Scan barcode
A review by writingqueerfic
Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda by Becky Albertalli
emotional
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.5
I first read this book the year after release, about eight years ago now, and then I rated it a three star read. Upon my re-read, I'm a bit disappointed and have decided to lower it to a 2.5.
Maybe it was the mystery that held me so tightly the first time around, the thrill of trying to figure out who Blue could be. Without the wonder, it seemed like the narrative was lacking. There wasn't much to get excited about, but spotting the many many pop culture references.
Of course, as before, Simon is a relatable, if somewhat annoying, lead. We get to know him first through email and learn of his secret pen pal, whom he's in love with. The author does a great job of capturing the experience of having your first love and the feelings that come with it.
Blue, Simon's secret, is authetic enough to believe as a love interest and doesn't intrude on the overall narrative. I enjoy his and Simon's exchange of emails every few chapters, we get to learn about him in small doses, almost as if we are living the romances. Do I believe that he would have the confidence to post about his sexuality on a gossip page though, not really. There's a bit of a contrast of him being super shy but yet forthcoming.
Simon's three friends, i have a mixed bag of emotions about them.
Abby: She is a 10/10 character, loved every scene she was in. Her energy and her humour stole many scenes, and even when she was in conflict, she was level-headed.
Nick: Meh. He was just there most of the time, a plot device for conflict. Do I understand why so many people would like him? No.
Leah: I know some people love her, but I couldn't stand her attitude. I understand her being hurt for some of the decisions made, but let's not pretend that she didn't bring those upon herself with her endless angst.
When Simon met Blue, I wish that this was the end of the narrative, or maybe after their first date. The making up with Leah should have been moved forward, and the email from Marton didn't need to happen...feck him.
I understand there's a squeal, one I'm not interested in reading, but it seemed like the last few chapters were shoehorned in just to facilitate this.
So overall, I enjoyed Simon and Blue's love story, yet it holds none of the same whimsy it seemed to harber when I first read it. Maybe it's an age thing.
Maybe it was the mystery that held me so tightly the first time around, the thrill of trying to figure out who Blue could be. Without the wonder, it seemed like the narrative was lacking. There wasn't much to get excited about, but spotting the many many pop culture references.
Of course, as before, Simon is a relatable, if somewhat annoying, lead. We get to know him first through email and learn of his secret pen pal, whom he's in love with. The author does a great job of capturing the experience of having your first love and the feelings that come with it.
Blue, Simon's secret, is authetic enough to believe as a love interest and doesn't intrude on the overall narrative. I enjoy his and Simon's exchange of emails every few chapters, we get to learn about him in small doses, almost as if we are living the romances. Do I believe that he would have the confidence to post about his sexuality on a gossip page though, not really. There's a bit of a contrast of him being super shy but yet forthcoming.
Simon's three friends, i have a mixed bag of emotions about them.
Abby: She is a 10/10 character, loved every scene she was in. Her energy and her humour stole many scenes, and even when she was in conflict, she was level-headed.
Nick: Meh. He was just there most of the time, a plot device for conflict. Do I understand why so many people would like him? No.
Leah: I know some people love her, but I couldn't stand her attitude. I understand her being hurt for some of the decisions made, but let's not pretend that she didn't bring those upon herself with her endless angst.
When Simon met Blue, I wish that this was the end of the narrative, or maybe after their first date. The making up with Leah should have been moved forward, and the email from Marton didn't need to happen...feck him.
I understand there's a squeal, one I'm not interested in reading, but it seemed like the last few chapters were shoehorned in just to facilitate this.
So overall, I enjoyed Simon and Blue's love story, yet it holds none of the same whimsy it seemed to harber when I first read it. Maybe it's an age thing.