Take a photo of a barcode or cover
pewterwolf 's review for:
The Diviners
by Libba Bray
adventurous
dark
mysterious
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
DNF in 2012
First read from March 2014 to May 2014 (Audiobook) - Audiobook given by PR company via Audible in exchange for honest review
Relisten from January 2020 to February 2020 (Audiobook) - Listen to Audiobook, though was given eProof by UK publisher via NetGalley in exchange for honest review/reaction. Though I could try and read it and... nope. Had to be audiobook.
***Write-Up from May 2014***
Write-Up Taken from The Pewter Wolf
I am going to admit this here and now: I tried to read The Diviners once before. It was when the book was first released in hardback a few years back. The UK publisher very kindly sent me a copy and I started to read it. I got about 200 pages in and I just stopped. I couldn't bear the main character, the story was too slow for my tastes and I just couldn't face continuing onwards (which is rare for me but life, I have now decided, is too short to read crap books).
Fast forward two years and a PR company who is doing PR for Audible.co.uk, asked if I fancied doing a review of one of Audible's new releases. I had asked for [b:Unlucky 13|18104702|Unlucky 13 (Women's Murder Club, #13)|James Patterson|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1382319672l/18104702._SY75_.jpg|25592905] and, on impulse, I asked if they had any details on The Diviners audiobook. And they kindly said that I could have a copy of this, if I wanted. So, THANK YOU!
Evie O'Neil has been exiled to New York to lived to her uncle, and Evie is going to enjoy it. It's New York, it's 1926, perfect for a modern girl like her! Only snag is that her Uncle Will runs a museum of the occult and she has a secret gift that he must never find out about. But Will is asked by the Police is help them on a mysterious murder, Evie realises that her gift might be key to solving this murder. But with the body count slowly rising, Evie, her uncle Will and his assistant, Jericho, must work quickly.
But New York is one large city and there is always more than one story to tell. Evie's friend, Mabel, is sweet on Jericho (who barely knows she exists) and is sick of being in everyone's shadow. Jericho has a secret that no one must ever find out about. Pick pocket Sam Lloyd has his own secret and is looking for someone. Street runner Memphis is mourning not only is parents but his special gift. Theta smiles the brightest smile but is running scared. Henry, Theta's "brother" is hiding not only his gift but his sexuality as well.
And all the while, in the city that never sleeps, a terrible evil has risen. Be afraid, New York... Naughty John is on the prowl...
Ok, let's talk about the audiobook narrator, January LaVoy. I LOVED HER! She was a joy to listen to. I never felt rushed with her nor did I feel that January was just reading the book. It felt like she was living the book. This is a huge deal for me. So, for her, I can't fault her!
The story itself. Ok, I am going to split this into 2 parts. The first half and the second half. The first half was hardwork. It was just hardwork. This was that main reason I stopped reading the book. It was just HARD WORK. And it was VERY slow paced. We had the prologue - which I was hooked - and then getting to the story and start following Evie, and I begin to lose my interest.
I think the problem I have with part one is that Libba Bray is getting us use to the characters, their flaws and the world around them. Which is fine. This is the first book in a series. I get that. However, I wish the plot was a bit more pace-y within the first half of the book. Why couldn't we learn all this stuff but have the pace that this book kinda deserves? (When I was listening to the first half of the audiobook, I honestly thought there was paragraphs and chapters that could SO EASILY be removed).
However, part two of the audiobook. Once we got to the chapter "The Hotsy-Totsy" (or was it the chapter prior, "The House On The Hill"?), things suddenly went up a gear and I sped through. The pacing was fast, things fell into place much quicker, characters met and my opinion on certain characters changed (mainly Evie - when we first meet her, she is spoilt, selfish and, at time, thinks of no one's feelings but her own. After "The Hotsy-Totsy", she begins to realises that her actions affect others [but this only happens when her best friend, Mabel, explodes at her in an argument]).
I much prefer the second half of the story rather than the first. It felt like it had become the story I wanted to read! IT CAME AT LAST!
So, you guys must go "Wait, so you hated part one but you liked part two. What does this mean about the sequel, [b:Lair of Dreams|16060716|Lair of Dreams (The Diviners, #2)|Libba Bray|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1560630223l/16060716._SY75_.jpg|21848181]? Will you read/audiobook that?". And I am very torn of this. On the one hand, I wanna keep going. I want to know where Libba is going to take the characters - that last half an hour very nicely set things up for book 2. However, I am very worried about the pacing. I can't go back to the pacing that the first half of The Diviners was.
I know I am very much in the minority when I say I didn't love the book (I like it, but I will never love it). But I won't refuse outright listening to the audiobook of Lair of Dreams if I was offered it. But only on one condition: if January LaVoy is the reader. If it's someone else, then nope. Not gonna happen.
