A review by kerishma
Bluebeard's Castle by Anna Biller

Did not finish book. Stopped at 16%.
I just couldn't finish this. I got about a fifth of the way through and just had to put it down. I'm sorry to say that the writing feels a bit amateurish—it's all telling and no showing. The prose feels straight out of online fanfiction, which is not in itself a bad thing (I was raised on FanFiction.net, Livejournal, and Quizilla!), but when Gavin's eyes are non-ironically described as "orbs" I had to put the book down and close my own orbs. It doesn't help that Judith, the protagonist, is both dull and irritating (it's entirely possible that she undergoes a dramatic character change in beyond what I read, but I don't know that I would count on that). It's clear that Biller loves the Gothic horror and pulp romance genres, but every cultural reference is so painstakingly spelled out to the readers that it feels like she didn't know how to weave in those references more organically. It didn't feel polished enough to be "serious" (for lack of a better term) fiction, nor was it sufficiently exaggerated or sensational enough to call it camp.

Still, I would love to see how Biller would adapt this to film. I think she's one of the few filmmakers today who really understands how to use visual aesthetics to tell a dimensional and engrossing story—in her films, style is a huge part of substance, which isn't easy to do successfully. Here's hoping!
Expand filter menu Content Warnings