Scan barcode
A review by just_fighting_censorship
Doctor Who: Series III, Vol. 1: Hypothetical Gentleman by Philip Bond, Mark Buckingham, Andy Diggle, Brandon Seifert
3.0
Okay so this could have been so much better! The first story, “The Hypothetical Gentleman” felt completely unfinished* and the second story, “The Doctor and The Nurse” was just meh, it went for the comical route over the science fiction awesome adventure route. Both stories suffered from some pretty terrible artwork.
The first story was turning out to be amazingly awesome and then it ended VERY abruptly with no resolution whatsoever. It was like the writer didn’t know where they were going, got lost, and just gave up.
The second story was very cartoonish in both plot and appearance, it didn’t really work for me, something was missing it just came off like cheesy fanfiction.
*2/18/14
The "Hypothetical Gentleman storyline is completely ignored in the second volume and then randomly returns in [b:Doctor Who Series 3 Volume 3: Sky Jacks|18128207|Doctor Who Series 3 Volume 3 Sky Jacks|Andy Diggle|https://d202m5krfqbpi5.cloudfront.net/books/1385993969s/18128207.jpg|25462433]
The first story was turning out to be amazingly awesome and then it ended VERY abruptly with no resolution whatsoever. It was like the writer didn’t know where they were going, got lost, and just gave up.
The second story was very cartoonish in both plot and appearance, it didn’t really work for me, something was missing it just came off like cheesy fanfiction.
*2/18/14
The "Hypothetical Gentleman storyline is completely ignored in the second volume and then randomly returns in [b:Doctor Who Series 3 Volume 3: Sky Jacks|18128207|Doctor Who Series 3 Volume 3 Sky Jacks|Andy Diggle|https://d202m5krfqbpi5.cloudfront.net/books/1385993969s/18128207.jpg|25462433]