Scan barcode
A review by narcissia
Forbidden by Tabitha Suzuma
4.0
Forbidden deals with the taboo subject of incest, and challenges normality and the boundaries of love. I was not sure going into this book if I would be able to finish it because the subject grosses me out. I'd read a multitude of glowing reviews about it though, and part of me just really wanted to see what all of the fuss was about.
The POV switches between the characters of Maya and Lochan, who are sympathetic enough. Maya is a fairly normal girl. She is pretty and friendly and attempts to remain cheerful and to keep things running smoothly. Lochan is handsome and smart, but struggles with social phobias and anxiety disorder at school. The only place he is comfortable is at home with his family. Their father has left them and their mother is a drunk and is rarely around, opting instead to cling to the guy she is seeing and leave her kids to fend for themselves. So Maya and Lochan end up being the parental figures to the three younger siblings, Kit, Tiffin, and Willa. They do their best to run the household and keep up with schoolwork, doing everything they can to prevent child services from being alerted to their situation since that would most likely split up the family.
I don't know if I can buy completely into the relationship development of Lochan and Maya. Yeah, they've been like best friends all their lives, and they help raise their siblings as if they're the parents, and they are each other's support system, and nobody else understands what they go through except for each other. But as someone who has brothers, none of this could in any way ever push me toward incest, so I have a difficult time finding their relationship believable or the catalysts for it convincing enough. It just never feels justifiable to me at any point in the story. But, to be fair, I don't think there is anything that could have made it feel natural to me, so I wasn't really going into it expecting the brother/sister boundary to be erased for me. It seems like a lot of people really bought into this relationship and cheered it on, and I wonder if those people have siblings.
While I could never get behind their relationship, I do appreciate the way in which they struggle with coming to terms with their feelings for each other. The ugliness of it all isn't shied away from, and I can respect that. They aren't really comfortable with their love, either. They wonder if they're sick, if their upbringing has caused them severe psychological issues that have prompted these feelings. They torture themselves over it. And they're not naive about the consequences of anyone finding out about them. They know that acting on their love is a criminal offense, and that they could be arrested and the family torn apart. And this tortures them as well. They attempt to date normally, to stay away from each other.
This book does not have a happy ending. The synopsis says as much. It's tragic, and it really puts the story in perspective for me. While I was never comfortable with their relationship, I do feel that the consequences which they suffer are not something that they deserve, that perhaps they are disproportionate to the crime. This feeling that they don't deserve the ending that they get is what, in the end, made me finally question if their love is really so terrible. Because of that, I'd consider this book a success.
I'd recommend Forbidden to anyone looking for a book with a controversial subject, or who is interested in taboo and/or tough topics. The subject matter is handled probably as well as something like incest can be handled. There are some scenes in the book which are sexually (very) graphic, for those who wish to avoid such things.
The POV switches between the characters of Maya and Lochan, who are sympathetic enough. Maya is a fairly normal girl. She is pretty and friendly and attempts to remain cheerful and to keep things running smoothly. Lochan is handsome and smart, but struggles with social phobias and anxiety disorder at school. The only place he is comfortable is at home with his family. Their father has left them and their mother is a drunk and is rarely around, opting instead to cling to the guy she is seeing and leave her kids to fend for themselves. So Maya and Lochan end up being the parental figures to the three younger siblings, Kit, Tiffin, and Willa. They do their best to run the household and keep up with schoolwork, doing everything they can to prevent child services from being alerted to their situation since that would most likely split up the family.
I don't know if I can buy completely into the relationship development of Lochan and Maya. Yeah, they've been like best friends all their lives, and they help raise their siblings as if they're the parents, and they are each other's support system, and nobody else understands what they go through except for each other. But as someone who has brothers, none of this could in any way ever push me toward incest, so I have a difficult time finding their relationship believable or the catalysts for it convincing enough. It just never feels justifiable to me at any point in the story. But, to be fair, I don't think there is anything that could have made it feel natural to me, so I wasn't really going into it expecting the brother/sister boundary to be erased for me. It seems like a lot of people really bought into this relationship and cheered it on, and I wonder if those people have siblings.
While I could never get behind their relationship, I do appreciate the way in which they struggle with coming to terms with their feelings for each other. The ugliness of it all isn't shied away from, and I can respect that. They aren't really comfortable with their love, either. They wonder if they're sick, if their upbringing has caused them severe psychological issues that have prompted these feelings. They torture themselves over it. And they're not naive about the consequences of anyone finding out about them. They know that acting on their love is a criminal offense, and that they could be arrested and the family torn apart. And this tortures them as well. They attempt to date normally, to stay away from each other.
This book does not have a happy ending. The synopsis says as much. It's tragic, and it really puts the story in perspective for me. While I was never comfortable with their relationship, I do feel that the consequences which they suffer are not something that they deserve, that perhaps they are disproportionate to the crime. This feeling that they don't deserve the ending that they get is what, in the end, made me finally question if their love is really so terrible. Because of that, I'd consider this book a success.
I'd recommend Forbidden to anyone looking for a book with a controversial subject, or who is interested in taboo and/or tough topics. The subject matter is handled probably as well as something like incest can be handled. There are some scenes in the book which are sexually (very) graphic, for those who wish to avoid such things.