But I think this book is a book that most people will love and enjoy if you invest time into it. I have and it's not exactly my cup of tea. But maybe the sequel will be...
***Write-Up from February 2020***
Write-Up Taken from The Pewter Wolf
If you have followed me on here or via my blog, the Pewter Wolf, for quite some time, you would know that I have a bit of a history with The Diviners. I tried to read this when the book first came out and I DNFed it halfway through. A year or so later, I tried again, this time on audiobook and I finished it. And while there were things I did like, there were others things that I didn’t. So… what made me decide to go back?
Answer: I have no idea. A few weeks before Christmas, I was looking up the second book in the Diviners series, Lair of Dreams, and after I returned an audiobook I disliked, I used the credit for that. I went “Well, if I’m going to listen to Lair, I should relisten to Diviners.” Once I thought of this, I was a little excited. Plus, as 2020 is my tenth year of blogging, this would be a nice way to celebrate - reread or relisten to some titles of my past. Plus, over the course of the next few weeks on me making this decision, I had somehow got my hands on the rest of the series so, guess what I’ll be planning to audiobook in the next few months!
I am still in two minds over this. Yes, still. Several years later, I am still torn over this. On the one hand, I am onboard with this series and I am going to see it through to the bitter end. This feels like a series I can really sink my teeth in. We have a murder mystery with a supernatural twist, combined two of my fave genres together - fantasy and crime. We have interesting, complex characters (both heroes and villains - the killer, Naughty John, hooked me!) and, because am more on ball than my first listen, I see that Libba is putting seeds down for the main overarching story for the series and is putting things in place for character development.
However, I did struggle with this. I am not much of a historical reader so this feels very slow pace to me. Libba Bray has done her homework and she wants us to be immerse us in this world, both the good parts of history and the horrifying. But because of this, the pacing is slower than I am used to read. And a slower paced novel is going to be a struggle for me. Plus, certain characters make very dodgy decisions, which are very in keeping with their characters and will push the series forward, but make me go “ARGH!!!”. Plus, this is the first book in series so is setting everything up. On some counts, this was done really well and others…
Like I said earlier, I am going to complete the series (am weirdly looking forward to doing so via audiobook - the narrator, January La Voy, is fabulous!) but this is very much a mix bag for me. I think I’ll have the face the fact that I am not much of a historical reader and this effected how I feel about this relisten and possibly the series as a whole…
First read from March 2014 to May 2014 (Audiobook) - Audiobook given by PR company via Audible in exchange for honest review
Relisten from January 2020 to February 2020 (Audiobook) - Listen to Audiobook, though was given eProof by UK publisher via NetGalley in exchange for honest review/reaction. Though I could try and read it and... nope. Had to be audiobook.
***Write-Up from May 2014***
Write-Up Taken from The Pewter Wolf
I am going to admit this here and now: I tried to read The Diviners once before. It was when the book was first released in hardback a few years back. The UK publisher very kindly sent me a copy and I started to read it. I got about 200 pages in and I just stopped. I couldn't bear the main character, the story was too slow for my tastes and I just couldn't face continuing onwards (which is rare for me but life, I have now decided, is too short to read crap books).
Fast forward two years and a PR company who is doing PR for Audible.co.uk, asked if I fancied doing a review of one of Audible's new releases. I had asked for [b:Unlucky 13|18104702|Unlucky 13 (Women's Murder Club, #13)|James Patterson|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1382319672l/18104702._SY75_.jpg|25592905] and, on impulse, I asked if they had any details on The Diviners audiobook. And they kindly said that I could have a copy of this, if I wanted. So, THANK YOU!
Evie O'Neil has been exiled to New York to lived to her uncle, and Evie is going to enjoy it. It's New York, it's 1926, perfect for a modern girl like her! Only snag is that her Uncle Will runs a museum of the occult and she has a secret gift that he must never find out about. But Will is asked by the Police is help them on a mysterious murder, Evie realises that her gift might be key to solving this murder. But with the body count slowly rising, Evie, her uncle Will and his assistant, Jericho, must work quickly.
But New York is one large city and there is always more than one story to tell. Evie's friend, Mabel, is sweet on Jericho (who barely knows she exists) and is sick of being in everyone's shadow. Jericho has a secret that no one must ever find out about. Pick pocket Sam Lloyd has his own secret and is looking for someone. Street runner Memphis is mourning not only is parents but his special gift. Theta smiles the brightest smile but is running scared. Henry, Theta's "brother" is hiding not only his gift but his sexuality as well.
And all the while, in the city that never sleeps, a terrible evil has risen. Be afraid, New York... Naughty John is on the prowl...
Ok, let's talk about the audiobook narrator, January LaVoy. I LOVED HER! She was a joy to listen to. I never felt rushed with her nor did I feel that January was just reading the book. It felt like she was living the book. This is a huge deal for me. So, for her, I can't fault her!
