You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
clo_clo2 's review for:
It Ends with Us
by Colleen Hoover
summary: 10/10 plot & arc, 5/10 execution, 3/10 writing
to be honest- I read this book after watching the movie. I had heard of it from its popularity but avoided after Hoover was cancelled for making light of its serious contents. And one last disclaimer: I have no personal experience with domestic violence.
So yes, the book was not as meaningful and affirming for me as it was for others, but I do think that it can be a valuable read for those who have connections to DV. I sincerely appreciate the look Hoover gives us into cycle breakers and DV relationships and the genuine love that is often there.
Until part 2, I thought the the movie was more impactful as it had been thoughtfully edited and cut out some scenes that weren't crucial to the story line. However, part 2 is where the book shines, perhaps because it is where Hoover becomes concise, and her words hold more power. Part 2 puts you in the shoes of the DV victim and abuser, showing you the love that can exist in the relationship despite the abuse. It shows the internal struggle and strength of women who leave, and even the (rightful, deserved) suffering of the abusers as they realized that they've hurt the people they love most.
Though the second part seems to take on a living form & practically brings you into the story, the first part is poorly done. Not saying that a book with DV themes must be strictly serious, but it needs to be told well because the story deserves it. It was written like a lighthearted romance summer read with a sprinkle of seriousness- small details such as character names and dialogue diminished the seriousness with which readers may take the story, making it seem outlandish rather than the reality for many.
to be honest- I read this book after watching the movie. I had heard of it from its popularity but avoided after Hoover was cancelled for making light of its serious contents. And one last disclaimer: I have no personal experience with domestic violence.
So yes, the book was not as meaningful and affirming for me as it was for others, but I do think that it can be a valuable read for those who have connections to DV. I sincerely appreciate the look Hoover gives us into cycle breakers and DV relationships and the genuine love that is often there.
Until part 2, I thought the the movie was more impactful as it had been thoughtfully edited and cut out some scenes that weren't crucial to the story line. However, part 2 is where the book shines, perhaps because it is where Hoover becomes concise, and her words hold more power. Part 2 puts you in the shoes of the DV victim and abuser, showing you the love that can exist in the relationship despite the abuse. It shows the internal struggle and strength of women who leave, and even the (rightful, deserved) suffering of the abusers as they realized that they've hurt the people they love most.
Though the second part seems to take on a living form & practically brings you into the story, the first part is poorly done. Not saying that a book with DV themes must be strictly serious, but it needs to be told well because the story deserves it. It was written like a lighthearted romance summer read with a sprinkle of seriousness- small details such as character names and dialogue diminished the seriousness with which readers may take the story, making it seem outlandish rather than the reality for many.