A review by alliereads_
Yerba Buena by Nina LaCour

emotional

2.0

I really wanted to like this book, knowing how popular it was and that it featured a lesbian romance, but I was let down. The plot takes off way too fast; we have no connection to these characters or understanding of why they make the choices they make. I don't empathize over her mother's death, I don't connect to her love for Annie, I don't understand the significance of Sara's relationship with her father, I don't feel the betrayal by Eugene, I don't get why she left so suddenly, abandoning her brother, to go off with a boy she doesn't know or why she suddenly agreed to prostitute herself to support them. It is the definition of telling, not showing. Unfortunately, this never changes. Yerba Buena feels disjointed; less like a cohesive novel and more like a series of vignettes (some of which are quite enjoyable!). Any progress feels swiftly undone from one chapter to the next. I just was never truly able to care about any of the characters or their relationships as a whole.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings