about the second, such as Mariko's innocent naivete mixed with her monstrous nature. The third story, the origin of the Bamboo in Japan, just wasn't that interesting. The pseudo-realistic, excited, and occasionally vacuous dialog that worked reasonably well in the first two stories made the entire species look silly in the third. I mean, oh, well, um...the royal family wasn't that impressive and the story of the fifth child and how she sent the sixth to Japan wasn't that interesting. If I ranked the stories individually on a 7 point scale with 7 being the best and 1 being don't bother, the first would be just over 6 stars, the second 5, and the third would be 3. Because the first story is the bulk of the book, I'm letting it pull the total up to the 3.5/5 instead of the 2.5/5 that they would all average out if they were weighted equally.