ciffee 's review for:

A Question of Holmes by Brittany Cavallaro
2.0

The ending, while open-ended, was just a bit too melancholy for me. Their relationship still seems very toxic to me: with Jamie always giving everything up and doing anything to follow Charlotte, even after she abandons him again and again. I enjoyed this series immensely, but I just wish Jamie was given time to heal and get past all the trauma he's suffered (maybe he had, but I don't believe we were adequately shown this), like Charlotte did. They both deserved better parental figures and role models.