A review by phyllica_reads
Hunter's Don't Cry: Extended Version by Eli Blake

adventurous emotional hopeful sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.5

* 4.5 Stars * 

Before you even look at the page count and let the thickness deter you away, give this book a chance. 
I devoured Hunters Don't Cry in one day and have zero regrets. Ensnared from the very beginning, I didn't put this book down for any other reason than I had to work and feed myself. 

Characters: The characters and their heartbreaking story are the main reason why I loved this book so much. Truly. The MCs and even the side characters propelled this story forward in a way that I felt as if I blinked and every page had been obliterated. 
Being queer, I found myself relating to Collen's journey the entire time. All he wanted was to be loved by the one person who captivated him from the very beginning and consumed his heart. He wasn't deterred by the consequences of his actions or his feelings, he simply wanted to be chosen. 
Logan stole my attention for a whole different reason. His constant mental battle with emotions and feelings stemmed from unrelenting pressures threatening to destroy him. He allowed fear to drive quite a few of his actions and decisions. However, even with a long journey of progression ahead, I will go as far as to say he went through the most change as the story unfolded. It might not have been my preferred outcome, but I know there is something big waiting around the corner. I look forward to what awaits him in the sequel.

Spice: *gasp* Yes, this is an MM Romance story with spicy, and a fair amount considering this is the extended steamy edition. I don't prefer to rate spice in books, however, I will say that the spice in this version is strategically placed and very descriptive. The scenes are enjoyable to read and not overly done. 

Worldbuilding/backstory: Unfortunately this is where my rating started to dip. The author provides a great deal of context clues to figure out a portion of the world, but I also felt as if I was supposed to read a prequel before diving into this chunky story. Throughout my reading, I kept referring back to notes that I had taken of details I knew would be important later on. I asked myself, "Why" a few times when attempting to wrap my head around things. 
This didn't create any type of negative opinion about the story, just a part of the book that lacked a bit. The main plotline stole my attention and focus enough that I still loved my experience with Hunters Don't Cry.

Overall, I was captivated by this story and do recommend it to those looking for an MM romance filled with heartbreak, strong emotions, a bit of violence, and a supernatural spin. I will be reading more from this author in the future.

Highlights/Tropes To Expect:
Single 1st POV
Protect each other at any cost
MM Romance with spice
Supernatural hunters
Angst
Homophobic society
Closet Sexuality
Mild Violence