The story itself. Ok, I am going to split this into 2 parts. The first half and the second half. The first half was hardwork. It was just hardwork. This was that main reason I stopped reading the book. It was just HARD WORK. And it was VERY slow paced. We had the prologue - which I was hooked - and then getting to the story and start following Evie, and I begin to lose my interest.
I think the problem I have with part one is that Libba Bray is getting us use to the characters, their flaws and the world around them. Which is fine. This is the first book in a series. I get that. However, I wish the plot was a bit more pace-y within the first half of the book. Why couldn't we learn all this stuff but have the pace that this book kinda deserves? (When I was listening to the first half of the audiobook, I honestly thought there was paragraphs and chapters that could SO EASILY be removed).
However, part two of the audiobook. Once we got to the chapter "The Hotsy-Totsy" (or was it the chapter prior, "The House On The Hill"?), things suddenly went up a gear and I sped through. The pacing was fast, things fell into place much quicker, characters met and my opinion on certain characters changed (mainly Evie - when we first meet her, she is spoilt, selfish and, at time, thinks of no one's feelings but her own. After "The Hotsy-Totsy", she begins to realises that her actions affect others [but this only happens when her best friend, Mabel, explodes at her in an argument]).
I much prefer the second half of the story rather than the first. It felt like it had become the story I wanted to read! IT CAME AT LAST!
So, you guys must go "Wait, so you hated part one but you liked part two. What does this mean about the sequel, [b:Lair of Dreams|16060716|Lair of Dreams (The Diviners, #2)|Libba Bray|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1560630223l/16060716._SY75_.jpg|21848181]? Will you read/audiobook that?". And I am very torn of this. On the one hand, I wanna keep going. I want to know where Libba is going to take the characters - that last half an hour very nicely set things up for book 2. However, I am very worried about the pacing. I can't go back to the pacing that the first half of The Diviners was.
I know I am very much in the minority when I say I didn't love the book (I like it, but I will never love it). But I won't refuse outright listening to the audiobook of Lair of Dreams if I was offered it. But only on one condition: if January LaVoy is the reader. If it's someone else, then nope. Not gonna happen.
But I think this book is a book that most people will love and enjoy if you invest time into it. I have and it's not exactly my cup of tea. But maybe the sequel will be...
***Write-Up from February 2020***
Write-Up Taken from The Pewter Wolf
If you have followed me on here or via my blog, the Pewter Wolf, for quite some time, you would know that I have a bit of a history with The Diviners. I tried to read this when the book first came out and I DNFed it halfway through. A year or so later, I tried again, this time on audiobook and I finished it. And while there were things I did like, there were others things that I didn’t. So… what made me decide to go back?
Answer: I have no idea. A few weeks before Christmas, I was looking up the second book in the Diviners series, Lair of Dreams, and after I returned an audiobook I disliked, I used the credit for that. I went “Well, if I’m going to listen to Lair, I should relisten to Diviners.” Once I thought of this, I was a little excited. Plus, as 2020 is my tenth year of blogging, this would be a nice way to celebrate - reread or relisten to some titles of my past. Plus, over the course of the next few weeks on me making this decision, I had somehow got my hands on the rest of the series so, guess what I’ll be planning to audiobook in the next few months!
I am still in two minds over this. Yes, still. Several years later, I am still torn over this. On the one hand, I am onboard with this series and I am going to see it through to the bitter end. This feels like a series I can really sink my teeth in. We have a murder mystery with a supernatural twist, combined two of my fave genres together - fantasy and crime. We have interesting, complex characters (both heroes and villains - the killer, Naughty John, hooked me!) and, because am more on ball than my first listen, I see that Libba is putting seeds down for the main overarching story for the series and is putting things in place for character development.
However, I did struggle with this. I am not much of a historical reader so this feels very slow pace to me. Libba Bray has done her homework and she wants us to be immerse us in this world, both the good parts of history and the horrifying. But because of this, the pacing is slower than I am used to read. And a slower paced novel is going to be a struggle for me. Plus, certain characters make very dodgy decisions, which are very in keeping with their characters and will push the series forward, but make me go “ARGH!!!”. Plus, this is the first book in series so is setting everything up. On some counts, this was done really well and others…
Like I said earlier, I am going to complete the series (am weirdly looking forward to doing so via audiobook - the narrator, January La Voy, is fabulous!) but this is very much a mix bag for me. I think I’ll have the face the fact that I am not much of a historical reader and this effected how I feel about this relisten and possibly the series as a whole…
Content Warnings
Graphic: Child death, Death, Racial slurs, Racism, Sexism, Antisemitism, Murder, Alcohol
Moderate: Cursing, Hate crime, Homophobia, Misogyny, Xenophobia, Religious bigotry, Fire/Fire injury
Minor: Animal cruelty, Animal death, Domestic abuse, Death of parent, War